Ghostface Killah Ghostdini: The Wizard of Poetry in Emerald City
  full reviewuser ratings (15) 
Tracklist:
1. "Not Your Average Girl" (featuring Shareefa)
2. "Do Over" (featuring Raheem "Radio" DeVaughn)
3. "Baby" (featuring Raheem "Radio" DeVaughn)
4. "Lonely" (featuring Jack Night)
5. "Stapleton Sex" (not on edited version[7])
6. "Stay"
7. "Paragraphs of Love" (featuring Vaughn Anthony & Estelle)
8. "Guest House" (featuring Fabolous)
9. "Let's Stop Playin'" (featuring John Legend)
10. "Forever"
11. "I'll Be That" (featuring Adrienne Bailon)
12. "Goner" (featuring Lloyd)
13. "She's a Killah" (featuring Ron Browz) (Bonus Track)
14. "Back Like That (Remix)" (featuring Kanye West & Ne-Yo) (Bonus Track) Xtreme


Release Date: 09/29/2009

user rating
2.8
good
Chart.

related



recommended by reviewer
Ghostface Killah Supreme Clientele
Ne-Yo Year of the Gentleman
John Legend Evolver

members also liked
Raekwon Only Built 4 Cuban Linx... Pt II
Raekwon Only Built 4 Cuban Linx...
The Notorious B.I.G. Ready To Die
Wu-Tang Clan Enter the Wu-Tang (36 Chambers)
Cam'ron Crime Pays
Dr. Dre The Chronic
GZA Liquid Swords
Outkast Aquemini

  
3.0
good
Sobhi Abdul-Rakhman STAFF (39 Reviews)

2009-10-02 | 37 comments | 3,809 views

Summary: It's hard not to inflate the rating of a record with some truly incredible joints, yet it's difficult to ignore the two-thirds filler...

Tony Starks likes two things, or so it seems according to the subject matter of his rhymes: bitches and blow. Abandoning the latter for a whole record (seriously), he dedicates his trademark crazed flow entirely to the fairer sex with mixed results. Not completely a club-oriented record, The Wizard of Poetry in Emerald City dons a multi-faceted mantle of sentimentality, jealousy, and sorrow; this emotional gamut really doesn't click in certain situations (namely the off-target affair that is "Baby"), but there are some incredibly catchy moments here. When the record was initially announced as Ghostface's foray into R&B, it was greeted with disdain and an overall air of negativity - and while fears of 90s radio-soul surmounted, this reaction is largely unwarranted with modern production standards and a collection of excellent featured vocalists. "Not Your Average Girl" and "Do Over" kick things off brilliantly with catchy hooks from Shareefa and Raheem DeVaughn, respectively. Quickly setting Ghost's intended tone amidst updated, soul-laden beats, this one-two punch unfortunately sets the bar quite high for the remainder. Follow-up "Baby" was seemingly written for an audience of peers and not a younger crowd with sappy generalizations for parents to be. As is typical of Mr. Starks, each and every track is mired in the misogynist musings of a man that loves "running trains" and "threesomes every other weekend"; "Stapleton Sex" runs these assertions to a head in what could possibly be a recording of the Wizard actually fornicating. TMI Ghostface, TMI.

Ghostdeini is at his absolute best on the more modern iterations on the radio soul/rap formula, especially on the John Legend assisted "Let's Stop Playing" and a killer trio of album closers. The crooning tenor of Lloyd over a clinic on funk in "Goner" stands out with a particularly absorbing chorus; as a good measuring stick, many ladies in this household have been caught recently with their heads bobbing. Interestingly enough, the two closing bonus tracks are some of the best - Ne-yo and Kanye collabo "Back Like That" may be familiar to some, and the heavily dynamic, autotune-tastic "She's a Killah" brings a unique spin to your typical club tune.

While difficult to expect another killer Wu joint immediately following the brilliant Only Built 4 Cuban Linx... Pt II, The Wizard of Poetry is definitely enjoyable even if it is sporadic in its appeal. It's hard not to inflate the rating of a record with some truly incredible joints, yet it's difficult to ignore the two-thirds filler combined with Ghostface's least complicated rhymes in years. The selection of singles here is also puzzling, with some of the worst tracks getting undeserved spotlight. Nice try Tony, but let's shoot for a Supreme Clientele II next time around.

