Kanye West Takes On T.I.

2018-04-28 by CaliggyJack | 298 Comments
https://consequenceofsound.net/2018/04/kanye-west-shares-aptly-titled-ye-vs-the-people-collaboration-with-t-i-stream/


Kanye West has released a second song on his site entitled 'Ye vs The People', in which he and T.I. have a rap debate over Kanye's recent support of Donald Trump.


According to Consequence of Sound:


... the track functions like a political debate between West and T.I, during which T.I. spars with West over his comments while West elaborates on his recent actions. “I never, ever stopped fighting for the people/It’s actually wearing the hat that show people we equal,” he raps. Elsewhere, he rhymes, “Make America Great Again had a negative reception/I took it, wore it, rocked it, gave it a new direction.” Better this than another Twitter rant?


He and T.I. touch on issues of police brutality, political affiliation, and also mention “the sunken place,” a reference to Jordan Peele’s Get Out that West has referenced a great deal on Twitter.



Both this song and his previous single "Lift Yourself" are available to listen to on his site.


http://www.kanyewest.com/

Tagged: Kanye West

Comments:Add a Comment 
Sharkattack
April 28th 2018
1731 Comments


Oh my fucking god I just want this guy to go away already

CaliggyJack
April 28th 2018
10036 Comments


"Oh my fucking god I just want this guy to go away already "

When pigs fly bruh

Prancer
April 28th 2018
1601 Comments


WOOP DEE DEE SCOOP POOP

Nicksput
April 28th 2018
24 Comments


Fucking brilliant.

Toad
April 28th 2018
2061 Comments


Lift Yourself > It's OK to Like Trump Let's All Get Along

JeetJeet
April 28th 2018
12160 Comments


This song is the equivalent of talking a lot without saying anything.

Drifter
April 28th 2018
20820 Comments


Shark Kanye rules

MyShadow
April 28th 2018
778 Comments


good song

Tyler.
April 28th 2018
19020 Comments


He needs to pull a Cobain. His legacy would explode even more.

????

MO
April 28th 2018
24016 Comments


"Oh my fucking god I just want this guy to go away already "

he's more woke than ever and redpilling the masses, he ain't going nowhere lmao

rabidfish
April 28th 2018
8690 Comments


Kanye for comedy AOTY.

Sharkattack
April 29th 2018
1731 Comments


Tyler Kurt Cobain committed suicide

someguest
April 29th 2018
30126 Comments


Does this mean T.I. supports Trump too? lmao

VaxXi
April 29th 2018
4418 Comments


'Tyler Kurt Cobain committed suicide'
he knows.

GhandhiLion
April 29th 2018
17641 Comments


Kanye 4 prez

Sharkattack
April 29th 2018
1731 Comments


Yeah vax but he just put a bunch of question marks so I just figured Kanye west fans didn’t know who he was or something

oltnabrick
April 29th 2018
40630 Comments


maga

someguest
April 29th 2018
30126 Comments


I got about a minute into the first one and ten seconds into the second before I turned them off.

Ryus
April 29th 2018
36626 Comments


lift yourself is infinitely better

Cygnatti
April 29th 2018
36021 Comments


[2]

EnyaFangirl
April 29th 2018
1822 Comments


the song New Slaves is actually about conservatives on college campuses

Rowan5215
Staff Reviewer
April 29th 2018
47594 Comments


this is trash but bear in mind it was recorded the day before release to try and appease some of the upset fanbase

aka hopefully it's this album's Facts

Eons
April 29th 2018
3770 Comments


He doesn't support Trump (100% guaranteed) he only wants to cause controversy and get talked about in the media. He's really a pathetic person, to be honest. He has no sense of artistry whatsoever. which is disappointing. Some of his earlier work was subtly interesting and had artistic merit. Now he's just a fucking meme of himself.

foxblood
April 29th 2018
11159 Comments


it's really hard to like either of these guys now. kinda sucks

AlexKzillion
April 29th 2018
17133 Comments


Please tell me this isn't gonna be on the album.

AlexKzillion
April 29th 2018
17133 Comments


Like this isn't even a song really

Meridiu5
April 29th 2018
4165 Comments


Kanye is a master of playing the media

EnyaFangirl
April 29th 2018
1822 Comments


https://twitter.com/kanyewest/status/990397560878645248

ok this whole thing is extremely funny now

foxblood
April 29th 2018
11159 Comments


wtf?

AlexKzillion
April 29th 2018
17133 Comments


Woah he supports both sides...

...just like he said in the song...

...fascinating

EnyaFangirl
April 29th 2018
1822 Comments


i'm not going to listen to it

foxblood
April 29th 2018
11159 Comments


I made the mistake of listening. I gained nothing from that experience. I couldn't really even call that rapping?

AlexKzillion
April 29th 2018
17133 Comments


Just tack on an angry Eminem verse at the the end and this wouldn't sound out of place on Revival tbh

rabidfish
April 29th 2018
8690 Comments


shit's been funny as hell for years, mate

JJKeys
April 29th 2018
1322 Comments


uhhhh lemme get uhhHHhh A O T Y

TheArtofTheGanja
April 29th 2018
389 Comments


i was going to say "bunch of cucks itt" but in the spirit of kanye, i love you all

JJKeys
April 29th 2018
1322 Comments


Lift Yourself confirmed for song of the year

henryChinaski
April 29th 2018
5014 Comments


Fuck this guy.

StrizzMatik
April 29th 2018
4156 Comments


Kanye's right, he's redpilled af and the butthurt on the internet is delicious

JeetJeet
April 29th 2018
12160 Comments


^^^Cringe

Rolling Girl
April 29th 2018
2028 Comments


Just in case you need another reason to hate Kanye

TheJunkhead
April 29th 2018
52 Comments


Lift Yourself is hilarious

gotsthedewsdood
April 29th 2018
754 Comments


Hopefully this doesn't turn up on the new album.

Ebola
April 29th 2018
4515 Comments


Terrible

deathschool
April 29th 2018
28620 Comments


I've always dug TI more than Kanye, so maybe I feel better about that now

foxblood
April 29th 2018
11159 Comments


'he's redpilled af'

lol no he's really not

DatsNotDaMetulz
April 29th 2018
4309 Comments


The only red pill is the one for communism.

deathschool
April 29th 2018
28620 Comments


m/





TheArtofTheGanja
April 29th 2018
389 Comments


y'all blue pillers

SCREAM!
April 29th 2018
15755 Comments


Nothing compares to these blue and yellow purple pills

JayEnder
April 29th 2018
19768 Comments


Never understood the appeal of this dude honestly

gryndstone
April 29th 2018
2730 Comments


he's just a narcissist that's glad to see that a celebrity can get into office on ideas alone. he doesn't support trump, he supports himself

tigersbrokefree
April 29th 2018
375 Comments


Idiota

DreamAgain
April 29th 2018
2469 Comments


People: "Kanye West is the voice of a generation. A musical genius that even beethoven would be jealous of"

> Kanye says he likes Trump

People: "OMG i just want this fucking guy to go away already, who listens to this trash"

lmao

Calc
April 29th 2018
17339 Comments


"People: "Kanye West is the voice of a generation. A musical genius that even beethoven would be jealous of"

zero people not named Kayne West have ever said this seriously.


saw a funny picture of Kayne's MAGA hat where someone changed it to "Make College Dropout Again"

alienobserver
April 29th 2018
4499 Comments


SCOOPTITY POOP SCOOP

DatsNotDaMetulz
April 29th 2018
4309 Comments


I took the red and black pill.

FrancieBrady
April 29th 2018
17 Comments


As a bipolar asshole, this guy is a raging bipolar asshole. He could be forcibly committed if his family had any balls. Public rants, presumably not in treatment, not on or taking meds, danger to at least himself...

SCREAM!
April 29th 2018
15755 Comments


Tell us more about what you read on webMD

Ebola
April 29th 2018
4515 Comments


I don't even care that he likes Trump. He's free to hold whatever beliefs he chooses. He could perfectly align with me on every issue and this song would still suck. Because it's bad.

SexualManChocolate
April 29th 2018
236 Comments


This is why Kanye is and will go down as the greatest of all time

robertsona
Staff Reviewer
April 29th 2018
27404 Comments


I can’t stop listening to this.

ScuroFantasma
Emeritus
April 29th 2018
11971 Comments


Hip hop debate track, I dig it

EnyaFangirl
April 30th 2018
1822 Comments


can't wait for the pizzagate anthem

xfearbefore
April 30th 2018
2038 Comments


It's not bad as a teaser, T.I. sounds good. Definitely better than that troll song Lift Yourself.

But damn Ye you trying to make your fans hate you?

