AngryChief95: Star Wars Movies Ranked

DominionMM1 07.29.16	switch 4 and 5 and you got it
Risodo 07.29.16	Agree with the bottom three. Switch 4 with 6, and 6 with 5 to make my list.
Ocean of Noise 07.29.16	5 > 4 > 3 > 6 > 7 > 1 > 2 for me.
bentheREDfan 07.29.16	Return needs to be higher… Islander is the only band I really dig here
teamster 07.29.16	Empire is my favorite too. Kirshiner did a fantastic job.
CaliggyJack 07.29.16	I still think 3 is worse than 1
elliootsmeuth 07.30.16	Good list. Quite agreeable. I'd only switch 4 and 5, and it'd be the same for me.
Masochist 07.30.16	In terms of epsiode numbers, for me it goes: 5 > 7 > 4 > 6 > 3 > 2 > 1
AlexKzillion 07.30.16	III=V>IV>VI>II>I Haven't seen VII enough times to put it in the ranking just yet.
Trundle 07.30.16	I < II < VII < III < VI < IV < V
hikingmetalpunk 07.30.16	anh tesb rotj
SIIMBOLIC 07.30.16	lets take the nostalgia goggles off and realise that ep 4 drags on at the beginning a bit. I also dont get why ep 1 is the most hated I reckon 2 is by far the worst. Every time anakin is with padme i wanna neck myself hard. I feel sorry for christensen, there's really not much anyone could've done with dialogue that shit and direction that pedestrian. Even Sam L Jackson was boring as shit. Lucas made SAM MOTHERFUCKING JACKSON boring. Christensen didnt stand a chance worst to best imo: 2,1,6,4,3,7,5
HazelMotes92 07.30.16	I agree with Siimbolic that Ep 2 is worse than Ep 1. I think Episodes 3 and 6 tend to be a bit overrated, perhaps because they close their respective trilogies and tie up loose ends. For me Ep 6 drags a lot in the middle and has some pretty awful dialogue in a few scenes. Worst to best: 2, 1, 3, 6, 7, 4, 5.
AlexKzillion 07.30.16	Attack of the Clones is one of the most consistently funny movies I've ever seen (along with Revenge of the Sith), which makes it better then Phantom Menace for me. The last four times I've watched it though I've fallen asleep the exact moment Yoda arrives with the clones and don't I wake up until usually the credits, definitely the thing that hurts that movie the most for me.
MarsKid 07.30.16	Phantom Menace and Attack of the Clones are definitely at the bottom for me. Then after that probably episode 7, episode 3, 4, 6, and 5.
SitarHero 07.30.16	What kind of clown ranks ANH below TFA and RotJ? Bad. Bad bad bad.
Valkoor952 07.30.16	Simbolic Let's take the nostalgia glasses off ? Good idea. Cause if we did Force awakens would only be higher than Attack of the clones, because it was a poor cash-grab remake with an incredibly stupid and unoriginal story along with some of the most political correctness ever seen. 6>5>4>3>1>7>2 Here. I actually like rotj quite a lot so that's why I put it at first place.
porcupinetheater 07.30.16	"Force Awakens...was a poor cash-grab with an incredibly stupid and unoriginal story" [2] JJ Abrams is the laziest fucking hack in Hollywood. Force Awakens is the worst movie in the franchise, at least the prequel trilogy tried to do something different instead of cheaply rehash past success in the most generic way imiginable to diminishing returns.
Rik VII 07.30.16	1) Empire Strikes Back (it aged sooo well) 2) Return of the Jedi (yeah it has some weak points but damn that final confrontation is the best scene in Star Wars by a mile imo) 3) A New Hope (kinda trashy but good and has some great character interaction during the death star arc) 4) Revenge of the Sith (inconsistent af, hardly ever seen a movie that feels so randomly put together, but besides having a lot of shit moments there's also a lot of really good ones, especially during the last scenes) 5) The Force Awakens (from a technical/cinematograhical perspective one of the best, the story is one of the worst. kinda inoffensive as a whole, actually inoffensive to the point of being offensive, I hope you get what I mean) 6) Phantom Menace (that's kind of a childhood movie for me, the story isn't that bad and at least it feels coherent. some things are the worst though.) 7) Attack of the Clones (what a shit movie, honestly.)
