The Old Firm Casuals
This Means War


2.5
average

Review

by tancrni USER (20 Reviews)
September 15th, 2014 | 8 replies


Release Date: 2014 | Tracklist

Review Summary: The definition of averageness.

The Old Firm Casuals is the latest almost-unknown side project of Rancid’s lead guitarist Lars Frederiksen. With that said, one would expect any effort from a band like this to be at least slightly interesting. The sad truth is that it really isn’t.
The album is weak and repetitive, consisting of average, too catchy and in some way “melodic” Oi!/Street Punk tracks such as Perry Boys, which was meant to be the centrepiece of the entire work, instead it just represents the lack of creativity and imagination Rancid, and as a result his guitarist, is going through.
In 2009 the band who was back in the Nineties the symbol of punk revival released possibly their worst LP, Let The Dominoes Fall, and after five years I’ve still got the feeling that the next album will not be a lot better, considering this OFC’s album and the single Rancid launched some months ago.

The tracks are not bad, but they sound all the same and the arrengement is neat but poor and scarceful.
You won’t believe it, but there’s nothing much more to say about this album, when about these guys I can honestly say that they aren’t even worth it live.
Lars cannot sing as he could twenty years ago: his voice now is so inconsistent you won’t recognise it’s the same which in 1995 performed Roots Radicals.
At least he can still play the guitar, while the other members aren’t really that good at their instruments: the second guitarist is really average and the drummer anonymously impersonal, whereas the bass player is pretty awful. Watching him strumming the bass as it were an acoustic guitar could make even Sid Vicious shiver.

The whole thing, band and album, is just not worth your precious time.
If you were interested in checking this out, you’d better spend your 30 minutes listening to a considerable part of Minor Threat discography or watching an old Top Gear episode.

A disappointing 2.5/5



Recent reviews by this author
Dropkick Murphys 11 Short Stories of Pain and GloryStiu Nu Stiu Ultra Silvam
Gaelic Storm Gaelic StormPink Floyd The Endless River
Rancid Honor Is All We KnowEagles Hotel California
user ratings (5)
3
good


Comments:Add a Comment 
eddie95
September 15th 2014


708 Comments

Album Rating: 2.5

This is my first negative/slightly negative review, so any feedback and criticism is highly appreciated!

Jots
Emeritus
September 15th 2014


7562 Comments


"The definition of averageness."
Kinda weak summary... that'd be like writing a 5/5 review and saying "the definition of perfect". It's just not very attention grabbing

"If you were interested in checking this out, you’d rather spend your 30 minutes listening to a considerable part of Minor Threat discography or watching an old Top Gear episode."
It'd make more sense to say "you're better off checking out..."
I mean, if I was interested in listening to this, then that kinda contradicts me "rather listening to something else... ya know?

Jots
Emeritus
September 15th 2014


7562 Comments


"“solo” guitarist Lars Frederiksen."
I don't get this... He's not the only guitarist in Rancid...

"too catchy"
I didn't know there was such a thing... did you mean that Lars was abandoning his 'punk roots' or something?

Why is Oi/Street Punk in italics?

Too many obvious Rancid comparisons.

Other than those gripes not a bad review. Definitely won't be checking this

eddie95
September 15th 2014


708 Comments

Album Rating: 2.5

Ok, I can explain:



1. "The definition of averageness": I've seen worse summaries, but anyways I think it says it all.

2. You're right. I meant what you say, but put it in a bad and non-comprehensive way. Sorry about that. Will change that

sentence.

3. There is also Tim who plays guitar in Rancid, officially, but you're right saying that practically speaking he's the one: for

"solo guitarist" I meant he's the lead guitarist. I'll change that, too.

4. Too catchy. A catchy song is good because, usually, it's easy to be appreciated. When a song is too catchy it can get

boring. This is what I mean.

5. Oi!/Street Punk is in italics because I thought it could be confusing not to put it like that, I don't think it's a terrible mistake

but I'll change that because it's the genre and not a title or anything like that.

6. Too many obvious Rancid comparisons because it's impossible not to do them, being Lars an established member of

Rancid or just because he's trying to do something different, but without succeeding in doing it.



I'm sorry for any misunderstanding but I'm not a native English speaker, so sometimes I give for granted things that are

obvious in my language without thinking that in another they are not quite so. Thanks for feedback, I will try to improve it.

Jots
Emeritus
September 15th 2014


7562 Comments


thanks for the clarification. I wasn't necessarily saying all your word choices were bad, they were just kinda confusing to read at some points.

yeah I guess the rancid comparisons are probably inevitable

zakalwe
September 15th 2014


38825 Comments


What a fuckin dude you are eddie.
Unlike Lars Friediswhatisname.
Old firm casuals indeed. What a complete tit.

eddie95
September 15th 2014


708 Comments

Album Rating: 2.5

No problem, I'm glad you made me notice some weak parts that from my point of view I couldn't see. It can just improve my writing

eddie95
September 15th 2014


708 Comments

Album Rating: 2.5

@zak I'm not sure what you mean, but I agree that Lars' surname is quite hard to spell lol. I always forget how to write it



You have to be logged in to post a comment. Login | Create a Profile





STAFF & CONTRIBUTORS // CONTACT US

Bands: A B C D E F G H I J K L M N O P Q R S T U V W X Y Z


Site Copyright 2005-2023 Sputnikmusic.com
All Album Reviews Displayed With Permission of Authors | Terms of Use | Privacy Policy