Pink Floyd Wish You Were Here
» Back to review

Comments:Add a Comment 
what
May 4th 2004



5 Comments


this album is definentely my favorite, I mean I wake up every morning to Shine On You Crazy Diamond (Part 1).

SubtleDagger
May 4th 2004



737 Comments

Album Rating: 5.0

Shine On = Good times.

YDload
May 4th 2004



1207 Comments


I have "Welcome to the Machine" on the computer. It's neat, and creepy.

loose cannon
May 5th 2004



6 Comments


As far as prog rock this is a good effort. I really dont care for progressive rock and on a whole Pink Floyd is much more than a progressive rock band. I like other Floyd albums better but this is overall decent.

SubtleDagger
May 6th 2004



737 Comments

Album Rating: 5.0

[QUOTE=jimmydean]the best Pink Floyd album is the greatest hits album. duh. :lol:[/QUOTE]
No...

Kingadamx
June 25th 2004



120 Comments


Awesome review man, I wouldn't have changed a thing. :thumb:

Pink Floyd Album List For Me
1. Dark Side of The Moon
2. Obscured By Clouds
3. Wish you were here
4. Animals
5. A Saucerful of Secrets

fizzyizzy
June 26th 2004



2 Comments


All their CDs are great and Wish You Were Here was great. I have the Dark Side of the Moon DVD and i must say, wow, great band :D

xHysteriax
July 2nd 2004



1 Comments


in my opionin the second best floyd album. the best Dark Side Of The Moon

HaveACigar2502
July 3rd 2004



2 Comments


Wish you were here deserves a well written review. Good Job!

weatherman123
July 3rd 2004



11 Comments


great review, i like the little background stories
also my personal favorite album, with meddle a close second

mexicanfloydian
July 3rd 2004



165 Comments


This album is excellent. You did an awesome review.
I give this album a 5/5 and your review a 5/5 also.

MxShredder
July 4th 2004



58 Comments


[QUOTE=what]this album is definentely my favorite, I mean I wake up every morning to Shine On You Crazy Diamond (Part 1).[/QUOTE]

how the hell does that wake you up? :confused:

that would put me to sleep so much faster. (i mean that in a good way, it's a great mellow song)

Zappa
July 4th 2004



355 Comments


Most Pink Floyd fans love this. I think it's good, 3.5/5.

ShineOnYouCrazyDiamond
July 19th 2004



22 Comments


Good review, but as some others said, I would have given welcome to the machine a 5/5. But this is my fav album of all time. 55/5

SubtleDagger
July 19th 2004



737 Comments

Album Rating: 5.0

Wow, lots of positive feedback for this one. Thanks guys.

Lumiere
July 21st 2004



53 Comments


WYWH is, after ANIMALS obviously, PF's best work. I'm not so keen on Machine (bit droney, lyrics a bit pedestrian) or Cigar (bit too slow and meandering), but the title track is blissful, and SOYCD is possibly the best Floyd song ever.

Woodstock
August 17th 2004



154 Comments


Wish You Were Here>DSOTM
Great Review :cool:
Highlights:
Shine On You Crazy Diamond(Pts. 1-10)
Welcome to the Machine
Wish You Were Here
Have A Cigar

:lol:

Med57
Moderator
September 3rd 2004



1001 Comments


I've really got into this album now. Personally, this is my favourite album by Floyd (great review as well), and I would advise anyone who is a music fan to get this. There isn't a song on here that I would give less than 4.5/5, and while both parts of Shine on You Crazy Diamond are amazing, the best song on here has to be Wish You Were Here. Lyrically and musically this is a perfect song, and may well be the best thing the band ever recorded. In my opinion this is a perfect album, so seriously, just check it out.

Zappa
September 3rd 2004



355 Comments


[QUOTE=Kingadamx]Awesome review man, I wouldn't have changed a thing. :thumb:

Pink Floyd Album List For Me
1. Dark Side of The Moon
2. Obscured By Clouds
3. Wish you were here
4. Animals
5. A Saucerful of Secrets[/QUOTE]

You appear to have a Lou Reed avatar and a Zappa-related usertitle. Unless this is not the case, you are displaying a radical contradiction.



clouds_are_cool
September 19th 2004



13 Comments


i love this album i listen to it more often than dark side. you forgot to mention the absolutely breathtaking organ work that comes into the song at 6:33. it puts me too sleep everytime i listen to it and makes me dream of purple skies with more than one moon out in a volcanic wateland. you dont have to be wasted on acid or weed or any drug for that matter to be taken to a different place when listening to solos like these (which floyd has so many of) its better than the one in part 2 by far. have a cigar is also amazing i was listening to it and thought "is this a floyd song"? but then the amazing keyboard work straight out've the previous track destroyed my doubts. a good chill song. wicked review by the way



You have to be logged in to post a comment. Login | Create a Profile





FAQ // STAFF & CONTRIBUTORS // SITE FORUM // CONTACT US

Bands: A B C D E F G H I J K L M N O P Q R S T U V W X Y Z


Site Copyright 2005-2013 Sputnikmusic.com
All Album Reviews Displayed With Permission of Authors | Privacy Policy