I legit haven't listened to anything by this band except debut so new one was a pleasant surprise

Album Rating: 4.0

i listened to these guys so much in high school. debut will always be their best but id def check out their first ep and their self titled album too

Album Rating: 3.7 | Sound Off

I really expected to see a 1 for A Lesson In Romantics from you after that comment Pika, haha



band kinda lost me on a couple mediocre albums since the departure of Jason but this album and the self titled are great in addition to the new one

Album Rating: 4.0

anywhere but here is the only one i outright dont like but monsters's opening stretch is a goddamn minefield. that album at least makes it up by having some really strong songs in the back end. black lines is pretty different from all the others but ive always thought it was great



perhaps i spoke a bit soon about the new one bc the back half has been a good bit stronger so far. really liked the last 5 songs

Album Rating: 3.5

Definitive:



A Lesson In Romantics > Mayday Parade > What It Means To Fall Apart = Sunnyland >> Black Lines >> Monsters in the Closet >>> Anywhere But Here

Album Rating: 4.0

drop the new one below black lines and put the debut ep behind s/t and i back that

Album Rating: 3.5

As much as I LOVE a few tracks off of black lines, I feel the albums as a whole are stronger when they commit to their true style (debut, S/T, and the 2 recent ones did that). Really glad they at least tried to experiment a little on Black Lines though.

Album Rating: 3.5

Sideways off the new album sounds like it is straight off Boys Like Girls debut album

Ahem:

s/t > ALIR > Black Lines > What It Means = Sunnyland > ABH > Monsters

Ait, I'll check s/t next

Album Rating: 3.5 | Sound Off

feather's rankings are right though I'd probably put Sunnyland over the new one

s/t ruled as well

Album Rating: 4.0

This is like the definition of pretty good pop punk. I just remembered it existed today but it definitely still holds up.