TVC15
Herbie Chrost
User

Reviews 22
Approval 81%

Soundoffs 334
News Articles 5
Band Edits + Tags 348
Album Edits 248

Album Ratings 5648
Objectivity 81%

Last Active 03-22-22 12:57 am
Joined 11-04-12

Review Comments 11,372

 Lists
03.24.23 Sputnik Yearbook 2023 Edition 09.08.22 Sprawling Long Bois
09.02.22 Liberal Ranks Kid Rock07.20.22 Anniversary of an Uninteresting Event
04.13.22 The 7 Deadly Sins as Albums04.04.22 Nuclear Bunker-core
03.18.22 Sputnik Users Yearbook 2022 Edition 02.02.22 Rec Me Similar Deathcore
01.20.22 Overrated Bands from sputnik that suck 08.12.21 Recommend Me Prog
05.05.21 Looking for an album...04.06.21 Cosmic Black Metal
03.15.21 Sputnik Users Yearbook 2021 Edition 08.25.20 Synthwave Jukebox vol. 2: Darksynth Rav
04.11.20 Quarantine Movies04.04.20 Sput on RateYourMusic?
03.27.20 Sputnik Users Yearbook 2020 Edition 08.23.19 Synthwave in 2019 (So far!)
More »

4 Years on the Sputnikmusic; Top 100

*Every album's ranked should be subtracted by 1 because of limited room* It's my 4 year Sputversary! Well tommorrow it is but I'm posting this today because I'll be way too busy tommorrow and the weekend. Wasn't able to make this a top 200 deal because of how excruciating it is to rank everything and even then this top 100 is rather loose (except for top 10) and likely incomplete to an extent. Also for the sake of having as much variety on this list as possible, I've excluded any potential 2016 album from entering into this ranking and albums that I felt are equal in quality were tied as long as they were by the same artist. I thank everyone here on Sput for this awesome journey!
101Tears for Fears
The Seeds of Love
100Pink Floyd
Live at Pompeii
99Sweet Trip
Velocity : Design : Comfort
98Acid Bath
When the Kite String Pops
97Tom Waits
Mule Variations


This should probably actually be higher but oh well
96Johnny Cash
At San Quentin
95No Doubt
Tragic Kingdom
94Pearl Jam
Ten


*Tied with their MTV Unplugged*
93Led Zeppelin
Physical Graffiti
92My Chemical Romance
The Black Parade
91Guided by Voices
Bee Thousand
90David Bowie
"Heroes"
89The Stooges
Fun House
88Godspeed You! Black Emperor
'Allelujah! Don't Bend! Ascend!
87Iggy Pop
The Idiot
86David Bowie
Station to Station
85Sex Pistols
Never Mind the Bollocks...
84Coil
The Ape Of Naples
83Lil Wayne
Tha Carter III
82Deftones
White Pony
81Nirvana
Incesticide


Like almost all of my favorite Nirvana songs are on this album and it's the only main release by the band that hasn't suffered in some way from being overplayed by me
80Burzum
Filosofem
79Alice in Chains
MTV Unplugged
78Radiohead
In Rainbows: From the Basement
77Killing Joke
Hosannas From The Basements Of Hell
76Porcupine Tree
Fear of a Blank Planet


*Tied with Nil Recurring*
75Swans
Public Castration Is a Good Idea
74Sigur Ros
Agætis byrjun
73Full of Hell and Merzbow
Full of Hell and Merzbow


*Tied with Sister Fawn*
72Gorillaz
Demon Days
71Silencer (SWE)
Death - Pierce Me
70A Place to Bury Strangers
Exploding Head
69Clint Mansell and Kronos Quartet
Requiem for a Dream
68Public Enemy
It Takes a Nation of Millions to Hold Us
67Death Grips
The Powers That B
66Cryptopsy
None So Vile
65Nine Inch Nails
Year Zero
64Discordance Axis
The Inalienable Dreamless
63Muse
Absolution


*Tied with BH&R*
62System of a Down
System of a Down


*Tied with Toxicity*
61Portishead
Dummy
60The Beach Boys
Pet Sounds
59The Beatles
The Beatles
58Eminem
The Marshall Mathers LP