Sharkattack
April 30th 2018
1731 Comments


Dude just commit suicide then everyone will love you and your reputation will become exponentially better

Hawks
April 30th 2018
87047 Comments


I love Kanye's early music and some of his more recent stuff but he sucks so fucking much.

theYearis1999
April 30th 2018
146 Comments


Oh shit, this has created quite the show

lecolumbus
April 30th 2018
227 Comments


kanye didn't make a single good point on this song and everything T.I. says in the song is right. he has an incredibly misguided view of what MAGA stands for and he's so incredibly wrong and naive to think he could steer it in the direction he desires or that he's doing that right now somehow

the irony of kanye saying "You just readin' the headlines, you don't see the fine print" when he's said he hasn't done enough research to confirm if he's a conservative or not
I guess good work for managing to put out a song that's dumber than the poopity scoopity song less than 24 hrs later

BlackMalachite
April 30th 2018
3711 Comments


I remember like a month ago Kanye could do no wrong in the eyes of the public, and if you didnt like him you were considered a racist. It's really sad how quickly people will turn on someone they claim to love just because of ideological differences. I still think Kanye sucks, but I respect him for sticking to his guns on this.

JeetJeet
April 30th 2018
12160 Comments


lol the only people thinking Kanye can do no wrong are his fanboys who will praise anything he does. And we all know how out of touch they are.

guitarded_chuck
April 30th 2018
18070 Comments


dude people have been shitting on kanye en masse for a decade

ZombieToyDuck
April 30th 2018
7203 Comments


what the hell was that ending on lift yourself? lmao

Ebola
April 30th 2018
4515 Comments


"I remember like a month ago Kanye could do no wrong in the eyes of the public, and if you didnt like him you were considered a racist."

For the most part, Kanye has been out of style for the last 5+ years. Your point here is simply, objectively incorrect. Nice straw man, though.

iglu
April 30th 2018
1740 Comments


I love how genuinely upset some people are about one damn person.

ktjammin
April 30th 2018
342 Comments


LOOOOOOOL

guitarded_chuck
April 30th 2018
18070 Comments


Im hyped for the album I couldn't give less of a shit about his politics [2]


altho i find his antics entertaining

emester
April 30th 2018
8271 Comments


Kinda unironically love Lift Yourself. That soul/gospel sample is fucking on point.

Ye vs. tho may actually be his worst track ever, even with politics aside

SCREAM!
April 30th 2018
15755 Comments


Lift Yourself is hilarious in a way that I think only Kanye can pull off

disciple31
May 1st 2018
41 Comments


kanye is the greatest spectacle of our time and it's all a part of his bit. he's actually a genius

Deez
May 1st 2018
10314 Comments


he's actually a retard'


There you go, fixed.

StrizzMatik
May 2nd 2018
4156 Comments


lecolumbus reading his sociology professor's diary itt

Deathconscious
May 2nd 2018
27347 Comments


"400 years of slavery? Sounds like a choice!"

He actually said this.

AlexKzillion
May 2nd 2018
17133 Comments


It's obvious what he was actually trying to say... he just said it in by far the dumbest and most indefensible way he possibly could.

Calc
May 2nd 2018
17339 Comments


yeah my wife is pretty pissed about that little quip of his

JWT155
May 2nd 2018
14948 Comments


Is Kanye's slavery comments though a comment on people still claiming that African Americans are still enslaved? I think his comments were more or less that if people still claim they're enslaved in 2018 then it's because of their doing.

Keyblade
May 2nd 2018
30678 Comments


even that charitable reading of what he said is still dumb af

JWT155
May 2nd 2018
14948 Comments


I concur.

SCREAM!
May 2nd 2018
15755 Comments


Yeah I think he explained it something along those lines. That 400 years later, people need to get out of this mindset if they want to prosper.

Although I'm not sure where he came up with this 400 years number. 150 might have been closer to reality and then all the direct and indirect repercussions that followed.

Doctuses
May 2nd 2018
1914 Comments


Kanye is ill/disturbed. Anyone who with a straight face says that slavery was a choice, a) doesn't know anything about slavery, b) is divorced from reality 3) has an ego so grandiose he's trapped in his own mind.

iglu
May 2nd 2018
1740 Comments


it made sense to me

JWT155
May 2nd 2018
14948 Comments


Again, I don't agree with Kanye's comments but people are being ignorant distorting his comments: I'm pretty sure he's talking about people now believing they are still in slavery, not those historically enslaved on this continent for hundreds of years.

Doctuses
May 2nd 2018
1914 Comments


around late 17th century-1960. that's where people get the 400 number from from. african slaves began being imported to the americas in large numbers around that time, and slavery did in fact continue after the emancipation proclamation. furthermore, it's not that controversial that until the end of jim crow you can consider african americans if not technically enslaved then so sufficiently oppressed it's arguably comparable to the pre-war era.

Doctuses
May 2nd 2018
1914 Comments


"slavery was a choice" yeah I don't know how you read anything else from that. and this is kanye west we're talking about, not an american history scholar.

Doctuses
May 2nd 2018
1914 Comments


he also said something like, we had the numbers to not be enslaved, so it's actually you who are reading something else into his comments that are not there.

JWT155
May 2nd 2018
14948 Comments


I agree, but for all intents and purposes I think Kanye is referring to African Americans of 2018, not pre 1965 Voting Rights Act.

Edit: Well if he said the numbers thing then he is just an idiot.

Doctuses
May 2nd 2018
1914 Comments


"I love how genuinely upset some people are about one damn person."

I love the meta comments about people getting upset about one person as if that's a hot take

AlexKzillion
May 2nd 2018
17133 Comments


Agree with JWT

I'm like 99% sure the 400 years he's referring to is 1619 (the year the first slave ships arrived in the new world) to 2018

iglu
May 2nd 2018
1740 Comments


what he was saying is that if people were in a bad situation for so long then it's because they didn't do enough to try stop it, it can apply to anyone not just slaves, obviously it wasn't their choice in the first place but it was their choice to do something about it.

AlexKzillion
May 2nd 2018
17133 Comments


Yeah exactly

Pretty common conservative narrative/ideal from what I understand

Just a dumb narrative/ideal that was presented in an even dumber way

Trebor.
Emeritus
May 2nd 2018
59835 Comments


It's a pretty absurd argument, just like most conservative testaments


JeetJeet
May 2nd 2018
12160 Comments


What he said and what he meant to say is dumb as fuck either way. That whole "black people still have a slave mentality today" bullshit gets parroted by the worst types of people.

Doctuses
May 2nd 2018
1914 Comments


"It's a pretty absurd argument, just like most conservative testaments"

yup and yet people defend him

Trebor.
Emeritus
May 2nd 2018
59835 Comments


I wish I had been in the same ward as Kanye. Shit would have been tight

JeetJeet
May 2nd 2018
12160 Comments


Ye's whole album rollout is him proving he's not as smart as the people who put him on a pedestal claim he is. Its so entertaining.

CaliggyJack
May 2nd 2018
10036 Comments


"It's a pretty absurd argument, just like most conservative testaments"

Really? Come on dude. Not like fucking Progressive's don't have their fair share of idiotic statements.

guitarded_chuck
May 2nd 2018
18070 Comments


hes just trying to be edgy for publicity obviously

guitarded_chuck
May 2nd 2018
18070 Comments


im not being forgiving of him for it btw but i still dont give a shit about the dudes opinions just make good music

AlexKzillion
May 2nd 2018
17133 Comments


Kanye will be on Infowars today lmfao

JWT155
May 2nd 2018
14948 Comments


GTFO

guitarded_chuck
May 2nd 2018
18070 Comments


lol sick

EnyaFangirl
May 2nd 2018
1822 Comments


silver surfer intermission except it's an advert for SUPER MALE VITALITY

BigHans
May 2nd 2018
30959 Comments


How can ONE MAN HAVE ALL THAT POWER??

guitarded_chuck
May 2nd 2018
18070 Comments


I AM A GOD

doot doot doot dootdootdoot







I AM A GOD


dududu dudu


AHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHH

guitarded_chuck
May 2nd 2018
18070 Comments


HURRY UP WITH MY DAMN CROISSANTS

BigHans
May 2nd 2018
30959 Comments


HAVE YOU EVER ASKED YOUR BITCH FOR OTHER BITCHES?

guitarded_chuck
May 2nd 2018
18070 Comments


alex got me watching alex jones and they havent said hes gonna be on so dont think thats a thing unfortunately

ScorpionStan
May 2nd 2018
1911 Comments


To everyone commenting on his "400 years of slavery sounds like a choice" statement

His exact clarification is:

"Of course I know that slaves did not get shackled and put on a boat by free will. My point is for us to have stayed in that position even though the numbers were on our side means that we were mentally enslaved."

Which is a fair point. He's just saying hey, we're always complaining about being behind in society...well isn't 400 years plenty of time to figure out the reality of our situation and how to get it turned around? Did we really give as much of an effort to improve our situation as we could have all this time?

Obviously it's a super nuanced issue and his initial statement was completely lacking any semblance of nuance whatsoever...but if you actually think about the big picture for 2 seconds instead of just making a snap judgement based only on his initial statement, it makes a lot of sense. Let's not pretend Stockholm syndrome doesn't exist.

