CK
12.09.13 | Useless list, obv Symbolic |
tempest--
12.09.13 | obv Rust in Peace |
nathan69
12.09.13 | rust in peace |
adr
12.09.13 | 1 is overrated.
Symbolic all the way.
|
tempest--
12.09.13 | lol |
insanedrexl1
12.09.13 | Love them both, but Rust In Peace wins for me. |
demigod!
12.09.13 | rust |
BigPleb
12.09.13 | Rust |
apert
12.09.13 | Rust in Peace obviously |
VisionsFromTheDarkSide
12.09.13 | Symbolic, just |
TronaldDump
12.09.13 | obv Painkiller |
mindleviticus
12.09.13 | rust |
TheSpirit
12.09.13 | there wouldnt be a symbolic without megadeth and to a lesser extent rip |
Necrotica
12.09.13 | RIP |
snowbbird
12.09.13 | Is this even a list or a question? Symbolic |
Necrotica
12.09.13 | "1 is overrated."
And Symbolic isn't? |
DrMaximus
12.09.13 | Rust, easily. |
Insurrection
12.09.13 | symbolic but both are 5s |
evilford
12.09.13 | Both are metal classics but symbolic is the greatest album ever made so |
Insurrection
12.09.13 | yea |
CK
12.09.13 | "there wouldnt be a symbolic without megadeth"
I feel like that's a silly point to make. That's like saying without Ministry's work, we wouldn't have NIN's The Downward Spiral so Ministry's work is automatically better |
Necrotica
12.09.13 | Symbolic's a hard 3.85 |
evilford
12.09.13 | 3.85/3.0 agrdd |
FearThyEvil
12.09.13 | Rust is going to win but I prefer Symbolic by a lot. |
Snake.
12.09.13 | Rust |
TheSpirit
12.10.13 | okay well then rust |
facupm
12.10.13 | both |
charbyno
12.10.13 | RIP |
Detritivore
12.10.13 | Both rules, but Rust is unique
|
CK
12.10.13 | ... and Symbolic isn't? |
tempest--
12.10.13 | Symbolic is more unique than Rust in Peace lol he prob hasn't even listened to Death |
DominionMM1
12.10.13 | as much as i love symbolic gotta go with rust in peace |
demigod!
12.10.13 | rust has better riffs |
demigod!
12.10.13 | and at the end of the day what matters more? |
YakNips
12.10.13 | heat death obviously |
nathan69
12.10.13 | death magnetic is better than both |
DrHouseSchuldiner
12.10.13 | Symbolic |
Gwyn.
12.10.13 | Rust agreed |
InbredJed
12.10.13 | tough one, but I think Rust takes it |
YoYoMancuso
12.10.13 | Both are the hardest 4.5's ever for me, but Rust In Peace wins because of Take No Prisoners |
GnarlyShillelagh
12.10.13 | TAKE NO
SHYIT |
InbredJed
12.10.13 | SHEEEYAHT |
SCREAM!
12.10.13 | THERE WILL BE ZEROO TOLERANCE
Symbolic ftw |
climactic
12.10.13 | rust |
Judio!
12.10.13 | I'm really not crazy about Symbolic. People give me shit for this all the time, but I think it's
immensely overrated. RIP, on the other hand, is just a pure masterpiece. Sorry guys... |
tempest--
12.10.13 | you will dig symbolic eventually just let it flow through your loins |
InbredJed
12.10.13 | bottom line is that Megadeth don't have a better album that Rust, where as Death have 2 albums better than Symbolic. |
Judio!
12.10.13 | Good point, Jed. I'll certainly have to relisten to Symbolic, because from what I remember I liked every other Death album better than Symbolic. This opinion can easily change, though. |
CK
12.10.13 | Well Human duh but other than that nah |
Judio!
12.10.13 | Sound of Perseverance > |
CK
12.10.13 | Some days yeah |
slimdaddy
12.10.13 | Symbolic |
InbredJed
12.10.13 | Individual Thought Patterns is better too |
Inveigh
12.10.13 | damn near impossible call but i might have to go rust |
YoYoMancuso
12.10.13 | the drums on TSoP are way too annoying, every song is like a huge 5-minute drum fill |
CK
12.10.13 | I don't mind the drums themselves, it's that damn production on them |
YoYoMancuso
12.10.13 | prob why Voice Of The Soul is the best song off that album |
InbredJed
12.10.13 | "prob why Voice Of The Soul is the best song off that album"
this, and that bitchin' cover of Painkiller |
InbredJed
12.10.13 | been listening to your album, Cap |
bloc
12.10.13 | Rust In Peace easily |
eternium
12.10.13 | Symbolic |
InbredJed
12.10.13 | yeah your death/metals taste yum bro |
InbredJed
12.10.13 | there's a shit tonne of lyrics, but I'm thru the 1st song and I like 'em
|
DominionMM1
12.10.13 | yeah man necro dogg was awesome |
MeatSalad
12.10.13 | Hmmm rust |
SCREAM!
12.10.13 | damn cap how many albums you got? |
InbredJed
12.10.13 | nonono Proverbial |
L4titudes
12.10.13 | too close to call
|
dathvada321
12.10.13 | symbolic |
JustinKing
12.10.13 | Symbolic for me, but both are amazing. |
Geadom
12.10.13 | I'm really not crazy about Symbolic. People give me shit for this all the time, but I think it's immensely overrated. RIP, on the other hand, is just a pure masterpiece. Sorry guys... (2)
|
JustinKing
12.10.13 | Symbolic isn't the best Death, in my opinion. Favorites are Individual Thought Patterns, Human, then Symbolic. Rust in Peace is undoubtedly best Megadeth, though. |
Keyblade
12.10.13 | SIMBOLIC |
CK
12.10.13 | Honestly, a little surprised KILL hasn't commented yet |
Wadlez
12.10.13 | RIP |
Trebor.
