frigyourgenre
08.31.13 | fitchdork |
BigPleb
08.31.13 | Well they were right about 4 and 5. |
treeqt.
08.31.13 | ya they rated 4 too high |
Artuma
08.31.13 | well it's pitchfork
shut up leb :] |
StallionMang
08.31.13 | All 5 TMV albums. |
BigPleb
08.31.13 | Hey, I'm just trying to enlighten you guys :D |
YoYoMancuso
08.31.13 | 2 is a sick album, love it |
Artuma
08.31.13 | you can't enlighten me when it's about one of my most important albums :P |
Cipieron
08.31.13 | sounds like they nailed 5 |
JazzHands333
08.31.13 | Taking Pitchfork seriously was your first mistake. But yeah, fuck Tool |
IbenizGEO1
08.31.13 | Taking Pitchfork seriously was your first mistake But yeah, fuck Tool [2] |
ILJ
08.31.13 | actually i think they nailed the gojira score. album is boring.
|
BigPleb
08.31.13 | Me and six agreeing omg. |
oltnabrick
08.31.13 | http://pitchfork.com/reviews/albums/16414-lil-b-gods-father/
XD |
oltnabrick
08.31.13 | I think its higher than an 8 but still im suprised |
DrHouseSchuldiner
08.31.13 | 2 is pretty boring tbh |
Keyblade
08.31.13 | Just 5? |
slagun
08.31.13 | 3 seems about right |
MyNameIsPencil
08.31.13 | 4's rating is right at least
but yeah 5's rating is ungodly low |
Keyblade
08.31.13 | 3 is the best album on this list |
oltnabrick
08.31.13 | 3 is like a 7.5 at least lol |
Sapient.
08.31.13 | 5 may be Tool's most overrated work, but it definitely doesn't deserve that rating |
chemicalmarriage
08.31.13 | 5 is a 5 |
Cygnatti
08.31.13 | 5 rocks. But hey, at least their mars Volta ratings are correct. |
Parallels
08.31.13 | 1.9 is a bit too low obviously, but I agree that Tool after Aenima just isn't the same. |
neurisis17
08.31.13 | Have the guys voicing their dislike for Tool perhaps been studying the "Guide to Metal Elitism"? |
Parallels
08.31.13 | What? I fucking love Tool. |
slep
08.31.13 | pitchfork's gotten a lot wrong man |
neurisis17
08.31.13 | also I'm not taking the site seriously at all, I'm just pointing out ratings that I think are comically low. Because, like a few users on this site, the seem to have a healthy distaste for popular metal oriented acts (except Isis and Neurosis, but they would be objectively wrong by poorly rating those bands). |
neurisis17
08.31.13 | not you parallels, however I am in the camp believing Tool has gotten better after each release. |
neurisis17
08.31.13 | haha exactly sixdegrees
|
neurisis17
08.31.13 | (kinda wish I would've put more thought into my username though) |
laughingman22
08.31.13 | pitchfork gave relayer a 5.3 and 90125 a 7.8. wut
|
Spec
08.31.13 | lateralus a 1.9? |
PistolPete
08.31.13 | they gave Jane Doe a 7.7 and all their other albums since have been rated higher
TRAVESTY!!!! |
wacknizzle
08.31.13 | God's Father got rated better than Jane Doe lol, shits tarded |
Dolving999
08.31.13 | I can't even hear the word "Pitchfork" since I saw a picture of Emmure members wearing their hats. |
Sleaper
08.31.13 | if your going to pitchfork expecting metal reviews, you are delusional.
its like being pissed off that XXL magazine didnt rate a punk album highly |
MoosechriS
08.31.13 | yeah, like this site doesn't have albums that are over or underrated...... |
apert
08.31.13 | Pitchfork get barely any ratings right. you'd struggle to find 5 rating pitchfork got right |
Spag
08.31.13 | it's cool to hate Tool I guess. damn shame |
NordicMindset
08.31.13 | 4 is generally right, but yea rating 5 that low is a piece of dogshit.
plus they gave old Rise Against (Siren Song) a 2.9 |
Acrosstheshield13
08.31.13 | damn hipsters.. |
Greem
09.01.13 | 5 is all right |
Keyblade
09.01.13 | Don't like a certain band? Elitist! Hipster! |
Spag
09.01.13 | damn hamsters |
IbenizGEO1
09.01.13 | hahaha calling me a metal elitist is like calling a sixth grader in a pre-algebra class an astro physicist. |
slimdaddy
09.03.13 | 4 is such a damn good album. |
guitarded_chuck
09.03.13 | Pitchfork is fucking terrible. Sputnik >>>>> Pitchform. It's a crying shame that we don't get half the traffic. |
Mr_Coffee
09.03.13 | i'm sorry, but tool sucks |
NeroCorleone80
09.03.13 | lol sure |
MrElmo
09.03.13 | You forgot Future of the Left's The Plot Against Common Sense and Greymachine's Disconnected |
MrElmo
09.03.13 | Also if you read the Lateralus review, what's being said (wich is mostly an odd and overlong fanboyish babble) doesn't match with the rating. |
oltnabrick
09.09.13 | FUK IS THIS |
BallsToTheWall
09.09.13 | Lil B > Tool |
Chesse
09.09.13 | Their gospel review yo |
oltnabrick
09.09.13 | Lil B > Tool [2] |
ButcherNate
09.23.13 | why all the tool hate? if you really dont like Lateralus you might be dumb |
demigod!
09.23.13 | their "reviews" for relationship of command and the fragile were fucking stupid |
zakalwe
09.23.13 | "why all the tool hate? if you really dont like Lateralus you might be dumb"
I'll live with being dumb, I'd rather kill myself than have to listen to a Tool album from beginning to end |
wabbit
09.23.13 | tool is something people who are starting to have good taste in music but still have bad taste in music like.
that Om album is incredible though |
IbenizGEO1
09.23.13 | "I'll live with being dumb, I'd rather kill myself than have to listen to a Tool album from beginning to end"
I'd probably listen to the tool album honestly
|
EaglesBecomeVultures
09.23.13 | tool sucks bro |
wabbit
09.23.13 | we probably have too much flouride from brushing our teeth that our third eye's are closed so we can't properly acknowledge how ~transcendent~ tool is man |
sncold
09.24.13 | They gave Murder by Death's In Bocca al Lupo like a 6 something I think. It's not their best work, but damn is that way too low. |