Tbh everytime I now listen to a Ken Kaniff skit from this guy I think about ArsMoriendi being Ken. It's quite amusing
57AJJ
People Who Can Eat People are the Luckiest People
56Against Me!
Reinventing Axl Rose


*Tied with s/t acoustic EP*
55Red Hot Chili Peppers
Californication
54Blur
Blur
53Green Day
American Idiot


Probably the most extreme example I've come across where brickwalling has damaged an album's entertainment value so much. The remastered version transformed this from a light 3 to a solid 5 for me
52Bathory
Blood Fire Death
51Mayhem
De Mysteriis Dom Sathanas
50Spacemen 3
Forged Prescription
49Unwound
Leaves Turn Inside You
48Bjork
Medulla
47Suicidal Tendencies
Lights...Camera...Revolution
46Swans
Soundtracks for the Blind


*Tied with Swans Are Dead*
45Metallica
...And Justice for All


So many thanks to my guitar teacher for giving me his guitar booklet of this album even tho they're all hard as fuck to play/learn
44Smashing Pumpkins
Siamese Dream
43Bob Dylan
Highway 61 Revisited
42Pig Destroyer
Prowler in the Yard
41The Dillinger Escape Plan
Irony Is a Dead Scene
40Nirvana
Live and Loud
39MGMT
Congratulations


Can't wait till I receive this edition of the album: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=SXLM3kG8yEs
38Agoraphobic Nosebleed
Altered States of America
37Tears for Fears
Songs from the Big Chair
36Mr. Bungle
California
35Guns N' Roses
Use Your Illusion


*Both discs of the album*
34Prince
Purple Rain
33David Bowie
Young Americans
32The Who
Tommy
31The Cure
Disintegration
30Talking Heads
Remain in Light


*Tied with Stop Making Sense*
29Joy Division
Les Bains Douches 18 December 1979


*Tied with Preston 28 February 1980*
28Coldplay
Viva la Vida or Death and All His Friends
27Arcade Fire
Neon Bible
26Manic Street Preachers
Journal For Plague Lovers
25Neil Young
Live Rust
24Boris With Merzbow
Rock Dream
23William Basinski
The Disintegration Loops
22The Angelic Process
Weighing Souls With Sand
21Marilyn Manson
Holy Wood
20United Nations
United Nations


File Under: Love at first listen; I forgot how I found this tbh
19Marina and The Diamonds
Electra Heart


File Under: Love at first listen; Marina is bae gtfo if you think otherwise; Under appreciated

The album that got me out of that "born in le wrong generation" phase and made me realize just how good and brilliant pop music can be. Every song on this as well as the ones that didn't make it but were posted on her VEVO are practically perfect. It's just pop at its finest. Also check out her entire discog too cos she's got something for everyone

Essential Songs: Honestly I mean like all of them, stop sleeping on pop's most underrated artist ever and get on her music right now
18Boris
Pink


File Under: Deluxe Edition of this is essential for anyone who loves music; Everything around me is Pink and idk what to do

m/ If that second disc of unreleased demos from this album made it onto the original album as is, they wouldn't sound out of place at all. They're just as on par as the songs on the original both in terms of songwriting and audio quality. In fact it could've made for one of the best double albums ever

Essential Songs (just for the regular edition): Farewell, t/t, Nothing Special, Blackout, Just Abandoned My-self
17The Clash
Rat Patrol from Fort Bragg


File Under: Purchasable Bootleg so it isn't disqualified; Better than the Original Album

You can still hunt down much better quality sounding versions of the demos that appear on the bootleg. But wow did Combat Rock lose so much meat when the songs were trimmed down and the excluded songs like The Beautiful People Are Ugly Too and Kill Time are surprisingly essential The Clash songs. Such a shame there isn't any interest to re-release this as a proper comp with remastered quality because this could be seen as a gargantuan even bigger than London Calling. But even then, for a lot of the songs the rough quality makes certain songs feel more poignant

Essential Songs: The Beautiful People Are Ugly Too, Kill Time, Straight to Hell, Sean Flynn (fuck on the original album this felt like incomplete filler but wow does it now pack a punch), Ghetto Defendant
16The Velvet Underground
White Light/White Heat