AlexKzillion
May 2nd 2018
17133 Comments


Alex Jones is a big fat liar then: https://mobile.twitter.com/realalexjones/status/991721835816505344?s=21

guitarded_chuck
May 2nd 2018
18070 Comments


fuckk outta here with that objective perspective im trying to be a defender of the good over here

guitarded_chuck
May 2nd 2018
18070 Comments


idk maybe he is he didnt mention it when i was watching

Doctuses
May 2nd 2018
1914 Comments


"Really? Come on dude. Not like fucking Progressive's don't have their fair share of idiotic statements.
"
Immaterial. We're not talking about progressives right now are we.


Doctuses
May 2nd 2018
1914 Comments


alex jones gave this country aids

Sharkattack
May 2nd 2018
1731 Comments


Dude I was so hoping that would be the gay frogs remix and I’m so stoked you didn’t disappoint.

ScuroFantasma
Emeritus
May 2nd 2018
11971 Comments


I get that perhaps Kanye hasn't exaclty earned a charitable approach for some of you, but to see his original statement boiled down to "Slavery was a choice" - Kanye 2018, and a few of you are buying that, is pretty concerning. I don't follow Kanye, but doesn't that comment seem too outrageous to be true? Almost as though it was completely removed from context and nuance? Well I thought so, which is why in about 5 seconds of searching I found the original video and his follow up statement on the same page, Lo and behold it's pretty clear from both what he's actually tying to say, some unfortunate word choice aside. Psychological oppression plays a huge role in tyrannising a group - obviously he wasn't saying slaves were totally down for what they went through, he's saying that they were mentally conditioned to remain in slavery, and he's drawing parallels to his whole "free-thought" thingie that he's going through now or whatever, telling people not to keep themselves down.

Sharkattack
May 2nd 2018
1731 Comments


Besides like overly sensitive SJW anti-hate speech shit what is so idiotic about progressives anyway?

Doctuses
May 3rd 2018
1914 Comments


kanye west thinks he so original, fuck him gay bars were original once too.

Eons
May 3rd 2018
3770 Comments


Morons take this guy seriously as he hypes up whatever he's got going on through controversy. The media, fans, everybody plays right into his ploy and gives him exactly what he needs. Idiots.

Doctuses
May 3rd 2018
1914 Comments


"Morons take this guy seriously as he hypes up whatever he's got going on through controversy. The media, fans, everybody plays right into his ploy and gives him exactly what he needs. Idiots. "

hot take alert , relax bitch aint like anyone here is going out buying yeezys and if you are then you probably like neurosis and dicks up your ass

Sharkattack
May 3rd 2018
1731 Comments


Do you just hate gay people doc or are you afraid of them too?

Keyblade
May 3rd 2018
30678 Comments


"Besides like overly sensitive SJW anti-hate speech shit what is so idiotic about progressives anyway?"

uh why would u need a living wage, free healthcare and college and equal rights when u can just pull urself up by ur bootstraps?? sounds pretty idiotic to me

Sharkattack
May 3rd 2018
1731 Comments


Wait what? I was trying to say progressive politics are pretty solid for the most part and not idiotic. I’m pro all the things you mentioned so far. I can’t tell if you are sarcastic or not.

hal1ax
May 3rd 2018
15775 Comments


he was being sarcastic

Sharkattack
May 3rd 2018
1731 Comments


Oh shit thanks dawg

Meridiu5
May 3rd 2018
4165 Comments


"Kanye will be on Infowars today lmfao"

LOL

guitarded_chuck
May 3rd 2018
18070 Comments


"Besides like overly sensitive SJW anti-hate speech shit what is so idiotic about progressives anyway?"

as if there needs to be any other reason

their complete ignorance of the atrocities and failures of every communist regime ever is probably the biggest thing tho

MO
May 3rd 2018
24016 Comments


yea agreed they are all basket cases lol

MotokoKusanagi
May 3rd 2018
4290 Comments


"their complete ignorance of the atrocities and failures of every communist regime ever is probably the biggest thing tho"

haha implying progressive = communist sympathizer. step away from Breitbart for a few minutes bud

guitarded_chuck
May 3rd 2018
18070 Comments


stick around and watch the rhetoric on sputnik for any length of time and you will see i am completely accurate in that sentiment B U D

MO
May 3rd 2018
24016 Comments


"haha implying progressive = communist sympathizer. step away from Breitbart for a few minutes bud"

looool dude are you for real. occupy wall street was literally the definition of communistic wealth redistribution (which is ironic since it was funded by the elite left en masse) and progressives ate that shit up with a silver spoon

guitarded_chuck
May 3rd 2018
18070 Comments


real socialism has never been tried

guitarded_chuck
May 3rd 2018
18070 Comments


^ive literally seen that exact quote from like 5 different people here

MO
May 3rd 2018
24016 Comments


yea tell that to the hundreds of millions of people who died under socialist and communist rule

fuck socialism and communism. my mom grew up under communist Russia, never again motherfuckers

MotokoKusanagi
May 3rd 2018
4290 Comments


it must be tough since you want to lump everyone in the same boat, but yes there is a difference between a progressive democrat and a socialist (and even more-so a communist). come on now

guitarded_chuck
May 3rd 2018
18070 Comments


the slight at conservatives was the first generalizing comment here but yes youre right its irrational to group and generalize like that on either side

but the ignorance of the realities of communism in general is a thing 100%, many lefty student types will line up to murder a neo nazi meanwhile have zero knowledge of the history of failed socialist states

SCREAM!
May 3rd 2018
15755 Comments


"but the ignorance of the realities of communism"

This is why people keep telling you the real thing hasn't been tried.

"many lefty student types will line up to murder a neo nazi "

You can point to some pretty horrific point within the ideology itself when it comes to neo Nazism. So far all your critiques about communism have been critiques against psychopathic dictators which can exists outside of communism and aren't an inherent part of communism.

"zero knowledge of the history of failed socialist states"

Brutal dictators aside, this also ignores the fact that much of the worlds superpowers actively hindered the spread and success of anything they deemed remotely communist leaning through wars, economic sanctions, etc. Do you think this is being done to protect you? I'm a little skeptical personally.

For the record, I'm not advocating for communism and I feel like I still need to read up and learn a lot about the ideology and the history (beyond hurr durr Stalin) to have something substantial to present opinion wise on all this. But reading to chuck's posts with all the nuance and finesse of a chipped brick was a little much.

MotokoKusanagi
May 3rd 2018
4290 Comments


@guitar

haha fair enough. for what it's worth, i consider myself a progressive but certainly don't welcome a socialist or communist regime. just thought i'd try to point that out. as for the occupy movement stuff - that drew in all different types of leftist agendas. i think you could probably talk to any two people there and get wildly different views. i agree it was a bad look, but so is inequality

botb
May 3rd 2018
17791 Comments


Woop di scoop

guitarded_chuck
May 3rd 2018
18070 Comments


"So far all your critiques about communism have been critiques against psychopathic dictators which can exists outside of communism and aren't an inherent part of communism."

lmao there it is as if on command

GIVE ME ONE EXAMPLE

guitarded_chuck
May 3rd 2018
18070 Comments


jesus christ why did i go on the internet today

guitarded_chuck
May 3rd 2018
18070 Comments


"For the record, I'm not advocating for communism and I feel like I still need to read up and learn a lot about the ideology and the history (beyond hurr durr Stalin) to have something substantial to present opinion wise on all this. "

lmfao he even admits he doesnt know

thank you for proving my point so clearly i couldnt have asked for such a perfect example of the ignorance i was pointing to

JWT155
May 3rd 2018
14948 Comments


But it hasn't really been done correctly chuck. /s

guitarded_chuck
May 3rd 2018
18070 Comments


no you see your historical education hasnt been done correctly

guitarded_chuck
May 3rd 2018
18070 Comments


nice /s edit pls dont tease me like that im one more idiotic comment away from full chuckragemode

SCREAM!
May 3rd 2018
15755 Comments


"lmfao he even admits he doesnt know

thank you for proving my point so clearly i couldnt have asked for such a perfect example of the ignorance i was pointing to"

It's a complex topic with a ton of litterature and I'm not going to pretend to have a full understanding of it the way you seem so comfortable doing, yeah.

guitarded_chuck
May 3rd 2018
18070 Comments


G I V E

M E

O N E

E X A M P L E

guitarded_chuck
May 3rd 2018
18070 Comments


if youre not going to pretend to have full understanding dont be an ignorant fuck like the rest of them and say that dictators are not an inherent part of communism, how can you possibly know that if you're not read on the subject

contrary to your immature personal jabs at me i am very well read on the subject and literally zero communist regimes have existed without a dictator and none of them lasted, most of them resulted in human rights violations equaling or succeeding anything the nazis did

thats the fucking reality and to claim otherwise is to disrespect the hundreds of millions of people who were killed by communist regimes historically and THAT is why i get fucking heated over the subject