Share: Facebook Stumble Digg!Digg Twitter Del.icio.us


Recent reviews by this author
Crooked I Mr. Pig Face Weapon Waist
Wale Attention Deficit
Royce da 5'9 Street Hop
Brother Ali Us
Raekwon Only Built 4 Cuban Linx... Pt II
Zechs Marquise Our Delicate Stranded Nightmare

Comments:Add a Comment 
kingsoby1
Staff Reviewer


Comments: 1630
10.02.09

Album Rating: 3 | Sound Off

Holy tbt batman

Digging: Wale - Attention Deficit

heavykevlarsuit


Comments: 119
10.02.09


Good review, great avatar.

bastard


Comments: 3412
10.02.09

Album Rating: 3.5

this album is really a bundle of fun

Digging: Kool G. Rap - 4, 5, 6

redskyformiles
Contributing Reviewer


Comments: 5824
10.02.09


album is chill

Digging: The Mars Volta - Frances the Mute

DaveyBoy
Staff Reviewer


Comments: 5825
10.02.09


Rock solid review Sobhi.

How does Estelle come out of it, or is it just a bit part?

Digging: Paloma Faith - Do You Want the Truth or Something Beautiful?

rasputin
Contributing Reviewer


Comments: 9689
10.03.09


sobhi in the hooood

Digging: Earth - Earth 2

kingsoby1
Staff Reviewer


Comments: 1630
10.03.09

Album Rating: 3 | Sound Off

estelle's guest spot is well done, but the track (concept & production) is so cheesy it's ridiculous. it's about running into the girl of your dreams, but she's already taken! poor ghostface :[

Six Foot Revolver


Comments: 73
10.03.09


never been a huge fan of his solo albums so i think i'm gonna give this one a miss

Digging: Have A Nice Life - Deathconsciousness

AggravatedYeti


Comments: 1078
10.03.09


I honestly can't wait to get this. The single I heard was great and well -- check that album cover, baller as fuck.

Digging: A Sunny Day In Glasgow - Ashes Grammar

Iluvatar
Staff Reviewer


Comments: 11112
10.03.09

Album Rating: 2.5

i love She's a Killah a lot

Digging: Animal Collective - Spirit They've Gone, Spirit They've Vanished

metaldude666


Comments: 111
10.03.09


i am conflicted as to whether to get this or not because ghostface is my fav and his solo albums are always great, but they ahve been diminishing in quality and that album cover is pretty homo

kingsoby1
Staff Reviewer


Comments: 1630
10.03.09

Album Rating: 3 | Sound Off

the album's as good as fishscale imo. but it's a totally different style.

metaldude666


Comments: 111
10.03.09


you think fishscale is a 3 >:|

MassiveAttack


Comments: 1759
10.03.09


That's my biggest gripe with Ghostface Killah's solo work. Always way too much filler to appreciate the album.

Digging: PJ Harvey - Dry

bastard


Comments: 3412
10.03.09

Album Rating: 3.5

this is awesome, but i agree with you on a lot of occasions MassiveAttack.

BallsToTheWall
Contributing Reviewer


Comments: 18779
10.03.09


Refuse to listen to this lovefest.

Digging: Deep-Pression/Exethersis - Train Exeter To D.P. State

combustion07


Comments: 3024
10.03.09


Album title is win

Digging: Stormtroopers Of Death - Speak English or Die

Zip


Comments: 3731
10.03.09


ugh hip-hop

Digging: Disparaged - The Wrath of God

bastard


Comments: 3412
10.03.09

Album Rating: 3.5

can i zip your mouth closed?

Roach


Comments: 1094
10.03.09


ugh hip-hop


giant fu

Digging: Stars Of The Lid - And Their Refinement Of The Decline



You have to be logged in to post a comment. Login | Create a Profile





FAQ // STAFF & CONTRIBUTORS // SITE FORUM // CONTACT US

Site Copyright 2005-2009 Sputnikmusic.com
All Reviews Displayed With Permission of Authors | Privacy Policy