Tyler
03.12.08 | I never saw why anyone likes 4, let alone considered it a classic. Porcupine Tree has always struck me as the pinnacle of mediocrity and Steven Wilson is a top contender for the most ordinary vocalist ever award |
Altmer
03.12.08 | To me, it's emotion, really. But I guess if an album doesn't do that for you, you won't see why I like it so much. I empathise heavily with the album's themes and lyrics as well as liking the music. It's not technical really, but I just really like what he's playing and how he plays it emotionally. |
WarAllTheTime988
03.12.08 | I truly respect everyones taste and realize everyones got different opinions, but I do tend to agree with Cocaine. My friend tried to get me into Porcupine Tree because I do enjoy prog and it just wasn't happening. I really either don't see what everyone else does or am just missing something...? 1,2, and 7 are all fantastic though! |
BallsToTheWall
03.12.08 | I'm pretty sure i've listened to 1 before but other than that and 2 which I can't get into I haven't heard a full album from these. I'm bound to check out 6,8, and 9 eventually. |
Chewie
03.12.08 | im pretty dissapointed not to see the Downward Spiral here, it is more of a classic then 8-10 |
Altmer
03.12.08 | I had to cut out a lot of albums that I love for this. Nine Inch Nails - Downward Spiral is indeed an album that's also emotionally very, very inspiring. Hurt and A Warm Place are two of my alltime favourite songs. |
Electric City
03.12.08 | I can agree with 1 and 2. |
TheGreatD17
03.12.08 | some excellent music here, I'm kind of surprised to see 5 though |
foreverendeared
03.12.08 | i agree with most of these. i've never listened to 4 or 8 though and i wouldnt really consider 7 on my top 30 list, let alone top 10 |
Metalikane
03.12.08 | 10 is waaay underrated. Probably my favorite of theirs. |
Chewie
03.12.08 | this could also use Master of Puppets, |
VicariousIntent
03.12.08 | Now this is a list. I can't even give you enough props for Thirteenth Step, it's my favorite album of all time and yes, a true classic. Really well done list. |
combustion07
03.13.08 | 1,4,7, and 10 ftw. |
Two-Headed Boy
03.13.08 | 1 and 2 for sure, 4, 5, and 7 ehhhhh not quite.
Haven't heard others but want to hear 10. |
Jim
03.13.08 | some awesome shit here |
Dis_Con_Nec_Ted
03.13.08 | 2-5 and 7 rule |
