Album Rating: 2.5

yeah i definitely negged that other one

Album Rating: 3.5

They're fanboys who got offended by the rating probably lol

Album Rating: 1.5

To be fair, I usually don't tell people when I neg reviews, because it opens me up to revenge negs.



I really hate the approval system on this site. It should either be removed, or changed to require someone who negs a review to make a comment.

Album Rating: 2.5

Unless it's a pathetic effort or an obvious troll review, I'll usually try to tell people why I negged. It's just that I take the reviewing game more seriously since I hope to do this professionally and hopefully become a contributor here someday.



"I really hate the approval system on this site. It should either be removed, or changed to require someone who negs a review to make a comment." [22134234] Couldn't agree harder.

maybe someone honestly thought this review wasn't well written

nah it was probably someone who didnt read it and really likes agalloch

but also who the fuck cares

Album Rating: 2.5

"maybe someone honestly thought this review wasn't well written"

-Yeah that's exactly what I was hoping. If people had legitimate concerns it would be nice if they would voice them.



but also who the fuck cares [2]

but also who the fuck cares

Album Rating: 1.5

^ yeah. Silly Judio

Album Rating: 2.5

lol dammit I guess do. Although I only actually care about purposeful negs (if there is a such thing)

and complaints, while troll negs are just really annoying because they always make me wonder if there

was something actually wrong with my writing.

Album Rating: 2.5

Well I went through and edited up my review, especially the third to last paragraph and that sentence everyone hated. Hopefully it reads better now.

i thought greyvy was saying i obviously care and i was like lol yeah totally

Album Rating: 4.0

'I really hate the approval system on this site. It should either be removed, or changed to require someone who negs a review to make a comment.'



stupid



people would just comment 'shit review lol butts' or something

Album Rating: 3.0

can't please everybody all the time...

So I've been enjoying this more than most. I have it on a high 3.5 for now and may even grow to a 4. I'm enjoying it about as much as Marrow at the moment and the first half of this album in terms of consistency is much better than Marrow in my opinion which is all over the place in terms of quality.

Second half of the album however is pretty disappointing and lacking direction....at least it seems that way with the listens I've given so far.

Album Rating: 3.5

quite my sentiments, im enjoying vales pretty much now. that song is catchy.

Dark matter gods however is so painfully dull i felt cheated everytime i listen to that. without that song this would even be a 4 for me maybe

That's weird because it's the complete opposite for me haha. Vale is such a bore and the closing instrumental is just alright. I love Dark Matters God which is weird because I hated it on first listen.

The Astral Dialogue rules

Album Rating: 3.5

Astral, Celestial and Vale are the ones that keep me coming back for more. The rest might grow a little more, hopefully.