Album Rating: 3.5

I'm getting some Neutral Milk Hotel vibes during parts of the new album

Album Rating: 3.0

wtf



new album slaps but you're so wrong

Album Rating: 4.0

Home is Where I Am Steaming Mushrooms

Home is Where Rat Saw God

Album Rating: 4.0

I get that the band considered this an LP but man the new one is such a well-constructed statement and feels so much more like an LP that it’s kind of a shame that it’s not technically their debut.

Album Rating: 3.7

this record slaps and is far superior to the new one. first two songs have NMH all over them, as does the new album's closer

Album Rating: 3.0

no

Album Rating: 3.7

have you heard of Neutral Milk Hotel they're actually quite a recognisable band once you know them

Album Rating: 3.5

Why must y'all try to dilute my enjoyment of The Whaler by comparing it to that overrated indie folk shit

Album Rating: 3.7

lol brandon macdonald is v open about NMH influence, and if you can't hear Jeff Magnum behind half her lyrics, you're gonna need a reading comp rerun



fwiw she wears it very well on this one - but kinda ridiculous to deny

Album Rating: 3.0

I don't care about lyrics

Album Rating: 3.5

well she does it a hell of a lot better lol in the aeroplane did nothing for me and it being considered the like #30 album of all time is embarrassing

Album Rating: 3.7

new pleb filter challenge: name 29 albums better than in the aeroplane over the sea

Album Rating: 3.5

i can name so many that the sputnik comment filter would say my comment's too long so i'll just sum up a small chunk.



my chemical romance - entire discog

underoath - everything post-act of depression

the devil wears prada - entire discog

glassjaw - entire discog

deftones - entire discog

dillinger escape plan - entire discog

devil sold his soul - entire discog

bring me the horizon - everything there is a hell onward including the long name electronic EP

nine inch nails - entire discog

alice in chains - everything with layne, black gives way to blue

converge - entire discog

pendulum - entire discog

finch - what it is to burn, say hello to sunshine

katatonia - entire discog

loathe - i let it in and it took everything

massive attack - mezzanine

the gathering - entire discog INCLUDING almost a dance

the ocean - entire discog

opeth - entire discog except heritage

refused - the shape of punk to come

a tribe called quest - entire discog

kanye west - everything before yeezus, the first donda

armor for sleep - entire discog

cave in - entire discog



this is way more than 29

Best comment of all time, close the site

wow can’t believe I’m here for this monumental moment

Album Rating: 3.7

"entire discog except heritage"



well damn that worked better than expected



aeroplane is far from a personal classic, but i ain't gonna hear shit about lyricism or songwriting on anything from anyone who doesn't understand that album

Album Rating: 3.5

heritage was of major disappointment to me bc i went in hoping the prog rock era would carry on the same feel as Damnation but they abandoned that entirely on that one.

i probably need to give it like 600 listens to "get it" but i shouldnt have to with a genre as simple as indie folk

Album Rating: 3.0

"i probably need to give it like 600 listens to "get it" but i shouldnt have to with a genre as simple as indie folk"



Yeah maybe just listen to another album where Chino sings about his dick as a knife or something

NMH ain't shit...TDWP is where it's at

/Drake meme

Album Rating: 3.5

https://open.spotify.com/playlist/6nUERnqhjzjj16NkmEaWcw?si=109e0afe89924935 everything here has evoked more emotion for me than all of aeroplane, i ended up dismantling most of this list forever ago but the stuff there still does it for me