White Lies
To Lose My Life


3.0
good

Review

by robin EMERITUS
January 20th, 2009 | 16 replies


Release Date: 2009 | Tracklist

Review Summary: Close to catchy, but could be bigger yet.

Despite the ridiculous climax to its release, To Lose My Life is released pretty much every year. The Killers, Editors et al have been down the same road with their music, but it was just that there was so much hype overflowing from the year-to-year transitions for White Lies that it was probably an impossibility for the Londoners to not stir just a little bit of disappointment. They appeared on Jools Holland’s floundering show before the fuss started, went on to promote with some numerous shows, and sparked the interest of quite enough British publications. Inside the band, stark movements occurred from happy to sad, from Fear of Flying to White Lies (the name change apparently significant news), and, inevitably, they grew up and became another post-punk act. So, unfortunately, To Lose My Life has plummeted from its build up.

A statement about as bombastic as the band’s music attempts to sound prophesises White Lies as a dark, doom ‘n’ gloom outfit who are, just to cite their influences, taking music to depressing routes. It’s music more contained in their roots, of course, but if that’s the case, “Death” should be an introduction that channels a long-winded Joy Division escapade. There have been comparisons, but this isn’t exactly the case; while White Lies certainly sound fresh from the subdued synth and all too familiar for their guitar work, “Death” sounds more in touch with “No I In Threesome” – Interpol’s very happiest. The group live nostalgia through other bands that once lived on nostalgia. “A Place To Hide”, for instance, takes a loud, wacky swipe at reality that comes right out of The Killers book (and, for some keyboard mix-up, even sounds not too wide of Keane). The Londoners sort of give a shy effort, and along with all the other blockbusters of smashing guitar-chords – “Farewell to the Fairground” the largest track to never sparkle during chorus – it’s sort of too light-hearted for Harry McVeigh to get grandiose over.

And yes, it’s overflowing with blockbusters, but it’s the bravado that comes out best. “Unfinished Business” bursts open with that so important epic atmosphere, and from then on becomes a song segmented into parts of slow synth ballad, loud pop choruses and hammering guitar pauses. It’s all strung together by McVeigh’s voice, which here works perfectly because he’s crying ridiculous contradictions (You’ve got blood on your hands and I know it’s mine/So let’s dance like we used to) and acting overly passionate. He gives “Unfinished Business” a bonus to the powerful new wave sound White Lies should just own up to.

This sound is no fluke, because in EST he’s going through it all again, packing in lyricism about old stereotypes and wailing Now be a good girl and do what you’re told. The effect, the same: an overflow of emotion for a fairly emotionless backdrop of spiky synthesiser, bass and little else. For the central tracks of the album – these two and “From The Stars”, made of nothing but a daydream – White Lies create blissful music that proves they can attune their marathon sound. For the rest of the album, all is left is a dreamy haze. “The Price of Love” almost reaches the same heights, with the 20-piece orchestra making in-out entrances to prove just how huge To Lose My Life is. But because McVeigh can’t quite make his music (or fellow musicians) sound so cogent and larger than life, he’s left crying every word to make up for it. He becomes the only one who sounds up for it, and that isn’t enough.



Recent reviews by this author
Angelo De Augustine Swim Inside the MoonJeff Rosenstock Worry.
Okkervil River AwayOren Ambarchi, Kassel Jaeger, James Rushford Pale Calling
Huerco S For Those of You Who Have Never...The Mountain Goats Get Lonely
user ratings (202)
Chart.
3.5
great
other reviews of this album
AliW1993 (3.5)
A very promising debut, solid foundations from which White Lies can become bigger and better....

related reviews

Big TV

Ritual

Comments:Add a Comment 
AliW1993
January 20th 2009


7511 Comments

Album Rating: 4.0

Good review, though I think the album is a little better than you give it credit for.

Fugue
January 20th 2009


7371 Comments


yeah good review Robin, is this worth a punt or am I better off sticking with the killers new album?

ClearTheLane
January 21st 2009


990 Comments

Album Rating: 3.0

Yeah, this was kind of a disappointment. Nothing original really.

But good review mate.

robin
Emeritus
January 21st 2009


4437 Comments


thanks guys. this isnt as long as i would have liked, but i dont think i can do much more. :/

ross, i've only heard two tracks off day + age - "human" which i didn't care for, and "goodnight travel well" which easily trumps anything on here.

Fugue
January 21st 2009


7371 Comments


Yeah, I found "Day and Age" to be infuriatingly inconsistent like that, although I for one like "Humans". Think I'll give this a miss for now.

gaslightanthem
January 22nd 2009


5209 Comments


this sucked, it's both unoriginal and at times plain derivative

robin
Emeritus
January 22nd 2009


4437 Comments


means the same thing tbh :p

gaslightanthem
January 22nd 2009


5209 Comments


idk i think you can lack originality without being completely derivative

robin
Emeritus
January 22nd 2009


4437 Comments


i guess. i wouldn't say this is as bad as you say, but the fact that it's been done so much does put me off. got to kind of take a realistic view though when so many artists do this.

Fugue
January 22nd 2009


7371 Comments


I know it hasn't had many votes, but a 2.8 average is kind of bad.

Knott-
Emeritus
January 22nd 2009


10198 Comments


i think this is f**king awful.

it's like a completely soulless version of Editors.

robin
Emeritus
January 22nd 2009


4437 Comments


i never thought the editors had soul.

Fugue
January 22nd 2009


7371 Comments


Editors first album was pretty good,the second was nothing great though, so if this is worse...

Knott-
Emeritus
January 22nd 2009


10198 Comments


Oh, it's definitely worse.

I like Editors' 2 LPs - especially the first. But these guys are just pointless. Title-track holds its own. Rest of album is dire. It probably doesn't even deserve my 2



robin
Emeritus
January 22nd 2009


4437 Comments


this isn't 'souless' in comparison to the editors to be fair, in fact i would say the editors write music about as mediocre as this. the album may be completely derivative but tracks like 'unfinished business' make up for it, as some tracks by the editors can do, similarly.



VikkiH
January 25th 2009


240 Comments


Yeah this album was quite a disapointment for me.

Good review



You have to be logged in to post a comment. Login | Create a Profile





STAFF & CONTRIBUTORS // SITE FORUM // CONTACT US

Bands: A B C D E F G H I J K L M N O P Q R S T U V W X Y Z


Site Copyright 2005-2017 Sputnikmusic.com
All Album Reviews Displayed With Permission of Authors | Terms of Use | Privacy Policy