Japandi
Decorative Duck


4.0
excellent

Review

by batuhan altinbas USER (37 Reviews)
December 31st, 2012 | 10 replies


Release Date: 2010 | Tracklist

Review Summary: Minimalist math rock

Japandi has always been a hit-or-miss band for the little circle of math-rock-listening friends I have around me. Some are into the genre solely to hear the upfront, in your face, light-speed instrumental masturbation of genre greats such as Tera Melos and Six Gallery. For those kinds of people, Japandi will likely be a disappointment. While quite a few bands in the math scene run on blistering fast and loud instrumental work, Japandi takes the opposite approach. They ditch the effects-layered sonic assault approach and instead opt for a brand of heavily stripped down math rock that breaks many stereotypes of the genre.

Decorative Duck was the first release I heard from these guys, and the experience was rather jolting at first; where are the sounds? The flamboyantly oscillating arpeggiations? The pop sensibility that I craved? Upon first listen, it was clear that Japandi doesn’t play that game. The number of loud instrumental interludes I can count on one hand. Their most prominent strong point is the simplicity of their sound. As a character in a Louis Sachar novel aptly put it, (and I’ll paraphrase) “music needs blank spaces.” There are actually many minuscule blank spaces throughout each song where the instruments stop playing entirely, only to resume half a second later.

But make no mistake, if you pick this album up, you’re not being cheated out of your hard-earned or perhaps stolen money; you’re not just buying blank spaces. Guitarists George Pritzker and Jeff Striker weave together playful, delicate, and intricate melodies along with bassist (and sometimes guitarist) Andy Seymour, as Marc Deriso provides a mellow backbone with subdued but creative drumming. Production and songwriting are bare-bones; nothing self-indulgent or unnecessarily convoluted is done, but that’s perfect because that’s exactly what Japandi strives to accomplish.

As the name of the EP may suggest, Decorative Duck is but simple ornamentation on the expansive genre of math rock. By no means does it redefine the genre or showcase prodigal levels of instrumental proficiency, but to dismiss it based on that is superficial and premature. The complexity, the dynamism, the sophistication, it’s all there, but Japandi chooses to present it all in a significantly less obvious way. Listeners must delve deeper into the music to appreciate it fully. The result, while initially seeming lackluster, actually turns out to be quite refreshing, a welcome respite in a scene where sounds are fired off like assault weapons.

Japandi’s serene and simple presentation provides a return to roots of sorts, and serves as a reminder to us all that there is more to math rock than just boisterous instrumental debauchery.

Personal standout track: “The Rite of Springsteen”



Recent reviews by this author
A Lot Like Birds DIVISIHow to Dress Well What Is This Heart?
Lana Del Rey UltraviolenceThe Amity Affliction Let the Ocean Take Me
Closure in Moscow Pink LemonadeAdestria Gilded Hearts
user ratings (31)
4.1
excellent


Comments:Add a Comment 
Azn.
December 31st 2012


5632 Comments

Album Rating: 4.0

I really enjoyed writing this review, tell me what you think!

Propose
December 31st 2012


959 Comments


sounds cool pos

Leatherneck
December 31st 2012


689 Comments


i don't know why but i supossed it was math rock from the band name

GnarlyShillelagh
Emeritus
December 31st 2012


6385 Comments


I thought it was Japandroids changing the names of everything

Azn.
January 1st 2013


5632 Comments

Album Rating: 4.0

thx d00ds



Something about the very essense of math rock is embedded inside band names, I have no idea why.

DeadbeatDankity
January 20th 2013


149 Comments

Album Rating: 5.0

BEST MATH ROCK RELEASE EVER EVER EVER EVER EVER EVER EVER

Azn.
January 23rd 2013


5632 Comments

Album Rating: 4.0

ok that's a bit of a stretch

Gnocchi
Staff Reviewer
March 12th 2013


18256 Comments


Here we go dude.

where are the SOUNDS?


Un-capitilise, none of the other rhetorical questions in that paragraph are presented the same way. It looks ugly in your review and the emphasis becomes lost as soon as the reader moves to the next series of questions.

The number of loud instrumental interludes I can count on one hand.


Fragment.

The flamboyantly


Remove the "ly". It wrecks your flow.

math rock that breaks many stereotypes of the genre.


Wording issues, this could be re-vised. My example:
...using an incredibly stribbed down brand of math rock which breaks away from the usual stereotypes of the genre...


Stretching out your opinions, making sure you have the wording right really helps put across your thoughts.

I like your next two paragraphs, but maybe describe the production and how it helps i.e. Polished, raw, recorded in a tin can, million dollar, self made, et cetera.

Japandi’s serene and simple presentation provides a return to roots of sorts, and serves as a reminder to us all that there is more to math rock than just boisterous instrumental debauchery.


One sentence is not a paragraph. Don't be afaid to buff out your ideas and actually add contextual depth.

Personal standout track: “The Rite of Springsteen”


Now, this is a matter of opinion but things like "Highlighted tracks/Reccomended Tracks/Standouts" should be incorporated into your review. Use them as an example for 'Why this record is so good/bad'.

All in all, it's a good review with some good ideas. There's just some things you need to look out for.

Azn.
March 12th 2013


5632 Comments

Album Rating: 4.0

thanks, I'll edit and keep this stuff in mind!

Gnocchi
Staff Reviewer
March 12th 2013


18256 Comments


All good, check out some staff reviews and see how the idea they have are presented.



You have to be logged in to post a comment. Login | Create a Profile





STAFF & CONTRIBUTORS // CONTACT US

Bands: A B C D E F G H I J K L M N O P Q R S T U V W X Y Z


Site Copyright 2005-2023 Sputnikmusic.com
All Album Reviews Displayed With Permission of Authors | Terms of Use | Privacy Policy