this album is definentely my favorite, I mean I wake up every morning to Shine On You Crazy Diamond (Part 1).

Album Rating: 5.0

Shine On = Good times.

I have "Welcome to the Machine" on the computer. It's neat, and creepy.

As far as prog rock this is a good effort. I really dont care for progressive rock and on a whole Pink Floyd is much more than a progressive rock band. I like other Floyd albums better but this is overall decent.

Album Rating: 5.0

[QUOTE=jimmydean]the best Pink Floyd album is the greatest hits album. duh. :lol:[/QUOTE]

No...

Awesome review man, I wouldn't have changed a thing. :thumb:

Pink Floyd Album List For Me
1. Dark Side of The Moon
2. Obscured By Clouds
3. Wish you were here
4. Animals
5. A Saucerful of Secrets

All their CDs are great and Wish You Were Here was great. I have the Dark Side of the Moon DVD and i must say, wow, great band :D

in my opionin the second best floyd album. the best Dark Side Of The Moon

Wish you were here deserves a well written review. Good Job!

great review, i like the little background stories
also my personal favorite album, with meddle a close second

This album is excellent. You did an awesome review.
I give this album a 5/5 and your review a 5/5 also.

[QUOTE=what]this album is definentely my favorite, I mean I wake up every morning to Shine On You Crazy Diamond (Part 1).[/QUOTE]

how the hell does that wake you up? :confused:

that would put me to sleep so much faster. (i mean that in a good way, it's a great mellow song)

Most Pink Floyd fans love this. I think it's good, 3.5/5.

Good review, but as some others said, I would have given welcome to the machine a 5/5. But this is my fav album of all time. 55/5

Album Rating: 5.0

Wow, lots of positive feedback for this one. Thanks guys.

WYWH is, after ANIMALS obviously, PF's best work. I'm not so keen on Machine (bit droney, lyrics a bit pedestrian) or Cigar (bit too slow and meandering), but the title track is blissful, and SOYCD is possibly the best Floyd song ever.

Wish You Were Here>DSOTM
Great Review :cool:
Highlights:
Shine On You Crazy Diamond(Pts. 1-10)
Welcome to the Machine
Wish You Were Here
Have A Cigar

:lol:

I've really got into this album now. Personally, this is my favourite album by Floyd (great review as well), and I would advise anyone who is a music fan to get this. There isn't a song on here that I would give less than 4.5/5, and while both parts of Shine on You Crazy Diamond are amazing, the best song on here has to be Wish You Were Here. Lyrically and musically this is a perfect song, and may well be the best thing the band ever recorded. In my opinion this is a perfect album, so seriously, just check it out.

[QUOTE=Kingadamx]Awesome review man, I wouldn't have changed a thing. :thumb:

Pink Floyd Album List For Me
1. Dark Side of The Moon
2. Obscured By Clouds
3. Wish you were here
4. Animals
5. A Saucerful of Secrets[/QUOTE]

You appear to have a Lou Reed avatar and a Zappa-related usertitle. Unless this is not the case, you are displaying a radical contradiction.

i love this album i listen to it more often than dark side. you forgot to mention the absolutely breathtaking organ work that comes into the song at 6:33. it puts me too sleep everytime i listen to it and makes me dream of purple skies with more than one moon out in a volcanic wateland. you dont have to be wasted on acid or weed or any drug for that matter to be taken to a different place when listening to solos like these (which floyd has so many of) its better than the one in part 2 by far. have a cigar is also amazing i was listening to it and thought "is this a floyd song"? but then the amazing keyboard work straight out've the previous track destroyed my doubts. a good chill song. wicked review by the way