Album Rating: 4.5

As cliched a pick as it may well be - it's my favourite from this

Album Rating: 5.0

Probably mine too - there are several other perfect songs here though, it's hard to pick one

Album Rating: 4.5

I really like War on War but I'm usually alone in that

Album Rating: 5.0

I love it but it doesn't make my top 5

Album Rating: 5.0

War on War is easily my least favorite on here, still good though



Radio Cure is my favorite



Other songs in my top 5: Jesus Etc., I'm the Man Who Loves You, Heavy Metal Drummer, and Kamera

Album Rating: 4.5

Jesus, War, Ashes, Poor, Kamera are my top 5

Album Rating: 5.0

My faves are the last 3 tracks

Album Rating: 5.0

Switch War with I Am Trying and you have my top 5 Doof

Album Rating: 4.5

I am trying... is my 6th pick



Then Radio, then Man Who...then it dips a bit for me. Not badly but the remaining few tunes I don't like as much.



I know a lot of people love Drummer but I'm a little indifferent about it

Album Rating: 5.0

6th pick would be Ashes probably

Album Rating: 5.0

Guess you guys know my favorite

Album Rating: 4.5

Updated track ranking/ratings:



5/5: Ashes of American Flags > Jesus, Etc. > Reservations

4.5/5: Radio Cure > I'm the Man Who Loves You > Poor Places

4/5: Heavy Metal Drummer > Pot Kettle Black > I Am Trying to Break Your Heart > Kamera

3.5/5: War on War

Album Rating: 5.0

Oh come on, those track ratings are more than good enough to warrant 4.5!

Hell, for Doof that spread of track ratings would be a 5!

Album Rating: 4.0

He's right you know, average of those track ratings (if they're not arbitrary) is a 4.4.

Album Rating: 5.0

Plus (for me at least) overal rating is greater than track average (excluding the odd case where an album is lesser than the sum of its parts)

I don't like this album all that much but I Am Trying to Break Your Heart is a stone cold classic, easily the best tune

Album Rating: 4.5

Ranked/Rated



1. Jesus etc [5]

2. War on War [5]

3. Ashes of American [5]

4. Poor Places[4.5]

5. I am Trying [4.5] (bumped this, better than Kamera)

6. Kamera [4]

7. Radio Cure [4]

8. Heavy Metal Drummer [3]

9. Pot Kettle [3]

10. Reservations [2.5]

Album Rating: 4.5

Album rating isn't directly related to track average - a 10 minute 5/5 song would be more important than a couple of two minute long 2.5/5 tracks



5/5 tunes are quite rare - out of 15,000 songs on my itunes only approx 1500 are labelled 5 star



Especially when you consider I actively only look to download the 5 star songs from certain albums where I'm not too bothered about the album as a whole

Album Rating: 4.5

ashes

i am trying

jesus etc

radio cure

poor places

reservations

war on war

kamera

pot kettle black

heavy metal

Album Rating: 4.5

@Boney feel free to consider my rating a 4.249 :P