this is like their fourth best album

Album Rating: 4.5

no.

Album Rating: 4.0

Anyone who doesn't like this is a faggot.

i would say this is third or fourth. I'd much rather listen to Black Sails or the Art of Drowning (in that order) but for some reason this is hitting the spot at the moment. it's refreshing since I haven't listened to this since I was in high school.

Well I always get a lot of hate for saying it, but my favorites are definitely this and Decemberunderground. I personally can't stand the AFI fans who think they're sell-out records.

Album Rating: 4.0

still one of my favorite albums of all-time.

i can give it to you on this one Obfuscation but Decemberunderground is absolute shit and a sell out record.

smashmouth broooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooo

*sigh* smashmouth is the jam

HEY NOW. YOURE AN ALLSTAR.

Album Rating: 4.5

this = out of this world

du = meh but gets too much hate

cl = sounded good at first but grows off you like crazy, haven't listened to any song from it in almost a year

this=orgasmic
du=a little less orgasmic but still brings the eargasms and such
cl=took forever to grow on me but I enjoy it now

for the most part i stopped listening to AFI after going to the concert that eventually became their I
Heard a Voice DVD. it took years to get over my disappointment

Wow. Very surprised sputnik likes Sing the Sorrow. It used to be my biggest guilty pleasure

So does that mean they're not worth seeing live? Or you just stopped listening to them around that time? Because I definitely want to see them next time they come to Atlanta.

^ Exactly why new AFI fans fucking suck

you'd probably love them live. i just had a hard time because i hated the crowd and hated half of the
songs that were played. i cant fucking stand stadium shows tbqmfh. they fucking slayed when i saw them
for the first time in 01.

I can't stand stadium crowds either so that might be an issue :o

Album Rating: 5.0

This=Hot Fire



DU=Like a watered down version of STS



CL=Has been out for a minute, Haven't heard it enough for it to grow on me, but it might not ever happen, album feels to boring and like it was touched to much by the hands of the evil corporation also known as the music biz

Album Rating: 4.0

Had to bump the rating up, it's like I didn't understand all the various aspects that make this such a good album (synths in some of the background = genius) and might bump it up even further.