TheMoonchild 07.30.16	My ranking (best to worst): Empire - Force - Hope - Jedi - Sith - Menace - Clones Also "prequels tried to do something different" really? TPM was basically just ANH with shitey CG smothered over it and dashes of Reboot thrown in for good measure, Clones was the bizarre bastard child of Dawsons Creek and every generic sci-fi flick of the late 90s to mid 2000s and Sith thought that hyperfocusing on grimdark could compensate for a lack of story but instead basically just ended up being a dark shitty movie. TFA didn't try to hide its nostalgia trip-ness and was better for it.
Valkoor952 07.30.16	No it wasn't. In the prequels everything was so new, George took a risk and completely changed the setting. That's why it was interesting, every movie had new flashy ships, planets and great looking original stuff. They could have done that with 7 by opting for a different era and a different setting to tell a different and interesting new story but nooo, we had to go back to the Skywalkers even though their story was fully COMPLETED and it was absolutely unnecessary to continue it. But whatever as long as they get the old original trilogy fans to see this movie it's all good. They don't need to be inventive, they don't need a good script ,just shout LUKE SKYWALKER, HAN SOLO, PRINCESS LEIA and everyone is on board the nostalgia train.
TheMoonchild 07.30.16	Nothing about the prequels was interesting. Yeah, Anakin becomes Darth Vader. So what? Anyone with even a marginal knowledge of the trilogy knows that. The first film is just boring politics and an attempt to cash in on the Reboot style world building (and a shite one). Attack... god I hardly remember a thing about it. Revenge is just pure shite. Basically "something something something Dark Side" complete with more Anakin being a whiny shit and the infamous "NOOOOO" and "THE HIGHER GROUND???" moments. The entire point of the whole series is that in this universe, everyone is bound to go through the same thing, which is why we got another Luke and Leia story. At least Rey and Finn have good backstories. One is a man who was forced into Storm Trooper slavery as a child who finally escapes after witnessing a horrific act on his first mission and another is a girl with a shitty childhood and not much better adulthood who scavenges scraps of old ships for shit portions of shit food who takes advantage of an escape opportunity when it hits her and uses her full potential. And at least it has a villain too. Palpatine only exists in the prequel trilogy to push forth more boring politics and Count Saruman only exists to have Christopher Lee in the SW universe. "Anakin becomes a villain" isn't a good excuse too. Yeah, Ben Solo is whiny as fuck but not without reason. He was seduced to the dark side almost entirely on false promises and wants more out of it. It's not even that hard to understand.
TheMoonchild 07.30.16	As for why I rank TFA above ANH, I find it has better pacing. I love ANH but the first 45 minutes are admittedly a tad slow.
Valkoor952 07.30.16	Nah force awakens sucks, can't say it any clearer.
TheMoonchild 07.30.16	The prequels are like an entire second floor of a building with a toothpick for support. TFA is like a simple two bedroom house with layers of complex bunker beneath. Give me nostalgia over try-too-hard and "let's rip off whatever is hot right now" any day. At least there was heart in TFA.
sempiturtle 07.30.16	Episodes 3-7 are all fucking awesome, but Empire, ROTJ and TFA are a cut above the rest. 1 and 2 are just bad, but 1 is the worst.
SitarHero 07.30.16	TFA is like a simple two bedroom house with layers of complex bunker beneath. Give me nostalgia over try-too-hard and "let's rip off whatever is hot right now" any day. At least there was heart in TFA. Whaaa? There was no heart in TFA, just pure cynical greed.