MO
May 3rd 2018
24016 Comments


"This is why people keep telling you the real thing hasn't been tried. "

agreed and why it needs to be shut down entirely as an idea to be tried in this day and age

Sharkattack
May 3rd 2018
1731 Comments


Just for the record I consider myself a progressive but I’m not an anti-capitalist and I don’t harbor socialist or communist views. I thought occupy Wall Street was a stupid gesture that ended up causing taxpayers more money than making any real economic changes. Essentially occupy Wall Street was a bunch of stoner hippies camping out while cops got paid crazy amounts of overtime to babysit them. It cost a shit ton of money and literally nothing happened except progressives got even more of a bad reputation as naive hippies.

guitarded_chuck
May 3rd 2018
18070 Comments


re: occupy movement:

im all for peaceful protesting no matter how ill-informed it is, and not that all occupy protesters were ill-informed either, standing up for the downtrodden is perfectly reasonable and needs to be done continuously in order to try and strike a balance in the system

JWT155
May 3rd 2018
14948 Comments


Well I had to add the /s after not realizing that enough dumb people have said that that you'd take me seriously

Sharkattack
May 3rd 2018
1731 Comments


Me too but that movement was such a disgrace. No organization or real ideas besides “rich people have too much money” which I agree with. At least in my city it ended up hurting the cause because it left a bad taste in otherwise sympathetic peoples mouths. Too much camping and not enough action.

MotokoKusanagi
May 3rd 2018
4290 Comments


yeah the occupy movement definitely attracted dirty hippie types which gave it a bad look, but let's not pretend that the wealth gap isn't a huge issue (and only getting worse). the occupy movement was better than not doing anything and being complacent, i think it got the message out there. can't really say it had much of a lasting impact however

guitarded_chuck
May 3rd 2018
18070 Comments


anytime that discussion comes up in terms of american economics i remind people that america does have some of the highest income tax in the west its just that the a relatively huge proportion of the spending is on defense rather than social programs compared to most other western democracies

Keyblade
May 3rd 2018
30678 Comments


"as if there needs to be any other reason

their complete ignorance of the atrocities and failures of every communist regime ever is probably the biggest thing tho"

this post is confusing for a couple of reasons

1) u say there doesn't need to be another reason (ie: anti hate speech sjws), then proceed to give a completely different reason

2) ur equating progressivism to communism??? and ur reasoning is that occupy wall street was communistic, as if that short lived protest is emblematic of the progressive movement

what a clusterfuck of ideas. I feel like it was just an excuse to rant about communism and socialism lol


MotokoKusanagi
May 3rd 2018
4290 Comments


haha glad i'm not the only one who thought someone saying progressive = communist was flat out ignorant. i mean i think i learned the difference in the 8th grade

guitarded_chuck
May 3rd 2018
18070 Comments


1) was a joke but yes mother fuck every sensitive pussy ever

2) i never used occupy wall street as a reason for saying progessivism = communism someone else brought occupy up nor did i say progressivism = communism AND ANYWAY what i actually was saying is progressives tend to be more forgiving at least or completely ignorant at worst of the history of communism vs other types of authoritative governments


what a clusterfuck of skewing my words lol

next question

Sharkattack
May 3rd 2018
1731 Comments


We went from Kanye West to socialism real fast

guitarded_chuck
May 3rd 2018
18070 Comments


"haha glad i'm not the only one who thought someone saying progressive = communist was flat out ignorant. i mean i think i learned the difference in the 8th grade"

someone point me to where this statement was made

Keyblade
May 3rd 2018
30678 Comments


that was actually MO who mentioned occupy wall street, my b

"2) i never used occupy wall street as a reason for saying progessivism = communism nor did i say progressivism = communism, i said progressives tend to be more forgiving at least or completely ignorant at worst of the history of communism"

literally nobody was talking about communism until u did, to respond to the question of why progressivism is idiotic

so why even bring it up, unless to equate the 2 on some level? it's so random

SCREAM!
May 3rd 2018
15755 Comments


"if youre not going to pretend to have full understanding dont be an ignorant fuck like the rest of them and say that dictators are not an inherent part of communism, how can you possibly know that if you're not read on the subject

contrary to your immature personal jabs at me i am very well read on the subject and literally zero communist regimes have existed without a dictator and none of them lasted, most of them resulted in human rights violations equaling or succeeding anything the nazis did

thats the fucking reality and to claim otherwise is to disrespect the hundreds of millions of people who were killed by communist regimes historically and THAT is why i get fucking heated over the subject"

I have enough of a basic understanding to know it's an economic system that could, in theory, be applied in a multitude of ways be it in a dictatorship or, as some argue, a stateless/anarchist society. Dictatorship isn't written into the ideology.
So far, the way it's been applied has basically been a revolution leads to a dictatorship taking over, the dictatorship "implements communism" to satisfy the population, "communism" is slowly taken away in all but name as the dictatorship does what dictatorships do. Now were the system to be implemented in a different way (democratically) maybe there could be vastly different results.
And, let's not pretend like human rights violations are somehow a symptom of communism alone and don't happen every day under a capitalist system as well... We're just lucky enough to have been born into a part of the world that's shielded from the worst of it.

I'm not even advocating for communism here and it's far from a perfect system and likely to idealistic to ever work. But on the flip-side, capitalism has shown it's definitely not perfect either and the best option is likely somewhere in the middle. However, to get there, there needs to be better discussion about what works and what doesn't in each system and if communism is already reduced to "dictatorship", I don't think anyone is doing themselves any favours. And that's where those (admittedly) cheap jabs at you from earlier came from.

guitarded_chuck
May 3rd 2018
18070 Comments


" so why even bring it up, unless to equate the 2 on some level? it's so random"

if you read the thread i was responding to a question

its not random that ignorance is highly prevalent and pisses me off to no end

Sharkattack
May 3rd 2018
1731 Comments


Damn scream I agree with you on most of that

SCREAM!
May 3rd 2018
15755 Comments


I can't believe I'm debating communism on a Kanye thread where tf did my life go wrong

guitarded_chuck
May 3rd 2018
18070 Comments


in theory =/= in practice

"And, let's not pretend like human rights violations are somehow a symptom of communism alone and don't happen every day under a capitalist system as well... We're just lucky enough to have been born into a part of the world that's shielded from the worst of it. "

again showing MASSIVE levels of ignorance here

go read the gulag archipelago at @ me when youre finished it

guitarded_chuck
May 3rd 2018
18070 Comments


"I can't believe I'm debating communism on a Kanye thread where tf did my life go wrong"

the moment you decided to pretend to be an expert on things youre not read on probably

guitarded_chuck
May 3rd 2018
18070 Comments


capitalism isnt perfect but nature isnt perfect, inequality is innate in nature

IN PRACTICE capitalism is the system that creates the most progress and peace

maybe someday we will evolve past the point of having greed be an innate part of human nature but until that happens a socialist system will never work

the only way communism works IN THEORY is to ignore the variable of human greed from the equation which is irrational

Sharkattack
May 3rd 2018
1731 Comments


I think someone said conservatives are idiotic and someone responded by saying progressives are idiotic too and I was like well besides sensitive college pussies what is so idiotic about progressive politics and then it got really weird

Keyblade
May 3rd 2018
30678 Comments


was there a capitalism v communism debate on here recently

this looks like a spillover from an old argument lol

guitarded_chuck
May 3rd 2018
18070 Comments


yeah but literally no one said progressives = communists so lets be adults and not skew each others words

Keyblade
May 3rd 2018
30678 Comments


"I think someone said conservatives are idiotic and someone responded by saying progressives are idiotic too and I was like well besides sensitive college pussies what is so idiotic about progressive politics and then it got really weird"
it went straight to communism. zero lead in lmao


guitarded_chuck
May 3rd 2018
18070 Comments


lmao

guitarded_chuck
May 3rd 2018
18070 Comments


two tactics ignorant people do to try and shut down discussion:

1) skew words

when that fails

2) mock

never a direct response because they have nothing to respond with

you want to be sympathetic to communism go live in venezeuela and tell me how well the people are doing there

guitarded_chuck
May 3rd 2018
18070 Comments


"In Venezuela, inflation quadruples to 18,000 percent in two months, with no end in sight"

http://www.miamiherald.com/news/nation-world/world/americas/venezuela/article210282264.html


Sharkattack
May 3rd 2018
1731 Comments


Yeah dude communism sucks agreed

MO
May 3rd 2018
24016 Comments


"Now were the system to be implemented in a different way (democratically) maybe there could be vastly different results."

as much as it would be nice I just don't see this working because essentially you're still just redistributing the means of living in a completely unnatural way. giving money to people who don't work for it is not a good idea imo (not including the disabled in this).

superficially putting people on the same level will result in laziness and an overall lack of innovation and creativity. they did a study in Finland recently which basically put a huge number of people on a UBI and it cost way more than the benefits since people got lazy and didn't want to do anything because they didn't really have to.