File Under: Lou Reed has a sick sense of humor; VU did avante garde rock first and the best
15Godspeed You! Black Emperor
Slow Riot For New Zero Kanada


File Under: Wow; Controlled chaos; Iron Maidenftw
14John Coltrane
A Love Supreme


File Under: Spiritual Goodness; Fuckin poetry
13The Flaming Lips
7 Skies H3


File Under: Wow; It's Like I'm listening to a Nice Painting; Psychedelic Goodness

Painstakingly made a 4 hour edit of the 24 hour song. I wish to not divulge into how quickly tedious the task became. Album is still an utter stunner that never fails to blow my mind
12Grouper
A I A


File Under: Thanks Sput (Aka AlienObserver); Love at First listen; Grey Desolation
11Mayhem
Live in Leipzig


File Under: Pure Fucking Black Metal; RIP; Deluxe Edition of this is essential for anyone who loves music

Notoriously bad in quality (if there was just slightly more in the low end then the quality wouldn't that bad actually), notoriously the final official release to have Dead on vox. Whatever, this legendary gig is probably the most ferocious and misanthropic metal release known to man. The deluxe edition contains a second disc, Live at Zeits, was a gig the band played the day before Leipzig and the CD booklet is a fascinating look at the history surrounding this live album as well as a cool explanation by Dead on how he got the name

Essential Songs (for both discs actually, although Zeits doesn't have Pagan Fears): Pure Fucking Armageddon, Funeral Fog, Carnage, Pagan Fears, The Freezing Moon
10Pink Floyd
Is There Anybody Out There?


File Under: Underrated as Fuck (Live album edition); Better than the original album; It's like I'm listening to the soundtrack of a musical

I wanted to tie this with The Wall but decided against it. Hell I decided to not have The Wall anywhere near my top 200. Yeah original album is fantastic but this one right here blows it right out of the water. Even the tracks that I originally considered filler (Goodbye Blue Sky, Vera, Is There Anybody Out There?) became essential to the storyline in how they take a break from the story to let the audience (as well as Pink himself) take a break from the story and absorb everything that has happened to him so far. The plot is thick with symbolism and other stuff that I (over)analyzed in my analysis of the film for my AP Psych class last year. The Master of Ceremonies bits are awesome as well, hopefully you can also find somewhere the version of the album that contains the 3 minute versions of both these interludes

Essential tracks: Outofroom
9Wendy Carlos
Walter Carlos' Clockwork Orange


File Under: Cool movie but the book is still better; Wow this shit was ahead of its time; Synthetic goodness

"Oh bliss! Bliss and heaven! Oh, it was gorgeousness and gorgeousity made flesh. It was like a bird of rarest-spun heaven metal or like silvery wine flowing in a spaceship, gravity all nonsense now. As I slooshied, I knew such lovely pictures!" *Proceeds to masturbate*

Because it's so hard to find otherwise:
https://www.yourmusics.co/album/wendy-carlos-a--clockwork-orange-10359.html

Essential Songs: Timesteps; Ninth Symphony, Fourth Movement; Title Music from a Clockwork Orange; idk everything else this shit is essential af
8Nine Inch Nails
The Fragile


File Under: breakingthefragile; Wow; It's Like I'm listening to a Nice Painting

Probably Trent's most creative album. I downloaded what I think is the most definitive version of this album (all signs of loudness war is gone and restores the originally longer instrumentals of certain songs as well as some greatly placed songs that were cut due to keeping the record short as possible or whatever) but the Youtube vid is now taken down due to Copyright and all that. It's one of those albums that I like to compare to a painting because it should be digested holistically. Idk I just like to liken to a painting

Essential Songs: Get a vinyl rip and absorb all the lost layers due to the shit dynamics
7Spiritualized
Ladies and Gentlemen We Are Floating in Space


*Tied with: Live From Royal Albert Hall*
File Under: Psychedelic goodness; wtf shoegaze my ass; Sadboi

Soundoff for Live from Royal Albert Hall: The way how the band brings that spacey atmosphere of their first few albums to the stage while making the arrangements noticeably more sparse than the original is so amazing.

