Album Rating: 4.3

Messenger ain't bad but it's very middle-of-the-road for this album I feel. Amedeo nails it on Falling Man and Doll is Mine fo sho

Album Rating: 4.5

It's not that Messenger is awful or anything, it's just like...



This album would probably be a 5/5 if it wasn't on here

Album Rating: 4.0

Oh wow even more than Falling Man and Maddening Cloud?

Album Rating: 4.5

No way, Falling Man is easily his best and like his only one that's in the top 5 on the album honestly

Album Rating: 4.5

Wait lemme rank:



1. Melody 5/5

2. Misery Is a Butterfly 5/5

3. Falling Man 5/5

4. Equus 5/5

5. Elephant Woman 5/5

6. Anticipation 4.5/5

7. Maddening Cloud 4/5

8. Doll Is Mine 4/5

9. Pink Love 4/5

10. Magic Mountain 3.5/5

11. Messenger 3/5

Album Rating: 4.3

Falling Man is a pretty big consensus pick, though I'd take Doll over it some days. I think Maddening Cloud is probs my least favourite, depending how much Magic Mountain hits the spot each listen

Oddly, Anticipation has grown into my favourite. That Maybe it didn't happen / maybe all of this would go away verse is one of the most chilling moments in these guys' discog imo

Kinda digging this one rn but I have a feeling it’s a grower

Album Rating: 4.3

Heh, all of this band's albums are big growers, but this is one that gets the most out of it ;]

Album Rating: 3.0

this album has such an interesting style, somewhere halfway between evanescence and mew. its melodramatic, operatic and emo all at the same time. unfortunately i couldnt get past the vocals, especially the male vocals i found super grating :/

Album Rating: 4.5

The male vocals are worse yeah... but they grew on me

Album Rating: 4.3

"somewhere halfway between evanescence and mew"

whut. and yup blonde redhead in general, and especially the vocals, and especially the male ones, is a slow grower experience

Album Rating: 4.5

I liked the female vocals off the bat



Also "somewhere halfway between evanescence and mew" needs to be a copypasta on here and I normally don't like sput copypastas

Album Rating: 4.3

me too tbh, but it didn't help that I started with Lemons (which probs has the weakest Amedeo tracks of any BR album)

gonna start referring to anything vaguely macabre as evanescencecore from now

sasscore

Album Rating: 4.5

"gonna start referring to anything vaguely macabre as evanescencecore from now"



That Depeche Mode record was total evanescencecore



I feel dirty now Johnny

Album Rating: 3.0

mewvanescence

Album Rating: 5.0 | Sound Off

my rating





1 Elephant Woman 5.00 stars

2 Messenger 5.00 stars

3 Melody 4.50 stars

4 Doll Is Mine 5.00 stars

5 Misery Is a Butterfly 5.00 stars

6 Falling Man 5.00 stars

7 Anticipation 3.50 stars

8 Maddening Cloud 3.00 stars

9 Magic Mountain 5.00 stars

10 Pink Love 5.00 stars

11 Equus





rating each track on https://rateyourmusic.com/~DreamyWitch

Album Rating: 4.5

I really like Messenger, dont get the hate ¯_(ツ)_/¯

Album Rating: 4.3

Messenger is at once the most dispensable and absolutely great in the #2 segue slot. Wouldn't drop it, but it's v much the perfect average of this sound

Also the above list that has Anticipation as the second weakest track here is cursed and I want to nuke it. Most chilling Kazu moment here aside from the opener maybe

nuke it