Sinternet
Contributing Reviewer
May 3rd 2018
26569 Comments


capitalism has only been sweetened in the eyes of the west because of reforms pushe d forward by socialists based on socialist ideals. the concepts of healthcare and education for all, the welfare system, worker's rights, votes for all, civil rights, women's rights, lgbt rights all stemmed from the work of socialists, to pretend that capitalism without the work of socialists minimising its negative impacts would be any different than the conditions found in dictatorships is to be ignorant of the fact that the exchange of system between feudalism and capitalism did little to upset the concentration of wealth and power between the upper classes and the working class. communism in practice has by and large not been successful save for a few isolated examples (although they might have been slightly better if it weren't for the USA's interesting foreign policies), where they might have made gains in some areas the ease at which dictatorships and authoritarian states can occur out of a revolution is it's biggest weakness. but capitalism has also seen extreme authoritarian states, mass inequality, imperialism, slavery, genocides and the lot. to pretend that capitalism is objectively superior just because you manage to live in a wealthy country built on the exploitation of natural resources and other nations is to be ignorant of the impacts a western lifestyle has on other parts of the world. for me, the end goal of society should be a socialist-like system, but the answer to how to achieve that is by slow democratic reform, not by sudden revolution as many countries have fallen into the trap of doing. our societies need to shift in a more social democratic direction if any transition to democratic socialism is made.

Sharkattack
May 3rd 2018
1731 Comments


Yeah universal basic income sucks agreed

MO
May 3rd 2018
24016 Comments


"IN PRACTICE capitalism is the system that creates the most progress and peace"

yep, it's a flawed system but its the best one that has ever emerged in our million year history and has lifted an insane amount of people out of poverty. sure the rich get richer, but the whole point is that the opportunity for anyone is there.


SCREAM!
May 3rd 2018
15755 Comments


"the moment you decided to pretend to be an expert on things youre not read on probably"

Yeah that's why from the start I openly admitted to NOT being an expert on the subject. That's totally me trying to pretend to be an expert.

"two tactics ignorant people do to try and shut down discussion:

1) skew words"



guitarded_chuck
May 3rd 2018
18070 Comments


yeah exactly, paranoid dictators and human rights violations aside lack of productivity is another major issue

what did communist russia create during the ussr besides mass starvation

tetris i suppose

guitarded_chuck
May 3rd 2018
18070 Comments


if youre not an expert then keep the insult based assertive claims out of the discussion plskthnx

saying you dont know the thing but think maybe communism could work is one thing, saying i have the nuance of a brick for actually having an educated opinion is another, show some maturity

Sharkattack
May 3rd 2018
1731 Comments


Yeah but the opportunities are shrinking and the gap between rich and poor is the worst it has ever been. Capitalism in America needs to get checked and updated or socialism will come to this country. The younger generation is extremely dissatisfied with the economic state of the country. Young kids are going to college and thinking socialism is the answer and when 8 people have more money than half the world they are becoming increasingly more justified.

Sinternet
Contributing Reviewer
May 3rd 2018
26569 Comments


then how do people survive once automation eats up more and more low-skilled work? you'd have unemployment rates in the tens of millions

iirc the study was only on people who were already on unemployment benefit(i might be wrong)

guitarded_chuck
May 3rd 2018
18070 Comments


i think universal basic income is inevitable driven by automation like sinternet says but itll never be full blown equal distribution, unless we reach some sort of far future utopia where people literally dont need to work and productivity is 100% automated

guitarded_chuck
May 3rd 2018
18070 Comments


big gap between democracy based capitalism with some major mass distribution policy where people get back much larger income tax refunds for example vs full blown communism

the latter will still affect productivity among the poor but it works when that productivity is brought up by automation, the level of total productivity remains equal

JWT155
May 3rd 2018
14948 Comments


Unemployment rates would have to reach 30-40% and higher for me to think a place like the US would ever consider Universal Basic Income.

guitarded_chuck
May 3rd 2018
18070 Comments


that seems to the be the direction the thing is headed though, as less manpower is needed to run the economy unemployment will continue to rise, wealth will continue to become more centralized, redistribution will be necessary

Sharkattack
May 3rd 2018
1731 Comments


If we just invest in alternative means of acquiring energy we could create millions of new jobs and we wouldn’t need UBI while simultaneously helping the environment

Sinternet
Contributing Reviewer
May 3rd 2018
26569 Comments


of course there are and thats a much more preferable solution for this time in history as our society is based on capitalist ideals - a shift to nordic-style capitalism/social democracy is way more likely to be successful than completely overturning the economic system embedded in the roots of the system, however i think the idea of socialism should always be the goal for an advanced society, reforming until we get to that point. of course, once you reach that point there may well be new ideas that continue to allow society to push forward (progress is a vital part of any system) and people who think communism or capitalism is going to lead to a utopia should realise that no economic system is permanent and it's likely society will never reach a utopian state, as there is always more that can be done, it really depends though whether you see a socialist stte as the natural successor of a capitalist state, certainly socialist ideas and reforms have shifted capitalism in a more progressive direction

SCREAM!
May 3rd 2018
15755 Comments


"big gap between democracy based capitalism with some major mass distribution policy where people get back much larger income tax refunds for example vs full blown communism"

I think we're in agreement but what I've been trying to say is that these are socialist/communist ideas that are getting implemented into capitalism (that middle ground I was driving at earlier). However, a wall we're hitting is that people hear of these ideas and this ingrained fear of socialism kicks in and it's an automatic kneejerk. If we want to get away from this mentality and open ourselves up to these potential solutions, we need to get away from this communism/socialism=dictatorship mentality because it's a lot more complex than just that.
This is what I've been trying to say this whole time.

JWT155
May 3rd 2018
14948 Comments


Agreed, but who knows what unemployment will be like in the next 5, 10, 20 years. Places like the internet didn't exist until a couple decades ago and now arguably the internet is one of the biggest creators in terms of jobs and careers. Who knows what next invention or culture shift will be and what the ripple effect in terms of job allocation will be.

Sinternet
Contributing Reviewer
May 3rd 2018
26569 Comments


i agree shark but in many cases those systems require little manpower anyway, at least in comparison to the jobs that will be lost because of automation

one idea i've heard is to provide students with a large maintenance rate to reduce the number of students working these shrinking low-skill jobsand open more up to those not in education, might be a bit short-ighted though

SCREAM!
May 3rd 2018
15755 Comments


"Agreed, but who knows what unemployment will be like in the next 5, 10, 20 years. Places like the internet didn't exist until a couple decades ago and now arguably the internet is one of the biggest creators in terms of jobs and careers. Who knows what next invention or culture shift will be and what the ripple effect in terms of job allocation will be."

Very fair point. But I do think it's crazy (and highlights some major problems with our system) that, with automation growing, rather than rejoicing at this technology that has the potential to make all of our lives a hell of a lot easier, people are freaking out at losing their livelihoods.

guitarded_chuck
May 3rd 2018
18070 Comments


"If we just invest in alternative means of acquiring energy we could create millions of new jobs and we wouldn’t need UBI while simultaneously helping the environment"

yeah thats my biggest gripe with trump tbh, he seems to the think the solution to unemployment is doubling down on industries that the free market has already rendered redundant, when the solution is obviously to start working on the new renewable-based power grid

that policy direct just reflects the hold the lobbyists have on government, drain the swamp lul

JWT155
May 3rd 2018
14948 Comments


Nordic-style capitalism/social democracy is an outlier is so many regards though: they've been propped up by their oil industry and it's profits, Norway is only 5 million people and would be on the smaller end of states in the US and they have assimilation in culture and ethnicity relative to places like the US that are very diverse. Implementing a Nordic style government in the US on a macro level just seems impossible to me.

guitarded_chuck
May 3rd 2018
18070 Comments


thats one of your more reasonable comments ive seen you make sinternet, cheers

Keyblade
May 3rd 2018
30678 Comments


"yeah but literally no one said progressives = communists so lets be adults and not skew each others words"

uh u implied that progressives are communist sympathizers at the very least

"two tactics ignorant people do to try and shut down discussion:

1) skew words

when that fails

2) mock

never a direct response because they have nothing to respond with

you want to be sympathetic to communism go live in venezeuela and tell me how well the people are doing there"

nobody's shutting down discussion, stop being a pussy. ur being just as snarky as anyone else in this thread. it's sputnikmusic.com ffs

also here u are accusing ppl in this thread of being communist sympathizers

MO
May 3rd 2018
24016 Comments


"If we just invest in alternative means of acquiring energy we could create millions of new job"

I can get behind this, why we haven't tapped into solar power is beyond me

JWT155
May 3rd 2018
14948 Comments


@SCREAM! Automation is a real issue and will most definitely have repercussions, my comment was definitely more on the optimism side but I'm definitely not looking past the negative externalities of automation which could cause mass unemployment in the very near future.

guitarded_chuck
May 3rd 2018
18070 Comments


" also here u are accusing ppl in this thread of being communist sympathizers"

dont act like you didnt react emotionally to the fact socialism was being trashed, you REEEED super hard misreading what i was saying