Essential Songs (Ladies and Gents...): T/t; Home of the Brave; Stay With Me; I Think I'm in Love; Cop Shoot Cop
Essential Songs (Live from Royal): Shine a Light; Walking With Jesus; Broken Heart; Cop Shoot Cop; Oh Happy Day
6Linkin Park
A Thousand Suns


File Under: Grey Desolation; Underrated as fuck; Just cos the band sucks doesn't make the album automatically bad; Thanks Dad; Imo my best review

http://www.sputnikmusic.com/review/69629/Linkin-Park-A-Thousand-Suns/

Essential songs: I mean it's a concept album and all the songs flow into each other like it's all one song so just listen to it and be patient with it
5Jane's Addiction
Nothing's Shocking


File Under: Underrated as fuck; Titties on the cover; Shoegaze and grunge before they were albums

I would copy and paste my soundoff but it's too long and I'm too lazy to write a more concise piece on what my thoughts are on this album.

Essential songs: Up the Beach, Ocean Size, Ted (Cruz), Just Admit it..., Summertime Rolls, Jane Says
4Refused
The Shape of Punk to Come


File Under: Punk is fuckin' dead (because of this album); Fuckin poetry; Bernie Sanders' favorite album

Becoming more educated in music, especially punk, this album hit me like a train wreck. Passionate, fierce, noisy, this album leaves no room for "familiar territory" for the listener to tread on. The lyrics are beautiful, being a statement for listeners to toss complacency out the window and do something and anything that makes the world a better place to live in. The overall creativeness from the techno beats that come out of nowhere to the jazz fusion elements are integrated so cleverly. The musicianship is so on point with the heavily jazz influenced drumming and the inclusion of upright bass on heavy sections of certain songs. The CD booklet is also really cool especially with the opening bit from a close friend of the band describing "a psychological scrutiny of their motives" (read: an indirect explanation as to why the band broke up).

Essential songs: I got no more room
3Neutral Milk Hotel
In the Aeroplane Over the Sea


File Under: Folk punk, rock, indie, whatever; Semen staind mountain tops; Fuckin poetry; Thanks Sput

Before there was The Holy Bible, there was this one right here. I remember my first encounter with this was when I was looking at a list that described this user and his girlfriend having the same music taste and the album cover really interested me. The thing is, Jeff is a really bad singer. But goodness can the dude rip out your heartstrings. The beginning of the album goes from being so innocent to descending into a world of darkness and the reprise of Two-Headed Boy just leaves you so devastated by reality. The eclectic instrumentals, the odd but powerful lyrics, the simply but straightforward folk chord progressions, it's just a perfect storm but the real power house is Jeff's passion and emotion that gives the songs so much character. No other singer, no matter how much better they are, can do these songs justice

Essential songs: Idk all of them I guess
2Manic Street Preachers
The Holy Bible


File under: Misanthropic punk rock; Thanks Sput; fuckin poetry; GOAT; I forgot How I Found this tbh

Unfortunately, I don't remember which review but I checked this out when the review mentioned this alongside those super dark 90s alternative albums that defined the decade (like In Utero, Ten, whatever). Not very sure what to say that may or may not have been said before. What makes this as emotionally devastating as it is, is how the entire albums sounds like a celebration of all of humanities woes with the nihilistic lyrics sung over power pop style hooks. Like the sample used towards the end of Mausoleum, the album essentially "wanted to rub the human face in its own vomit and force it to look in the mirror" and by God does the band do just that with this juggernaut.
1Manic Street Preachers
The Holy Bible


(continued): From topics ranging from the death of a girl suffering from anorexia, to the Holocaust, to even censorship due to PC culture, this was Richey's last hurrah with a society that he was slowly becoming fed up with. Hell, even if he was alive, there was a certain tension he felt with the music industry itself, Yes being the band's version of Rape Me (despite its blunt lyrics about the day in the life of a prostitute, it's actually an analogy for how Richey felt record companies and the media were handling him and the band).


Essential songs: All of them but I mean if I had to pick: Yes, Of Walking Abortion, Archives of Pain, 4st 7lb, PCP
Show/Add Comments (58)

STAFF & CONTRIBUTORS // CONTACT US

Bands: A B C D E F G H I J K L M N O P Q R S T U V W X Y Z


Site Copyright 2005-2023 Sputnikmusic.com
All Album Reviews Displayed With Permission of Authors | Terms of Use | Privacy Policy