12.10.13 | Rust In Peace is one of the most overrated albums of all time and Symbolic is classic soooooo |
MrMackey
12.10.13 | Symbolic m'kay |
Ovrot
12.10.13 | WITHOUT JUDGEMENT WHAT WOULD WE DO? |
Trebor.
12.10.13 | Does anyone remember a single drum part besides the opener of Rust In Peace?
me neither
and those fucking vocals my god
and the album isn't heavy or catchy enough to be really |
Trebor.
12.10.13 | good |
tempest--
12.10.13 | yea uh i remember the whole god damn album you idiot |
Ovrot
12.10.13 | INSIDE CRYSTAL MOUNTAIN
EVIL TAKES ITS FORM |
Muisc4Life26
12.10.13 | St. Anger |
CK
12.10.13 | Hey, it's better than Death Magnetic |
Myrkur
12.10.13 | I prefer Death to Megadeth but I'll say Rust on this one |
Imperial
12.10.13 | Megadeth sucks Symbolic 5/5 |
Vakarian12
12.10.13 | rust |
KILL
12.10.13 | "Does anyone remember a single drum part besides the opener of Rust In Peace?"
um yes how about the classic drum intro to polaris or the perfect double bass use in five magics bridge or the whole of take no prisoners are you fucking kidding me menzas drumming is incredible on rip
and i aint choosin fuck ya'll
|
InbredJed
12.10.13 | ya pretty evenly matched |
Pestiferous
12.10.13 | synbolic |
Comatorium.
12.10.13 | Symbolic |
demigod!
12.10.13 | goddamn i hate when trebor enters metal threads, such a faux overload |
SpiritCrusher2
12.10.13 | they're both 5s, but nothing is better than Symbolic |
Pestiferous
12.10.13 | ^^ haha |
SpiritCrusher2
12.10.13 | "Does anyone remember a single drum part besides the opener of Rust In Peace?"
wow, you're weird. I'm a drummer and I consider RIP to be the most fun metal album to play on drums. it's not that hard, but it's so fun, creative and catchy. btw here's my ancient cover of RIP...Polaris https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=86UUZAuIOCA |
KILL
12.10.13 | honestly find the drumming more interesting on rip, if this was rip vs human it might be a diff story tho |
Vicho
12.10.13 | Symbolic, is a masterpiece. |
demigod!
12.10.13 | i always found gene to be a bit too flashy, like spirit said RIP's drumming is more creative and catchy and less about being technical as fuq so yeah i prefer RIP's drumming too |
SpiritCrusher2
12.10.13 | KILL is right about Human though, Sean Reinert is a GOD |
evilford
12.10.13 | gene rules but yeah human is on another level |
ncguitar
12.10.13 | I go back to Symbolic a lot more, so Symbolic for me! |
DikkoZinner
12.20.13 | Symbolic |
InbredJed
12.20.13 | Leprosy vs Cryptic Writings |
FadeToBlack
12.20.13 | apples vs oranges |
Trebor.
12.20.13 | oranges are way better than apples |
InbredJed
12.20.13 | Testicles vs Ovaries |
laucha1266
12.20.13 | well thats hard...
but i rather eat Ovaries than eat other's people testicles |
CK
12.20.13 | Oranges are way better than apples [-1] |
tempest--
12.21.13 | apples > |
SIMBOLIC
12.21.13 | turtles vs penguins
apples > (2) |
demigod!
12.21.13 | oranges are best fruit |
SIMBOLIC
12.21.13 | disagree hard |
tempest--
12.21.13 | dude biting in a crunchy, juicy apple is like the best thing ever |
SIMBOLIC
12.21.13 | ^^^^^ |
SIMBOLIC
12.21.13 | and symbolic by a pube |
SIMBOLIC
12.21.13 | lol hep |
Funeralopolis
12.21.13 | rust in peace |
hikingmetalpunk
12.21.13 | gotta agree with hep on this, symbolic takes this by a landslide. |
CK
12.21.13 | I mean, there's nothing wrong with Rust in Peace... there's just less wrong with Symbolic :) |
Dodenakker
05.27.14 | This isn't even a contest. |
Funeralopolis
05.27.14 | rust in peace |
Negator
05.27.14 | RIP Symbolic |
mandan
05.27.14 | I'm a bigger 'Deth fan than Death fan, but Symbolic is my fave Death, while RiP ain't my fave 'Deth. So, as much as RiP rules, my vote goes to Symbolic. |
L4titudes
05.27.14 | symbolic |
mandan
05.27.14 | Just realized that this is an old thread. |
CK
05.27.14 | Yeah this is old news dammit dodenakker |
WashboardSuds
05.27.14 | RIP. if this was rip vs human it might be a diff story tho[2] |
Geadom
05.29.14 | RIP. if this was rip vs human it might be a diff story tho[3]
This is not a test of power |
evilford
05.29.14 | here's a list that didn't need to be resurrected |
adr
05.29.14 | y u so evil damn |
TalonsOfFire
05.29.14 | RIP but it's close |
facupm
05.29.14 | tie |