it probabaly sounds the same as every song on the album becouse allll bands do that...ur just another person who thinks they shouldbe liek they were on the black and and justice ..well face it they wont ..metallica is still my favorite and i like st.anger if i were to compare it to previous albums (WHICH I DONT DO BECOUSE IT IS SO LAME) i would say the change is not for the best but they still sound good

Whoa. Sorry Captain Fanboy.

Album Rating: 2.0

This is certainly a mediocre album, at best. The songwriting was toned down and boring. I don't really care for any Metallica beyond the black album, and even that one is pushing it.

well ur right too i dont really find them that great either but they aint total garbage

Album Rating: 4.0

reload is a good album, it isnt as good as the previous albums but you cant expect a bunch of old man playing trash/speed metal like they did before...besides reload has very good lyrics and some cool riffsThis Message Edited On 12.07.05This Message Edited On 12.07.05

Good cd...but nothing to the old stuff...good review to

Album Rating: 2.5

I find this album to be very average, but there's a couple gems on this that pull out of mediocrity for me. Fixxxer is one of my favorite Metallica songs ever. Not to mention that fact that Low Man's Lyric is absolutely beautiful.

Album Rating: 1.5 | Sound Off

I might as well just put this album on eBay or something. I never listen to it and I don't intend on picking it up ever again.

Album Rating: 3.0

Sell it as a coaster.

Nah, just kidding. I actually quite like ReLoad. It's got more character than it's predecessor, but that had more style. There's a lot of filler, but for an alternative rock album, it's no slouch.

Not Metallica's best by any means, but it gets occasional rotation in my room.

Album Rating: 4.0

this album has grown on me at such point that i like it better than kill em all...my metallica albums rankings are this way:



1-->...AJFA

2-->MOP

3-->RTL

4-->reload

5-->kill em all

6-->st anger

7-->black album

8-->load

Album Rating: 2.0

This is a poor record. At times I would take St. Anger over this.

wow, metaldude213 likes reload over kill em all. thats unexpected going by your name.
on a different note now that i have mentioned that, i'm going to rank my albums 1-8 like metaldude213 and other people hopefully will continue on this revolution of ranking albums that will change the world.
1: ...AJFA

ok as you can all tell my computer was made in 1964 and has a mind of its own. to contine my ranking:
1: ...AJFA
2: BLACK
3: Kill em All
4: MOP
5: st. anger
6: RTL
7: Load
8: Reload

Album Rating: 4.0

Wooow....such a diferent ranking than mine....i still love reload and st anger tough

Album Rating: 3.0

Alright, fine. Here's mine.

1. St. Anger (no fooling)

2. RtL

3. MoP

4. ...AJFA

5. Load

6. Metallica

7. Reload

8. Kill 'em all

But I don't know, the bottom four are kinda the same for me in terms of enjoyment.

Album Rating: 4.0

I hate how people say all the songs on this album sound the same, or all the solos. Kill 'Em All, anyone?

Album Rating: 4.0

dude everyone has different tastes.....and the fact that the black album is beneath st anger doesnt mean i dont like it, its just that i found little standouts in the black album (my friend of misery, holier than thou, the god that failed, wherever i may roam) and i just like st anger a lot for some reason

Album Rating: 4.0

yeah.....well mostly everybody loves kill em all and their self titled.....i think reload and st anger should get more props, if you actually listen reload is a freaking incrediblle album, i love the riffs, lars's drumming isnt out of this world but its very nice drum playing, the bass is somewhat good, and overall is an awesome album, just the same with st anger, but people rejected because its not as good as AJFA, or MOP but its still an awesome album

Album Rating: 5.0

Fixxxer In my opinion deserves a 5. It is one of my favourite songs from the 90's (Besides Sandman and Nothing Else Matters).



This was a good review.This Message Edited On 03.20.06

Album Rating: 3.0 | Sound Off

I think this cd like (like load) is underrated because it's not Metallica's usual work so emidiatly say its garbage. But if you look at this album and compare it some of today's biggest bands like blink-182 and green day, its clearly superior to their like 4 chord songs and medioker riffs. The only reason this album has kind of a low rating is because people are comparing it like the Black Album which is shere genius so this album seems inferior but compared to most other music its quite good, excellent even.