SCREAM!
May 3rd 2018
15755 Comments


@investing in new sources of energy idea

That would create jobs but also cost a lot in non-renewable sectors, no? Likely a positive plus/minus ratio but enough to combat something like automation?

guitarded_chuck
May 3rd 2018
18070 Comments


"That would create jobs but also cost a lot in non-renewable sectors, no? Likely a positive plus/minus ratio but enough to combat something like automation? "

for sure and if we dont want to directly invest in the new system with public money thatd be fine the free market would take care of it anyway, the problem is trump is impeding that process with tariffs and investing in non-renewables (oil and gas still being the number one provider of republican funding)

the lobbyists are impeding progress and ultimately contributing to unemployment at home 100% (not mention the environmental issues)


Keyblade
May 3rd 2018
30678 Comments


"dont act like you didnt react emotionally to the fact socialism was being trashed, you REEEED super hard misreading what i was saying"

um no, idgaf about socialism but ok. I misread what u said cuz what u said was so tangential to the original discussion that it made no sense, not cuz u "thrashed" socialism lmao


guitarded_chuck
May 3rd 2018
18070 Comments


sure bro

Doctuses
May 3rd 2018
1914 Comments


you all have aids

Sharkattack
May 3rd 2018
1731 Comments


Doctuses hates and is afraid of gay people confirmed

guitarded_chuck
May 3rd 2018
18070 Comments


so anyway do we think kanyes album is gonna be a trainwreck or what

hoping for the best, expecting the worst

Sharkattack
May 3rd 2018
1731 Comments


Investing in new ideas is what capitalism and a sound economy thrive on. If we kept using the same technology I would not be able to type this comment and I would need to ride my horse six miles to the nearest well for water just for that day.

Sharkattack
May 3rd 2018
1731 Comments


As far as Kanye West and his album I don’t care at all. As expressed in my first comment I just want him to go away l.

guitarded_chuck
May 3rd 2018
18070 Comments


i miss the old kanye

SCREAM!
May 3rd 2018
15755 Comments


straight from the gold Kanye

Doctuses
May 3rd 2018
1914 Comments


you got a pretty mouth there boy

Keyblade
May 3rd 2018
30678 Comments


it's hard to believe the insightful and introspective Kanye from early in his career could descend into such inanity

dude is going senile in his early 40's

JWT155
May 3rd 2018
14948 Comments


Kanye has been saying fucked up shit his whole career, the fact people on the left think he's just becoming unhinged now because he's spewing stuff that people who tend to lean right associate with is just silly. The dude literally said the President of the US didn't care about black people live on tv.

Keyblade
May 3rd 2018
30678 Comments


he was always a narcissist and said and did crazy things...but he seemed to have a grasp on reality at the end of the day

"slavery was a choice" is not a left/right issue...at least I hope. it is just absurdly outlandish, even for Kanye

Meridiu5
May 3rd 2018
4165 Comments


So... the headline about Kanye being on infowars was a lie

FAKE NEWS

Drifter
May 3rd 2018
20820 Comments


I LOVE DAZ I LOVE THE CRIPS I LOVE THE BLOODS I LOVE EVERYBODY

Kanye's totally scared of Daz lmao. I fear for Daz though, I don't want him getting into trouble for this :[[[[ The police already came to his house for rants lol

JWT155
May 3rd 2018
14948 Comments


Bullshit. The guy walked on stage when another person was accepting an award to say someone else deserved it. The dude has never been a beacon of rational thought and to argue otherwise is asinine.

I also find it fascinating how Kanye can say the President hates Black People and the left scrambles to support him and give nuance to his thoughts but now with this "400 years a slave" comments there is no nuance, it's black and white, he thinks blacks chose to be slaves all along. I think the comment was pretty stupid and not well thought out at all, but it's funny how depending on who's agenda his words serve he's either given a chance to explain himself and given nuance or his words are labeled as the worst interpretation imaginable.

JWT155
May 3rd 2018
14948 Comments


Also I find it hysterical how people like Laura Ingraham (who's a nutjob) gets flack for telling Lebron to shut up and dribble and the left is appalled and thinks anyone should be able to speak their mind politically, but then after Kanye's words Maxine Waters essentially tells him to shut up and rap.

Sharkattack
May 3rd 2018
1731 Comments


Liberal media is hypocritical as fuck agreed. Especially when it comes to words they don’t like.

SCREAM!
May 3rd 2018
15755 Comments


Hypocrites on both sides tbh

Just look at the whole Michelle Wolf uproar

JWT155
May 3rd 2018
14948 Comments


Oh for sure, hypocrites on both sides for sure. I tend to lean right myself and the unraveling of the morally superior Christian Conservative right is second to none.

guitarded_chuck
May 3rd 2018
18070 Comments


revenue for corporate media continues to dwindle as people use free content so the clickbait machine just becomes more and more clickbaity, more opinion pieces less direct information

guitarded_chuck
May 3rd 2018
18070 Comments


im slightly left of center according to how id describe myself and those poli compass tests but slightly left of center is viewed as conservative these days it seems as much of the left has gone full irrational in NA at least

liberal used to mean liberty = free speech

JWT155
May 3rd 2018
14948 Comments


But the secondary free sources are starting to be regulated in scary ways. Zuckerburg just came out saying they're implementing a new system where they rank the credibility of news sources, that can't go wrong at all.... It's also a scary precedent for Facebook for them because if they begin regulating their content then they essentially are defining themselves as an online publisher instead of a tech company.

Sharkattack
May 3rd 2018
1731 Comments


There should be like a mass exodus from Facebook. Like on August 14th or something everyone just deletes their Facebook. It would make zuccfucc and a bunch of big wigs scared out of their bones.

Keyblade
May 3rd 2018
30678 Comments


@JWT ok so the worst interpretation of "the president hates black people" doesn't even come close to even the most charitable interpretation of "400 years of slavery was a choice". like not even on the same plane. ur really reaching with this false equivalency. I also seem to remember him getting blasted all over the news over his Katrina comments

nobody is denying that he's always been a bit "out there" so to speak. that's the whole implication anyway when ppl say he's "lost it"...as in he's finally tipped over the edge. put it this way, do u think 2005 Kanye would say some shit like that about slavery? hell no

like honestly, what nuancy is there with ""When you hear about slavery for 400 years . . . For 400 years? That sounds like a choice.You were there for 400 years, and it's all of y'all. It's like we're mentally imprisoned.". the best attempt I've seen to find the nuance in it in this thread (I think it was u actually) was that he means ppl are still slaves today. honestly, from the context I just don't see it. I watched the whole clip to see if o wasn't missing anything...nope, still as bad. One of the most appalling things I've heard anyone say

guitarded_chuck
May 3rd 2018
18070 Comments


yeah facebook slipped up with the cambridge analytica stuff and gave the machine an excuse to enforce controls, but ultimately FB or otherwise i think relatively clear information streams will reign on the internet in some ever evolving form

i think reddits system is more or less the perfected one tbh, democratic

iglu
May 3rd 2018
1740 Comments


So that new album should be good. I'm thinking 15 min songs.

guitarded_chuck
May 3rd 2018
18070 Comments


tbf if kanye had just explicitly said he thinks black people could have done more to combat slavery it wouldnt be that crazy a statement (not saying i agree whatsoever) but he's trying to be one of these edgy conservative internet personalities with his use of language in the "slavery was a choice" thing

ultimately lets be real, its purposeful publicity for his upcoming album

JWT155
May 3rd 2018
14948 Comments


Haha I'm not defending his words dude, but this idea of how he's "changed" and he's going senile now is ridiculous; the fact that people are surprised Kanye said this to me is more telling, like hello, the dude's spat crazy shit his whole career, sure this may take the cake but for one I'm not shocked.

guitarded_chuck
May 3rd 2018
18070 Comments


YO TAYLOR IMA LET U FINISH BUT

JWT155
May 3rd 2018
14948 Comments


My honest hot take goes with what chuck said, I think Kanye admires how Donald Trump went from being a joke to now having a stalwart fan base and I think that his primary mindset is to sell records, and what better way then to get 40 million trump die hards to buy your record just so they can give liberals the middle finger. It'd be the second greatest con job next to Trump becoming President. Heard this once and I think it rings true: "conservatives would eat shit if it meant Liberals had to smell their breath".

guitarded_chuck
May 3rd 2018
18070 Comments


all that being said i 100% understand people being annoyed with him over it, as much as free speech entails he has a right to say it it entails anyone has a right to call him out on it, this is how the thing regulates itself

guitarded_chuck
May 3rd 2018
18070 Comments


yeah for real its the trump business model, any press is good press

JWT155
May 3rd 2018
14948 Comments


Yeezy is prob trying to see if he can get Sean Hannity, Alex Jones, and all the right wing talking heads to market his album for him, because knowing them and how they're shills they'll tell their whole fanbase at the drop of a hat to buy something if they think it'll upset liberals.

Keyblade
May 3rd 2018
30678 Comments


"Haha I'm not defending his words dude, but this idea of how he's "changed" and he's going senile now is ridiculous; the fact that people are surprised Kanye said this to me is more telling, like hello, the dude's spat crazy shit his whole career, sure this may take the cake but for one I'm not shocked."

he was showing signs of cracking around the time of 808's imo and has been on a slow descent ever since, it's not like he suddenly lost it in 2018 because of trump lol. anybody who thinks that is deluded

I'm just astonished that the decline has been this steep. I wouldn't expect what he said from anybody really. I imagine even the dudes from Arghoslent clutched their mjolnir pendants at what he said

MO
May 3rd 2018
24016 Comments


""slavery was a choice" is not a left/right issue...at least I hope. it is just absurdly outlandish, even for Kanye"

I don't know I feel like his words were taken too much at face value and he didn't get enough time to clarify what he had said

normally I don't like these youtube vids but this guy (who is black) breaks it down well, but who knows if this is what Yeezy actually meant

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=DjxiI0Di_zc


JWT155
May 3rd 2018
14948 Comments


Get out of here MO with some rational thought, there's absolutely zero nuance to his words that he said off the cuff in a TMZ interview.

JWT155
May 3rd 2018
14948 Comments


I just watched the video you posted MO and that guy gave a really good explanation, and I think he hots the nail on the head for what Kanye was going for.

MO
May 3rd 2018
24016 Comments


neva!!

RadicalEd
May 3rd 2018
9546 Comments


I really couldn't give a fuck less about his political views (and I'm pretty much convinced that he's just cynically exploiting twitter controversy) but his antics have way, way, way surpassed his status as a musician at this point, at least in my opinion. He's just annoying me and I used to be a huge fan.

JWT155
May 3rd 2018
14948 Comments


Really? Him tweeting and simply giving his opinion in interviews and on twitter is more upsetting then being rude and upstaging people at award shows, using a charity event to call out the President of the US and countless other examples from his past? I guess acting like an ass and being rude was fine, but speaking his mind and giving controversial opinions is a bridge too far... again, I'm not defending Yeezy, I just am dumbfounded on how this was the straw that broke the camels back. If anything people are just proving conservatives right on how people who lean right are treated differently in the public eye. Act rude and interrupt Taylor at an awards show, call the President a racist, no big deal, spout conservative principles on your own accord and respectively on social media and in interviews, uncalled for...

Keyblade
May 3rd 2018
30678 Comments


yea I guess the nuance is a fake Harriet Tubman quote and the semantics of "they didn't choose to be slaves...they chose not to free themselves...uh because of intense physical and psychological oppression".

all of which Kanye never said himself mind you, and is merely an interpretation. even if that was really what he meant, it's still an incredibly inane and denigrating way to phrase something that's self evident. yea obviously slaves found it hard to escape because of the obscene physical and mental torture they had to endure...which was designed precisely so they couldn't escape. why would u even call that a choice and implicitly chastise them for not escaping sooner? shit, I'm not rocking with this "nuanced" interpretation either

I can get behind the dude in the video and what he's saying. I might not agree with him everything hes saying, but it seems like he's genuinely trying to find a solution to a problem. the problem is Kanye sounds like he's just putting down his people to take him feel better. words are powerful, and when you have the platform that Kanye does you have to choose them carefully. nobody should have to try to find deeper meaning to things you have put in very plain terms. leave that for your lyrics and art

JWT155
May 3rd 2018
14948 Comments


Maybe both sides are wrong, maybe both sides are wrong to rush to either crucify or herald him as a hero? Maybe instead of rushing to judgement responsible journalists should ask for clarification on what he meant, because it's clear from the reactions that there can be multiple interpretations ranging from utterly offensive to understandable.

iglu
May 3rd 2018
1740 Comments


I was wondering why people are still making a big deal out of this, then I remembered it's becasue he is a god.

MO
May 3rd 2018
24016 Comments


"the problem is Kanye sounds like he's just putting down his people to take him feel better."

I think he's saying black people have been pawns in politics for so long and they can start thinking for themselves. it's almost like they are sick of the over-politicising and use of the words racist/bigot and not everything is about skin colour

Keyblade
May 3rd 2018
30678 Comments


he could have just said that then lol. I mean it would still be extremely flawed and patronizing (do black people not already think for themselves??), but it's not really outlandish

but it's such a far cry from what he actually said. I really doubt Kanye West of all people can struggle so spectacularly to say what he actually means. it's literally his profession



guitarded_chuck
May 3rd 2018
18070 Comments


he meant what he said cause his profession is selling music and that got him attention

DoofusWainwright
May 3rd 2018
19991 Comments


Big mouth strikes out again 2

JWT155
May 3rd 2018
14948 Comments


"but it's such a far cry from what he actually said. I really doubt Kanye West of all people can struggle so spectacularly to say what he actually means. it's literally his profession"

Have you seen his interviews the past 10-15 years? He's one of the hardest people to follow their train of thought in interviews, look no further to his Ellen Degeneres interview years ago where he said he was dead.

guitarded_chuck
May 3rd 2018
18070 Comments


yeah i think around the time of that ellen interview he was actually having a nervous breakdown, he was doing some weird shit at shows too and ultimately ended up in a mental hospital

Keyblade
May 3rd 2018
30678 Comments


"Have you seen his interviews the past 10-15 years? He's one of the hardest people to follow their train of thought in interviews, look no further to his Ellen Degeneres interview years ago where he said he was dead."

lol I remember that. he was on that dmx steez, with the hand gestures and everything

he was saying some weird shit that nobody even understood then. he was quite clear at TMZ and wasn't just ranting, but debating other people. I saw his 2 hour interview with charlegmane the other day and he was very lucid in the way he expressed himself. he didn't say anything of substance really, but he was clear. he can say what he's thinking, and definitely has no qualms about doing so (ask Taylor Swift). but whether those thoughts are coherent is another matter

I've got a lot of time for 'Ye...he put out one of my favorite records of all time, and was somewhat inspiring in the early 00's. but no matter how I look at this, he doesn't come out of it looking good

jagride
May 3rd 2018
2975 Comments


"they did a study in Finland recently which basically put a huge number of people on a UBI and it cost way more than the benefits since people got lazy and didn't want to do anything because they didn't really have to"

it's amazing that a random sputniker is privy to the unreleased study data and it lines up neatly with his ideological stance on the issue

Keyblade
May 3rd 2018
30678 Comments


hmm it's almost like he crossed a line

SCREAM!
May 3rd 2018
15755 Comments


"Have you seen his interviews the past 10-15 years? He's one of the hardest people to follow their train of thought in interviews, look no further to his Ellen Degeneres interview years ago where he said he was dead. "

Yeah he was pretty clearly off on something during that interview (he's recently mentioned having dealt with addiction so I don't know if that could be it). He and Ellen played a game afterwards and Kanye was answering a bunch of nonsense and laughing to himself

BenThatsMyJamin
May 3rd 2018
4012 Comments


Do people shitting on him actually think he meant slaves in the 18th/19th century had a choice in the matter? I genuinely don't know at this point

Keyblade
May 3rd 2018
30678 Comments


he also said he was fucked up off opioids while tweeting last week after his liposuction

JeetJeet
May 3rd 2018
12160 Comments


"Do people shitting on him actually think he meant slaves in the 18th/19th century had a choice in the matter? I genuinely don't know at this point"

Yes because thats exactly what he meant. He doubled down on this sentiment in a few tweets which he then deleted. One of them said "my point is that for us to have stayed in that position even though the numbers were on our side means that we were mentally enslaved"

And if that wasnt bad enough he tweeted a fake quote from Harriet Tubman. So yeah L for Kanye who clearly thinks that slavery was just a numbers game.


JeetJeet
May 3rd 2018
12160 Comments


But hey if anyone feels like they can find the nuance in that statement go ahead and try to get water from that stone

JWT155
May 3rd 2018
14948 Comments


Eh his point was that if a plantation had 1,000+ slaves, they realistically could maybe overthrow the plantation owners with some casualties. But it didn't happen, and that's because slaves were very much abused on all levels: physically, emotionally, spiritually, intellectually, etc.

I think Kanye's approach on this dumb as hell and he used a terrible example, but I think his core concept about how people can be mentally beaten down and held down bears some truth and I think that's what he was trying to say, he just said a mouthful of really stupid shit.

guitarded_chuck
May 3rd 2018
18070 Comments


^tr00f

CaliggyJack
May 3rd 2018
10036 Comments


"Interesting that former supporters of him seem to have instantly turned their backs as soon as he announced his support of t_d despite sticking through the rest of his insane antics from the beginning... :thinking:"

I'm still sticking by him cause I'm an actual fan of his music, not the reputation of it.