Valkoor952 07.30.16	The entire point of the whole series is that in this universe, everyone is bound to go through the same thing, which is why we got another Luke and Leia story."" What in the fucking fuck are you talking about. And at least it has a villain too." Yeah the CGI Snoke, what a great villain. While I like Kylo I can't POSSIBLY call him a villain, because he is a fucking bitch and can't defeat a girl who has learned the ways of the force in less than 1 day. "One is a man who was forced into Storm Trooper slavery as a child who finally escapes after witnessing a horrific act on his first mission and another is a girl with a shitty childhood and not much better adulthood who scavenges scraps of old ships for shit portions of shit food who takes advantage of an escape opportunity when it hits her and uses her full potential." Yeah, by the way how fucking stupid was that ? The guy has been training his whole life to be a stormtrooper, KNOWING that he's gonna have to kill. Being raised in this life, and he sees the FIRST mission and he says fuck it ! He doesn't have any emotional turmoil, he is just a good guy all of a sudden. Bullshit. And also Rey, hmmm does that remind me of Anakin Skywalker .... nah maybe it's just me but forsaken powerful force user teen on a desert planet not knowing his full potential or his heir line that gets sucked into the action... totally not the same to be honest.
TheMoonchild 07.30.16	Aliens was far superior to Alien in every aspect though, so...
SitarHero 07.30.16	"Aliens was far superior to Alien in every aspect though, so..." Who's contesting that?
TheMoonchild 07.30.16	No, he didn't know he had to kill. He worked FOR the storm troopers as a cleaner and got whisked along on the mission. They even blatantly say this out loud in the film. Yeah so, Kylo can't beat Rey, and she didn't learn the ways of the force in a day. She even has a nightmare scene in the middle of the film that hints where she learned to use the force. Of course Kylo isn't going to defeat Rey, for the same reason Darth Vader didn't defeat Luke or Leia or Han. I'm not even a fanboy of the series and got this ALL ON MY FIRST VIEWING. I have a short attention span too, so I didn't look too deep into things.
TheMoonchild 07.30.16	There was TONS of heart in TFA. The cynical greed was in the prequels.
SitarHero 07.30.16	Well clearly you have a short attention span if you think TFA is better than ANH because of pacing. You probably think Tropic Thunder is better than Apocalypse Now for the same reason.
TheMoonchild 07.30.16	Wow, generalization much. Apocalypse Now is one of my favourite movies ever made and TT is a good, fun movie. Sometimes slow pacing is just slow pacing. Period. By your logic, anyone who prefers Wrath of Khan to Star Trek: The Motion(less) Picture because there's no 10 minute periods of people staring out of windows (AKA most of ST's fanbase) has a short attention span.
smaugman 07.30.16	accurate list
SitarHero 07.30.16	There was ZERO heart in TFA because the movie spent its entire runtime telling the audience, "Hey! We're just like you! We love all those scenes in the original triligy! That's why we're recreating them slavishly instead of trying to do something/anything new." They knew they could completely cannibalise the OT and still make a gazillion dollars off it, hence cynical greed. At least George Lucas tried to tell an epic story of a galaxy's fall into tyranny. He failed miserably, but he tried.
SIIMBOLIC 07.30.16	I really love ep 3. Sure its got some of the typical prequel shit but Christensen stepped it up, Ewan Mcgregor absolutely nailed it, srsly the scene at the end after anakin gets cut up was hardcore. Other than that it really was ambitious and the tone, especially when the jedi are trying to find the sith was really well done. The fight at the end was rediculous tho. And jar jar > ewoks. A stupid attempt at comic relief is one thing, getting teddy bears with stone spears to overpower the galactic empire is just too much
SitarHero 07.30.16	"By your logic, anyone who prefers Wrath of Khan to Star Trek: The Motion(less) Picture has a short attention span." I'm trying not to be overly aggressive dude, but that's the worst use of the word "logic" I have seen today.
TheMoonchild 07.30.16	No, he didn't even try. He just took whatever was hot at the time and gave it lightsabers and blasters. Hell I swear I heard at least 40% of AOTC's dialogue in a season of Felicity. TFA had heart in bringing old characters back without making the film rely on them, giving new characters tons of breathing room and even taking risks like killing off Han Solo. What did the prequels do? George saw an episode of Dawson's Creek and basically threw it into Episode II because Anakin being in love = deep, maaaaan.
TheMoonchild 07.30.16	>implying you've seen it more than once this early in the morning.
SitarHero 07.30.16	You keep bringing up the Padme/Anakin romance like you don't know what a strawman argument is. Yes, the romance was ridiculous and awful. NOBODY disagrees or defends that aspect of those movies. How about you take your ADD ass back to your DVD collection and rewatch the trilogy for the political intrigue it attempted. It wasn't well done by a long shot, but it tried to do something which the original trilogy did not. Name one thing that TFA did which was not directly cribbed from the original trilogy.
TheMoonchild 07.30.16	Oh joy, the oh so original ADD argument. The crossguard saber. You know how long that took me? 5 seconds, and it's been almost a year since I've seen the original trilogy. And what political intrigue? There's no intrigue in watching people sit around debating what to trade in a universe known for mostly the epic battle sequences and exploration of different planets.
miketunneyiscool123 07.30.16	Episode 6 is better than it's given credit for. 5 > 4 > 6 > 7 > 3 > 2 > 1
TheMoonchild 07.30.16	I find it so hilarious that people think faint praise for the notoriously bad prequels is a good enough reason to slam TFA. We may as well congratulate an anorexic for eating a marshmallow.
SitarHero 07.30.16	"The crossguard saber" Well done. You just proved my point.
miketunneyiscool123 07.30.16	@Moon I noticed that a lot, TFA being compared to the sequels and all. I think it fits between the two trilogies for ranking imo. Just a solid sci-fi flick.
TheMoonchild 07.30.16	What point? That mediocrity to even downright shit is excusable if it "tries to be original"?
miketunneyiscool123 07.30.16	Episode 4 always gets nostalgia points for me since it's the first great sci-fi opera and is single-handedly responsible for the spawn of an entire generation of filmmaking.
TheMoonchild 07.30.16	@Mike and that's all I went in expecting. I'm no Star Wars fanboy. I just wanted something fun and free of 2 hour setup and boring politics and above all fun and that's what I got. Simple as that.
miketunneyiscool123 07.30.16	@Moon I don't consider myself a Star Wars fanboy either. I don't do that cosplay stuff, read the books, or even talk about it much. I find the first trilogy to be fun, well-put together films and the seventh a solid, worthy follow up.
Faraudo 07.30.16	Saw TFA yesterday for the 5069606 time, and it still rocks. My second favorite after Empire.
TheMoonchild 07.30.16	@Mike and a lot of movies nowadays could learn from its example. Among many things too many movies nowadays feel it's necessary to devote an entire first 30 minutes to setup. SW just thrust us into the action and we went with it. The only movies I've ever given a free pass for an hour of setup are The Departed and Minority Report, because the setup is not just important but is also well done, so much that it's just as entertaining as when the actual plot kicks in.
Valkoor952 07.30.16	Yeah TFA was shit.
miketunneyiscool123 07.30.16	@Moon Quite true.
SitarHero 07.30.16	"What point? That mediocrity to even downright shit is excusable if it "tries to be original"?" No, the point that a resolutely derivative remake with a slightly fresh coat of paint does not make a reboot better than the original. You're arguing that TFA is better than ANH, remember? The ADD Strikes Back!
Valkoor952 07.30.16	While I don't agree, I can accept that TFA is better than Phantom Menace. However NOTHING more than that.
SIIMBOLIC 07.30.16	no way its worse than clones that just not a thing
DoofusWainwright 07.30.16	Empire>Hope>Jedi>Sith>Awakens>Phantom>Clones
AsleepInTheBack 07.30.16	Agreed that 4-7 are better than 1-3, not sure how I would order 4-7 though, although 4 has nostalgia going for it more than the others
SIIMBOLIC 07.30.16	one boy. all he wanted was to go to tosche station and pick up some power converters. What he got was a whole lot more
Valkoor952 07.30.16	Doofus has the right idea.
AlexKzillion 07.30.16	Honestly, The Force Awakens was definitely a very good movie, but it is pretty much A New Hope but re-imagined. To say that TFA was more "original" and "creative" then the Phantom Menace is just not correct at all though, even if you think TFA is a far better movie.
BallsToTheWall 07.30.16	4,5,7,6, 3,2,1
Valkoor952 07.30.16	Nah no way 7 is better than 6 or 3, I'm sorry it's just impossible.
Crymsonblaze 07.30.16	4,5,6,7,1,3,2 Easy
ArsMoriendi 07.30.16	6 > 5 > 4 > 7 > 3 > 2 > 1
Crymsonblaze 07.30.16	"Nah no way 7 is better than 6 or 3" i've never understood how 3 gets a pass from so many people. dazzled by all of the green screen action scenes, maybe? people shit on 1 (and rightfully so - it sucks), but 2 and 3 have far, FAR more cringeworthy scenes of horrible dialogue and wooden acting. and in case anyone hasn't watched episode 3 recently, the action scenes do NOT hold up well, like at all. if you shrunk the screen and pixelated it a bit, you could pretty easily pass it off as a sega cd game.
AlexKzillion 07.30.16	The CGI holds up remarkably well in III compared to the rest of the prequels. Also the CGI in the prequels looks way better then every other movie I've seen that used around the same amount of CGI.
miketunneyiscool123 07.30.16	@MrAlexK Time hasn't been kind of the CGI effects of the first two prequels, but they're pretty good on the 3rd and very good on the 7th. I still appreciate the realisitc effects of the first trilogy more though. I'll be the one to say that Attack of The Clones is probably the worst Star Wars film. Phantom Menace at least has some cool scenes, but AoTC was such a drag.
AlexKzillion 07.30.16	Agreed Mike, New Hope and Empire are two of the most visually stunning movies I have ever seen. However, I didn't like the CGI in TFA at all, mostly because they relied so much on the realistic effects that when they had to use CGI it just looked fake and completely out of place in the movie.
Crymsonblaze 07.30.16	"The CGI holds up remarkably well in III compared to the rest of the prequels. Also the CGI in the prequels looks way better then every other movie I've seen that used around the same amount of CGI." the CGI is pretty par for the time (that scene on the volcano planet at the end of 3 still looks pretty bad though). i'm moreso talking about the fakey setpieces and horrible green-screening. the prequels look like they could co-exist in the spy kids universe
Valkoor952 07.30.16	I'm sorry but episode 3 looks a lot better than TFA. In TFA they overdid the practical effects to the point shere they looked fake / it looked like an actual set and not a planet far far away. The volcano scenes were amazing wtf. The CGi used there would look great today not to mention 2005.
CaliggyJack 07.30.16	I'd give every single Star Wars a 5/5 so I couldn't put together a ranking. I love star wars
Valkoor952 07.30.16	Jack loves every Star Wars. Be like Jack.
porcupinetheater 07.30.16	"Aliens was far superior to Alien in every aspect though, so..." I'm late, but just woke up to this - whaaaat?
TheMoonchild 07.30.16	Alien and Aliens make up my top 2 films ever made, the reason I give Aliens the edge is because the stakes are much higher, the direction is more involving and the mix of humour, action and even the scary bits (like the swarm of xenomorphs right above the crew in the ceiling) make for some of the most memorable cinema moments ever. Not to mention the face off against the queen at the end! Mind you Alien is basically a completely flawless film. Gorgeously shot, scary as fuck (I got to see it at a cinema a year ago back to back with Aliens and the tension during some of the scenes among the packed crowd was amazing), the anxiety-filled last 20 minutes... even the special effects which look far better than a lot of movies today.
GotDoritos 07.30.16	5 >>> 4 > 6=7 > 3 > holiday special > 2=1
TheMoonchild 07.30.16	IMO. Revenge is the best of the prequels but it's still one of the worst movies I've ever seen. It's like saying a head cold is better than a migraine.
Polyethylene 07.30.16	"IMO. Revenge is the best of the prequels but it's still one of the worst movies I've ever seen. It's like saying a head cold is better than a migraine." this so much
Polyethylene 07.30.16	5 > 7 > 6 > 4 > 3 > 1 > 2
sempiturtle 07.30.16	Everyone complains about Rey defeating Kylo, who should've been dead anyway due to Chewbacca's bowcaster. But no one complains about Luke using the force powers he hasn't even tried before to make an impossible shot and destroy the Death Star.
Valkoor952 07.30.16	It's not impossible though, they even said it before the whole attack started. And yeah he got lucky against a big ass piece of metal, versus Rey getting lucky versus a trained powerful sith, it kinda doesn't hold up.
Valkoor952 07.30.16	Well it's a good thing a lot of people agree that 3 is a good movie then.
TheMoonchild 07.30.16	@semipturtule I'm guessing the reason it didn't affect Kylo that much was because he shot it from a distance and the hit wasn't as strong on Kylo.
TheMoonchild 07.30.16	I love how only one here has mentioned the Holiday Special. One of my favourite bad movies. 10 of the best bucks I've ever spent.
Crymsonblaze 07.30.16	"I'm sorry but episode 3 looks a lot better than TFA. In TFA they overdid the practical effects to the point shere they looked fake / it looked like an actual set and not a planet far far away. The volcano scenes were amazing wtf. The CGi used there would look great today not to mention 2005." lul
Typhoon24 07.30.16	5 > 4 > 7 > 1 (pod racers and darth maul are cool fight me) > rest shit. episode 6 was honestly a nickelodeon comedy show on tatooine and endor with the stunts and gags
TheMoonchild 07.30.16	ROTJ isn't a great film (first half great and then it goes full Beyond Thunderdome in the second) but I'd watch it before any of those horrid prequels.
Valkoor952 07.30.16	Yeah Rotj is a great film, excluding the ewoks, it's pretty much awesome.
Valkoor952 07.30.16	Honestly what the fuck people have problems with episodes 6 and 3 and yet they love episode 7. This is actually depressing tbh. Hollywood are going strong with their brainwashing.
TheMoonchild 07.30.16	"Hollywood are going strong with their brainwashing" lel
FullOfSounds 07.30.16	Revenge of the Sith is really underrated
Ocean of Noise 07.30.16	ROTS is better than ROTJ.
FullOfSounds 07.30.16	Sometimes I can agree with that, sometimes I don't.
AlexKzillion 07.30.16	Don't think they could have done that Luke Vader Emperor sequence any better in VI.
Crymsonblaze 07.30.16	"Revenge of the Sith is really underrated" you are so beautiful. it's only because i'm so in love. no, no. it's because i'm so in love with you. then love has blinded you? well... that's not exactly what i meant. but it's probably true.
TheMoonchild 07.30.16	They could do worse though... like in 2011, when the blu-ray edition inexplicably slipped in a NOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO during that scene.
Insurrection 07.30.16	5 > 4 > 6 > 7 > 3 >>>> 1 > 2
Valkoor952 07.30.16	Ohhhh nooo that's right episode 3 had shit dialogue. That's why episode 7 is great right ? Because of the dialogue. Just check this out> -You got a boyfriend ... ? A cute boyfriend ? That's like some high level Tarantino shit man. Or how bout. - I didn't think there was so much green in the whole galaxy. Or the scene where the genius totally not made for comic relief character of Finn talks smack to Phasma : -Not anymore. The name's Finn and I'm in charge. I'm in charge now, Phasma. I'm in charge." I was cringing so hard at that. The whole dialogue between Han and Leia was absolutely nauseating. That enough for ya ?
Crymsonblaze 07.30.16	"That's why episode 7 is great right ? Because of the dialogue." Umm... no? 7 is very good (not great) because of its tone, acting, writing, and overall universe being much more in line with the original trilogy. Let's not pretend that Star Wars has ever had great dialogue. However, instead of being campy, pulpy fun, as was the intent and result in 4, 5, and 6 (easy to see, given the inspirations), the prequels kept the bad dialogue but excised any and all charm from it via horrible direction and stilted acting (sans Ewan McGregor who has actual superpowers and can generate charm from nothing).
Valkoor952 07.30.16	it's great because of its writing ... but not because of it's dialogue ? ok , dude you win.
SIIMBOLIC 07.30.16	apart from Lord J. Williams, McGregor was the only thing to come out of the PT with a maintained/ increased reputation. It takes a special kind of ineptitude to make liam neeson and sam jackson totally forgettable
Crymsonblaze 07.30.16	"it's great because of its writing ... but not because of it's dialogue ? ok , dude you win." Not sure if you know this, but writing is not comprised solely of dialogue.
Valkoor952 07.30.16	I didn't think Jackson was forgettable, I quite liked him in fact. He wasn't given a big enough role to shine so yeah. @Crymsonblaze Well in a script the dialogue is like 80% of the writing so, if the dialogue is bad you can't really say the writing was great.
AlexKzillion 07.30.16	"and overall universe being much more in line with the original trilogy." Hell fucking no. I agree with the rest of your points although I do really like the prequels.
Crymsonblaze 07.30.16	"Well in a script the dialogue is like 80% of the writing so, if the dialogue is bad you can't really say the writing was great." Did you like, even read what I wrote? Bah, whatever. I have already talked more about RotS then I ever wanted. Outie5000
trackbytrackreviews 07.30.16	I honestly like Ep3 more than Ep6
AlexKzillion 07.30.16	Same
CaliggyJack 07.30.16	This list is really nitpicky because I almost love all of the Star Wars movies equally. 5>1>4>6>7>Clone Wars>2>3 Yeah. I love Phantom Menace. Sue me.
SIIMBOLIC 07.30.16	The difference between 3 and 6 is that 3 had shit loads of ambition and it didnt quite come off, and 6 played it safe and pretty much nailed it. Mcgregor in 3 though should've at least been in the discussion for a best supporting actor nom
SIIMBOLIC 07.30.16	yeah as a movie on its own phantom menace is at all bad imo. I think the huge change of tone and style from the OT is why the backlash is so bad
Valkoor952 07.31.16	Phantom is not bad, agreed.
TheMoonchild 07.31.16	"I saw a video hologram of him... killing younglings." A line from ROTS. Bonus points to Ewan, you can see him visibly try not to burst into laughter while saying that line. I'd take "I'm in charge now, Phasma, I'm in charge" to... uh, that, or "The higher ground? THE HIGHER GROUND???????"
Lord(e)Po)))ts 07.31.16	it really doesnt matter how you rank them as long as you have 1-3 at the bottom
TheMoonchild 07.31.16	^ Pretty much. Potsy has spoken
AlexKzillion 07.31.16	I think you guys are exaggerating the importance of the dialogue problems in these movies.
Valkoor952 07.31.16	What's the problem with the "I saw a hologram of him... killing younglings" How exactly do you want him to word it ? -I saw a digital movie clip of him commiting the act of murder against a group of undeveloped jedi children. That good enough line for you ? Or do you want him to go straight in - Yeah your boyfriend killed the whole academy with dem kids, girl. I understand there's shitty dialogue but this is nitpicking at its highest.
Valkoor952 07.31.16	Pots liked BVS so I'm sorry but he doesn't have ANY kind of authority.