BigPleb: Thursday = Prog

BigPleb 04.25.13	Say yes to prog p/
ButteryBiscuitBass 04.25.13	List made me cum.
ButteryBiscuitBass 04.25.13	I'll drive up to Liverpool and rape you if you carry this on, Leb.
BigPleb 04.25.13	Was hard to publish, too much prog pumpin through ma veins.
Keyblade 04.25.13	no camel. I am sad
ButteryBiscuitBass 04.25.13	Buzzing so much that 10 is here - one of my favourite KC albums.
DegausserGuernica24 04.25.13	If Thursday goes prog, I'm going to shit myself with happiness.
BigPleb 04.25.13	Its from the big 4 only Key, but I will try to squeeze in some Mirage.
Keyblade 04.25.13	had no idea there was a big 4. I'd have camel in my big 4, and in my big 1 for that matter
JamieTwort 04.25.13	List rules.
blairosh 04.25.13	No Gentle Giant = disappointing.
BigPleb 04.25.13	Ye there was man, a lot of people think Yes should be replaced by Camel. @blairosh Read the descrip.
JamieTwort 04.25.13	Jethro Tull should be in the big 4.
BigPleb 04.25.13	There's too many awesome 70's prog outfits for their to be a Big 4.
ButteryBiscuitBass 04.25.13	Replacing who, Jamie?
Keyblade 04.25.13	"Ye there was man, a lot of people think Yes should be replaced by Camel. @blairosh Read the descrip." I am also of this school of thought
JamieTwort 04.25.13	@Buttery: Probably Yes. But I prefer Tull over all of these so it's hard to say.
BigPleb 04.25.13	Probs right man.
ButteryBiscuitBass 04.25.13	It's such a tough call. I'd have Gentle Giant over Tull, but admittedly, I need to check more Tull.
BigPleb 04.25.13	Floyd are in a different league imo, but whatever.
JamieTwort 04.25.13	Tull Floyd Genesis KC ^my big 4 ranked. Floyd and Genesis are interchangeable.
BigPleb 04.25.13	Floyd Genesis Camel KC
ButteryBiscuitBass 04.25.13	King Crimson Genesis Floyd Gentle Giant Mine.
JamieTwort 04.25.13	The lack of Tull makes me sad.
BigPleb 04.25.13	I've only just recently started listening to Tull, been infatuated with Floyd for as long as I can remember. Love you regardless, JT < 3
ButteryBiscuitBass 04.25.13	Sorry Jamie xxx
Keyblade 04.25.13	Camel Genesis Yes Floyd
BigPleb 04.25.13	Floyd that low? Hot diggity damn.
ButteryBiscuitBass 04.25.13	I dig Floyd so hard, but I feel that their not as strong when it comes to technical musicianship as the other hardcore prog bands. Their still amazing though.
BigPleb 04.25.13	Well no other prog rock band have released better albums than Animals and WYWH, just saying.
Butkuiss 04.25.13	No Devolucion was pretty proggy guys.
ButteryBiscuitBass 04.25.13	@Leb - Mirage.
BigPleb 04.25.13	No way haha, but opinions.
ButteryBiscuitBass 04.25.13	;-)
NeroCorleone80 04.25.13	Yes Camel Tull Floyd
BigPleb 04.25.13	Fuck all of this low ranking Floyd bullshit, its making me ill.
ButteryBiscuitBass 04.25.13	Floyd King Crimson Genesis Gentle Giant There you go, Lebbo.
BigPleb 04.25.13	But you don't mean it :/
ButteryBiscuitBass 04.25.13	Embrace the moment.
BigPleb 04.25.13	Its gone.
ButteryBiscuitBass 04.25.13	Do you dig Piper At The Gates Of Dawn?
blairosh 04.25.13	Sorry to drop a clanger guys, but in the scheme of good prog rock bands, Floyd are massively overrated (Animals aside). My top 5 prog bands: 1) Genesis (Peter Gabriel-era) 2) Gentle Giant 3) Rush 4) King Crimson 5) The Mars Volta Probably pretty divisive but whatevs. Yes and Tull have produced some absolute classics (particular Tull, with Aqualung and Thick As A Brick) but their output in general has been pretty patchy.
BigPleb 04.25.13	Wow, you lie.
ButteryBiscuitBass 04.25.13	The Mars Volta in the top five is an outrageous joke. Amputecture is a master piece, agreed, but that's it. 3 out of 6 albums are 4 - 5s.
BigPleb 04.25.13	Bringing TMV into a classic prog thread is dumb.
Artuma 04.25.13	fuck yeah, just started to jam Aqualung good prog day is today
blairosh 04.25.13	Note that I didn't say "top 5 classic prog bands". If that's all you're looking for (and why should it be?) then replace TMV with Camel. Also, there's a load more classic prog bands you could mention (Van Der Graaf Generator, Caravan) - prog lists with loads of Floyd are boring. BBB: Amputecture isn't even the best TMV album.
ButteryBiscuitBass 04.25.13	Blair -Yes it is.
ButteryBiscuitBass 04.25.13	It has zero filler, unlike the first two.
Artuma 04.25.13	"prog lists with loads of Floyd are boring" dunno what to say
blairosh 04.25.13	Thomas (or bloke from Masterchef) - the quality control on that album is massively inconsistent. They have never topped DITC, although FTM gives it a good run for its money. Even TBIG is better than Amputecture. Artuma - Floyd is a good prog band BUT there are far better prog albums out there (in my opinion).
ButteryBiscuitBass 04.25.13	I disagree. In my opinion every song off Amputechture show the best of Omar without his wankyness. DITC has too much wanky parts on it - the middle of Cicatriz ESP for example. And same with FTM. First half of TBIG is gold, then is drops.
Artuma 04.25.13	all the floyd albums here are better than any TMV album imo but then again they are hardly even comparable bands
manosg 04.25.13	Great list.
JamieTwort 04.25.13	all the floyd albums here are better than any TMV album [2] You could delete the word floyd and this statement would still be true.
ButteryBiscuitBass 04.25.13	all the floyd albums here are better than any TMV album [3] You could delete the word floyd and this statement would still be true. [2]
Artuma 04.25.13	pretty much yeah Jamie :D
blairosh 04.25.13	Must remember not to feed the Pink Floyd fanclub trolls next time...