wabbit
02.25.13 | correct
Hobbit is still amazing though |
ZilbelPing
02.25.13 | Yeah Fellowship is the best. |
Vakarian12
02.25.13 | nah Return was best |
CaptainHadouken
02.25.13 | