Shakey Graves
Fondness, Etc.


5.0
classic

Review

by Sowing STAFF
May 16th, 2026 | 48 replies


Release Date: 05/15/2026 | Tracklist

Review Summary: Come dream with me

One of the underexamined consequences of aging is that it completely warps your perception of time. Most of us can recall how summer seemed to last forever as a child, but as an adult the calendar pages all blur together. Hell, it’s been eight whole years since I relished Can’t Wake Up’s eerie, starlit atmosphere, yet the moment that ‘Counting Sheep’ first gave me chills still feels like it was only a couple months ago. If Fondness, etc. is any indication, Alejandro Rose-Garcia senses this phenomenon as well, and explores it in depth through his music. The artist’s fifth full-length album is a stripped-down work that also functions as a total creative reset on the heels of 2023’s sleek indie-pop; the lukewarmly received Movie of the Week. In rather stark contrast, Fondness, etc. buzzes with tender lo-fi imperfections and hazy edges that make the whole thing crackle. It’s all very dreamlike, washing over you with warmth and proximity in a way I haven’t felt since perhaps Lord Huron’s Long Lost. There’s a magic to this that simply can’t be manufactured – listening to it is akin to sinking into a fond memory, and with that the record’s title suddenly makes sense.

As my wife and I casually strolled up the stone path that led into the heart of the beach town we were staying in, the air was heavy. It was July and we were on our honeymoon, and it was the kind of oppressive heat that makes the simplest things feel like exercise. We were seeking out a unique breakfast experience, and stumbled upon a quaint building with vines growing up the side. Perched on a ledge by the front door was a colorful songbird that my wife was able to name at the time, but now it escapes me. We took a seat in the backyard of the restaurant, at a black metal table that seemed to only magnify the heat of the still young day. On the patio, a man quietly strummed an acoustic guitar, picking at the strings with a grace and elegance that was perhaps partially imagined thanks to the lovestruck atmosphere, but that has nevertheless become lore now in my mind. To this day I remember that morning, and that place, as one of the most peaceful moments of my entire life. Things simply couldn’t get better than they were at that time. Some people look back at such memories with longing, almost regret, that whatever life they’ve fashioned since then doesn’t quite compare. I think that we should be grateful if we ever have moment so fond, a distillation or representation of a specific point in time that we can always look back upon and realize, even if only in hindsight, that it was indeed perfect.

Fondness, etc. might be the closest I’ve come to reliving that moment. Rose-Garcia’s guitars here ring out with pristine clarity, yet sound so far away – as if they’re echoing through time. There’s no shortage of tranquil, intimate moments here, but the one that sticks out to me every time I spin this is ‘I Once Was An Ocean’ – a brilliant five minute instrumental track that feels equidistant to both a tropical island and an old Western movie. Songbirds serenade the opening seconds before Rose-Garcia’s melodic chords take over like a tour guide through all of your most cherished recollections. I can’t listen to it and not lose myself; its transfixing and transportive, a masterclass in atmosphere capable of sweeping me from even the most hectic junctures of my day. It’s the same way I feel about the aptly titled ‘Time Flies’, which swells with rich, flourishing strings that amorously intertwine with sweeping, soulfully cascading guitar chords swaying with a gorgeous, lush ambiance. Rose-Garcia’s voice doesn’t dominate, instead becoming one with the surrounding bliss and willingly fading into it. If there were to be a musical equivalent to how I felt that on that balmy morning many years ago, the pairing of these songs together might just be it.

Fondness, etc. remains abuzz with breathtaking melodies, experimental textures, and minimal tones for the majority of its nine song duration, ensnaring you within its beautiful mini-world. ‘The Boilermaker’ has a toe-tapping beat born of muted bass drums, subtle claps, and driving rhythmic guitars. ‘Don’t Change a Thing’ is bluesy and yearning, led by its proximal front porch acoustic vibe, distantly wailing synths, and a warm, embracing chorus. The instrumental track ‘Suddenly’ feels like traveling through time, replete with distant, disorienting clock bells/chimes striking at random. I could wax poetic about every individual track here, because they all possess their own innately unique and alluring traits, but I also believe that part of Fondness, etc.’s mystique comes from simply letting it wash over you for the first time with no prior assumptions. It may take some time to sink in, but it will.

By the closing ‘No Place to Be’, it feels like snapping back to the present – the dreamy guitars are replaced by raw, organic strums, and Rose-Garcia’s voice feels just a tad crisper. He sings, “Well, I ain't got no place to be / Might as well take in the scenery / As long as you're right here with me / Then this life will finally be easy”, and I look up from my laptop. The morning sun is coming through the curtains, and I hear little footsteps awakening upstairs. It's no longer ten years ago, surrounded by sun and salt-rich air, but somehow this precise moment feels just as perfect – maybe just a little different. The tricky thing with looking back fondly on the past is that no matter how nice it feels, it’s best not to dwell there for too long. It keeps you from living in the present with the same ardor, fashioning newly perfect moments to add to the emotional scrapbook. It sounds like idealism, and it is, but if that isn’t at least what we should be pursuing, then I’ve lost the plot. And maybe that’s not the worst thing that can happen in this crazy world. Chasing the fantasy is all we can do…so come dream with me.



Recent reviews by this author
Manchester Orchestra Union Chapel (London, England)The All-American Rejects Sandbox
Kevin Morby Little Wide OpenThe Milk Carton Kids Lost Cause Lover Fool
Tigers Jaw Lost on YouThe Fray A Light That Waits
user ratings (14)
3.9
excellent


Comments:Add a Comment 
Sowing
Moderator
May 16th 2026


45911 Comments

Album Rating: 5.0

Best Shakey Graves to date. Album is an absolute lo-fi gem.

AlkemestRedux
Contributing Reviewer
May 16th 2026


2576 Comments

Album Rating: 4.0

Oh wow! Man I can't wait to jam this one. Great review.

LouBreed
May 16th 2026


569 Comments


Eh, those opening sentences are spot on. I don't mind some gray hair in my scalp or the fact that I get tired a bit faster, but what I wouldn't give to get back the young perception of time. It's already mid-May, and it feels like February was just two weeks ago

This doesn't seem like my thing to be honest, but I will give it a try

Sowing
Moderator
May 16th 2026


45911 Comments

Album Rating: 5.0

Thanks Alkemest! Let me know what you think.



Lou, agreed completely. The way time goes faster every year is a source of minor frustration because it feels like life is slipping away, but at the same time, it beats not having that time at all. The only thing to do is live every day its fullest, as much as you reasonably can given responsibilities. It definitely resides within a very niche lo-fi folk sound, so if that's not your typical vibe this may not convert you. I do think this is incredibly lush and enjoyable though, so who knows!

Hawks
Staff Reviewer
May 16th 2026


125445 Comments

Album Rating: 3.9

This rules.

Sowing
Moderator
May 16th 2026


45911 Comments

Album Rating: 5.0

Hell yeah, redeemed after MKC ;-)

If I have a single complaint its that the best songs are backloaded, so as usual I've rearranged things for those interested in something that might flow even better [and, as per recent tradition, my track ratings in brackets]

When The Love Is New [4.2]

I Once Was An Ocean [4.7]

Time Flies [5]

Don't Change A Thing [4.5]

The Boilermaker [4]

Away It Goes [4]

Suddenly [3.5]

On My Own [4]

No Place To Be [4]

Hawks
Staff Reviewer
May 16th 2026


125445 Comments

Album Rating: 3.9

Hahahaha yessssss. Time Flies is probably my fav here, what a banger, but the whole thing is super consistent!

CrisStyles
May 17th 2026


930 Comments


Also haven't listened to a Shakey Graves album in many, many years. Will add this one to the list as well.

Sowing
Moderator
May 17th 2026


45911 Comments

Album Rating: 5.0

Yeah Hawks, 'Time Flies' is pure bliss. I could listen to it all day. I Once Was An Ocean is also amazing, as is Don't Change a Thing. When The Love Is New would have make a strong opener, hence why I changed up the tracklist a bit for myself. I'm listening to The Boilermaker now and it's super lush, sheesh. This album is amazing man, first time this year I felt comfortable handing out the 5 without hesitation.

You'll have to let me know what you think CrisStyles, but I hope you enjoy it. His pre-Can't Wake Up material was pretty decent, Can't Wake Up was always his best by a mile (IMO), and then Movie of the Week felt like a different artist completely and I was not a big fan of the (again, IMO) watered down indie pop. Fondness, Etc. is a back to basics palate cleanser. I've been waking up with this album and my morning coffee, and it's super chill. The aura is so peaceful and dreamy. I do think it'll take some warming up for just about anyone though, because it's admittedly pretty stripped down and lo-fi.

DoofDoof
May 17th 2026


17870 Comments

Album Rating: 4.0

A 5?



Damn, guess I give this a shot!

Sowing
Moderator
May 17th 2026


45911 Comments

Album Rating: 5.0

It's been an amazing weekend for folk/Americana between this and Kevin Morby. Would strongly recommend both.

DoofDoof
May 17th 2026


17870 Comments

Album Rating: 4.0

I too have experienced that 'honeymoon nostalgia', I feel a very different person to 9 years ago, I don't know if the world is genuinely more threatening and troubling now or if that's just heightened threat response from parenthood.



I can recall almost every moment from my three week (!) honeymoon but it feels light years away, but I love that time and who we were then as a couple...



The most visceral symbol of those memories being something I can't return to is seeing the pictures of Jasper Main Street in Canada in flames during the wild fires. Real tragic, we stayed in the area for five days.



Started listening now and this does seem excellent, great review Sowing.

DoofDoof
May 17th 2026


17870 Comments

Album Rating: 4.0

The Morby was already on the list but this might have been lost in the shuffle so thanks.

Sowing
Moderator
May 17th 2026


45911 Comments

Album Rating: 5.0

---I don't know if the world is genuinely more threatening and troubling now or if that's just heightened threat response from parenthood---

Probably both. I feel like an old man talking this way, but there was something simpler about the 2010s. Even the problems the world had weren't as sinister, or at least didn't feel that way to me at the time. I could lose myself in important life moments a whole lot easier without my mind constantly racing. Part of why I love this album so much is because it gives me that honeymoon nostalgia, taking me back to 2015 when things were just...better.



---The most visceral symbol of those memories being something I can't return to is seeing the pictures of Jasper Main Street in Canada in flames during the wild fires---

That's awful and also such an apt metaphor for not being able to return to the past



Last but not least, happy to help spread the word about this. For whatever reason it doesn't seem to be getting a whole lot of coverage. I think 2023's Movie of the Week was kind of a flop as his mainstream bid, so I've read that this was meant to be a creative reset for him. I love the new direction.

DoofDoof
May 17th 2026


17870 Comments

Album Rating: 4.0

This seems a lot more direct and classic to me, this is much more my thing than his other stuff (which was still good don't get me wrong).



I guess the late 2010s was that last period of time before Covid>Ukraine>Iran....but also it might just be a time of life thing to some degree

Sowing
Moderator
May 17th 2026


45911 Comments

Album Rating: 5.0

Agreed, direct and classic are two good descriptors. I also enjoyed his prior material, but this just taps into the precise vibe/nostalgia that I love. It's so easy to sink into.

AlkemestRedux
Contributing Reviewer
May 18th 2026


2576 Comments

Album Rating: 4.0

This is a great listen! Definitely gonna give it some more, but it's a hard 4 on first listen. Dug it!

Hawks
Staff Reviewer
May 18th 2026


125445 Comments

Album Rating: 3.9

Rules hard agreed bros!

AlkemestRedux
Contributing Reviewer
May 18th 2026


2576 Comments

Album Rating: 4.0

Big agree. The whole lofi synth sounds were v nice and caught me off guard.

Hawks
Staff Reviewer
May 18th 2026


125445 Comments

Album Rating: 3.9

I loooooove lofi folk stuff like this.



You have to be logged in to post a comment. Login | Create a Profile





STAFF & CONTRIBUTORS // CONTACT US

Bands: A B C D E F G H I J K L M N O P Q R S T U V W X Y Z


Site Copyright 2005-2023 Sputnikmusic.com
All Album Reviews Displayed With Permission of Authors | Terms of Use | Privacy Policy