One Direction Four
» Back to review

Comments:Add a Comment 
DirEnRefused
November 18th 2014


3665 Comments


god i wish queen was still here instead of these guys. retweet, like, upvote and share if you agree.

DirEnRefused
November 18th 2014


3665 Comments


though being serious, i've noticed in this thread and the taylor swift thread sputnik is riding some kind of weird counter-
counter culture mentality, where if you strongly dislike the mainstream pop album du jour then you're lumped
immediately as some kind of "le wrong generation" stereotype, when i think there's plenty of legitimate reasons to think
this album is just really homogenous and artifical.

idk it's some kind of weird meta layer of elitism, where you're "rising above" the immature hipsters who've "risen above"
the sheeple masses.

SharkTooth
November 18th 2014


14922 Comments

Album Rating: 2.5

Ehh, while I don't cate for Taylor Swift or 1D, I do enjoy a few pop acts here and there(most recent

would probably be OneRepublic). You gotta understand though that there are a lotta hipsters in this

site, so obviously there is going to be at least some bias towards mainstream pop-music

ArsMoriendi
November 18th 2014


41087 Comments


Can't we all just be honest with the music we like? : (

SharkTooth
November 18th 2014


14922 Comments

Album Rating: 2.5

And hell yeah the Beatles were a boy-band, it was the fuckin' British Invasion! Every band that

crossed the ocean to earn a spot on the Ed Sullivan Show was essentially a boy band att

someguest
November 18th 2014


30126 Comments


I don't like when music is used merely as filler. Nearly everything on traditional FM radio here fits that
bill.

I don't devote time to hating pop. Most of the time I don't even know songs that are really popular until
months or years after they've hit that mark. As someone who enjoys the weirder side of sonic entertainment,
I flock to more extreme forms of the art; forms that are not acknowledged in mainstream media. Therefore,
my dismissal of pop music is unintentional due to lack of care and the fact that I'm too busy immersing
myself in music that I know I'll be far more inclined to enjoy.

ArsMoriendi
November 18th 2014


41087 Comments


I see boy bands as a more of a manufactured singing and dancing choreography based group
that doesn't write their own music and tries to only appeal to young girls.

SharkTooth
November 18th 2014


14922 Comments

Album Rating: 2.5

"I see boy bands as a more of manufactured singing and dancing choreography based group that doesn't write their own music and tries to only appeal to young girls. "



in a way this is accurate, but it's a very narrow way to look at it. I'd more say boy bands are any mainstream band that has all members looking young and relatively attractive enough to the point that their faces could be used as marketing tools to young girls, regardless of who writes their songs

someguest
November 18th 2014


30126 Comments


The same way Aerosmith has been an old lady band for the majority of their career.

ArsMoriendi
November 18th 2014


41087 Comments


But the Beatles were just a REALLY popular rock band who appealed to everyone.

The Beatles influenced boy bands in the same way The Velvet Underground influenced punk, but the Velvet Underground aren't punk, just an influence.



ArsMoriendi
November 18th 2014


41087 Comments


"The same way Aerosmith has been an old lady band for the majority of their career."

Agreed. One that Permanent Vacation album came out it was pretty evident.

NordicMindset
November 18th 2014


25137 Comments


I loathe One Direction and everything about them. Something about that lack of personality and emotion just irks me.

Frippertronics
Emeritus
November 18th 2014


19513 Comments


yeah

lack of personality
T O O L

remember that review you did that got panned to hell?

deathschool
November 18th 2014


28658 Comments


Four? More like Five

Bloodlax
November 18th 2014


123 Comments


shit

treeqt.
November 18th 2014


16970 Comments


more like 100_ _

treeqt.
November 18th 2014


16970 Comments


no please stop im offended

Aftertheascension
November 18th 2014


3564 Comments

Album Rating: 1.5

offense

ChoccyPhilly
November 18th 2014


13630 Comments


"I loathe One Direction and everything about them. Something about that lack of personality and emotion just irks me."

So do i, but they're catchy sometimes...

occasionally...

DrGonzo1937
Staff Reviewer
November 18th 2014


18318 Comments



Not sure how to feel about this.[2]



You have to be logged in to post a comment. Login | Create a Profile





STAFF & CONTRIBUTORS // CONTACT US

Bands: A B C D E F G H I J K L M N O P Q R S T U V W X Y Z


Site Copyright 2005-2023 Sputnikmusic.com
All Album Reviews Displayed With Permission of Authors | Terms of Use | Privacy Policy