JWT155
May 3rd 2018
14948 Comments


Isn't that something, to be able to disagree with someone's point of view but still enjoy other aspects they bring to the table. We live in a polarizing culture now, whether it be the right or the left, that if you don't check off all the boxes and completely agree with all of my ideologies then we must boycott you and shut you up.

Look no further then the recent Starbucks fiasco. Starbucks is one of the most progressive and Liberal companies in the US and the minute two black men were arrested at one of their locations people began boycotting them. On the right you had Yeti Coolers discontinue a special that affected the NRA but wasn't specifically targeted at them, they reiterated that and even offered new deals, NRA nut jobs are still boycotting and blowing up their coolers that they own.

It's dog eat dog on both sides. It's honestly scary to think how frowned upon it is on either side to think for yourself and hold multiple different views that any side may not completely agree with across the board.

ScorpionStan
May 3rd 2018
1911 Comments


This is Kanye's exact Tweet in clarification of his statement:

"Of course I know that slaves did not get shackled and put on a boat by free will. My point is for us to have stayed in that position even though the numbers were on our side means that we were mentally enslaved."

In other words, it seems like he's talking more about the 150+ years SINCE slavery was abolished than the obvious horrors that came before. His point seems to be look...it's been over a century and a half since actual slavery existed -- how are we still complaining about the same type of shit today? If we were really working as hard as possible to get past this all along, wouldn't we be a little farther past it by now?

Which is a fair point, I'd say. Obviously there's arguments on both sides, but this certainly isn't "unhinged", "deranged", "senile", or any of the other ridiculous snap judgements I've seen on here.

JWT155
May 3rd 2018
14948 Comments


Even take his initial point at face value, say slave in the 1800's didn't leave because they were mentally enslaved, is that such a radical statement? Mental health is such an important topic in today's world, I can't imagine the mental abuse and fortifications put around a slave's mind back in the day. Repressed from being educated, separated from family members, whipped and made example of for the smallest infractions if none at all, having your life threatened and all you hold dear every single day, barely holding on by a thread. These people were mentally held hostage and abused, what happened to them was terrible, and after generations of repression, mental abuse and prevalent racism that has stuck around whether it be Jim Crowe and other places, I think Kanye thinks for some these mental barriers can still be in place. I think you could argue that Kanye in his mind is trying to articulate these barriers that some may not know exist or let hinder their daily lives and goals and to finally free themselves from being repressed and told they can't be successful.

BenThatsMyJamin
May 3rd 2018
4012 Comments


@Jeet It's not what he meant at all; that's not a narrative or even a conspiracy theory, it's just unequivocally false. Even the most racist far right conspiracy nut you could find wouldn't deny that black slaves were worked against their will. It's not so much getting water from a stone as simply being aware of the relatively common modern concept that black people are subconsciously beholden to the Democratic party along with Kanye's propensity for trying (largely unsuccessfully) to condense complex ideas into trite 'deep' and often provocative phrases, not aided by using twitter as the platform for such activity.

I'm not going to debate the validity of that argument but to me it's unthinkable that anyone would actually take what he said literally, unless he really is on some strong shit or mentally unstable as other comments have alluded to, in which case there would be little point in being outraged at his ramblings in the first place.

Keyblade
May 3rd 2018
30678 Comments


from that tweet, it seems he means that the actual enslavement wasn't a choice (thank God, but that was already evident), but the remaining in that enslavement for however long was...which was how many ppl interpreted it to be fair. he's not talking g about the 150 years since then, unless the English language works differently now

yea, no shit they we're mentally enslaved and didn't escape...that was the whole point of the mental enslavement. it's such a redundant and inane thing to say in itself, but his wording of it is what makes it so bad. a choice? of all the words he could have used, he chose the one word that meant the opposite of what the situation was

how hard was it to say "we are mentally enslaved now just like we were 400 years ago, the difference now is we have a choice"? he said a bunch of other shit in that interview completely coherently (and even poignantly in some cases)

JWT155
May 3rd 2018
14948 Comments


Because it's fucking Kanye dude lol a guy who has a track record of routinely not being able to articulate anything, whether it's rudely interrupting an award show, calling the President racist to this. What don't people get that Kanye has no chill and says ridiculous stuff.

iglu
May 3rd 2018
1740 Comments


IT'S IN MY CODE!!!!

ScorpionStan
May 3rd 2018
1911 Comments


@Keyblade if you're going to get so worked up about his initial wording even though he's already clarified his statement multiple times, then you're not trying to actually come to an understanding. You're just needlessly complaining.

Like JWT said, the guy has a long as hell history of speaking in sensationalistic, off-the-cuff remarks. This shouldn't surprise anyone.

TheOrgazoid
May 3rd 2018
137 Comments


I hope people eventually realize this dude's music is just as embarrassing as he is.

Keyblade
May 3rd 2018
30678 Comments


his clarification was just a reiteration of what he said tho lol. he didn't even say he phrased it wrong, just bemoaning not being allowed to think 'freely'. all he clarified was that he didn't mean the initial enslavement wasn't a choice...just the 400 years after that. yea, that was obvious the first time

I'm not feeling a way either way. I don't think he's mentally stable and I don't hold that against him, but it was still a fucked up thing to say. that's the beauty of 'free thought'. u can freely think some bullshit, and I can freely say that was some bullshit

JeetJeet
May 3rd 2018
12160 Comments


He literally compared himself to Nat Turner in one of his tweets tho by saying "If this was 148 years ago I would have been more like Harriet or Nat"

Cmon. Theres no "well what he really meant". Nah. He said what he said because he has a poor grasp of what he's talking about.

EnyaFangirl
May 4th 2018
1822 Comments


chief keef and lupe are the only trustworthy chicago rappers now don't @

AlexKzillion
May 4th 2018
17133 Comments


New track with Travis and Uzi is okay

MH18
May 4th 2018
456 Comments


I love how Kanye makes you guys discuss politics. Adorable

guitarded_chuck
May 4th 2018
18070 Comments


theres some sort of ongoing political discussion going on somewhere on this site at all times more or less

BenThatsMyJamin
May 4th 2018
4012 Comments


And it generally has a 90% chance of giving you a brain aneurysm

MH18
May 4th 2018
456 Comments


Can't relate to it anyway. Blessed

guitarded_chuck
May 4th 2018
18070 Comments


adorable

MH18
May 4th 2018
456 Comments


I know right

ScuroFantasma
Emeritus
May 5th 2018
11971 Comments


"like honestly, what nuancy is there with ""When you hear about slavery for 400 years . . . For 400 years? That sounds like a choice.You were there for 400 years, and it's all of y'all. It's like we're mentally imprisoned.". the best attempt I've seen to find the nuance in it in this thread (I think it was u actually) was that he means ppl are still slaves today. honestly, from the context I just don't see it. I watched the whole clip to see if o wasn't missing anything...nope, still as bad. One of the most appalling things I've heard anyone say"

What nuance is there? Well how about the 400 years part which he stressed and repeated, considering slavery in America began 400 years ago as of 2020 and was abolished about 150 years ago. How can you not understand that he's referring to mental slavery in a contemporary context if you know these things? You have to be purposefully misunderstanding him or not know history for that to be the case.

Doctuses
May 5th 2018
1914 Comments


Half baked reference i see u

Doctuses
May 5th 2018
1914 Comments


Never thought I could contract aids from an internet thread but i hjust did and im a doctor

Doctuses
May 5th 2018
1914 Comments


Pitch it to comedy central make dave chapelle a producer and call it half baked 2 fully baked ur welcome

Drifter
May 5th 2018
20820 Comments


Lmaooooo



You have to be logged in to post a comment. Login | Create a Profile





MOST VIEWED NEWS

Jesse Lacey Allegations
Jayyvon Opens Up About Abuse
The Fall of Troy bassist melts do..
The Story So Far's vocalist dropk..
Deftones stream new single
R.I.P. Lemmy
Killswitch Engage debut new single
Scott Weiland dead at 48
Nothing But Thieves accusations
Lil Peep Dead At 21



OTHER RECENT NEWS

Dysrhythmia tease upcoming album
Knocked Loose x Poppy
Burzum announces new LP, single
Lotus Eater Machine on hiatus
Eye Release Second Single
Typhuzz kick off their jam
Hard Times for David Byrne
Conifere stream debut LP
Alcest release Flamme Jumelle
(Julie) Christmas in June
Amusi re-release Adapt in Codes
DGD Say Goodbye to Tilian
2nd new Six Feet Under single
Century tease upcoming tour, album
Heavenly Blue Have The Answer

» see all news

RELATED REVIEWS
Kanye West
Donda 2
Kanye West
Donda
Kanye West
Wash Us in the Blood
Kanye West
Jesus Is King
Kanye West
ye
STAFF & CONTRIBUTORS // CONTACT US

Bands: A B C D E F G H I J K L M N O P Q R S T U V W X Y Z


Site Copyright 2005-2023 Sputnikmusic.com
All Album Reviews Displayed With Permission of Authors | Terms of Use | Privacy Policy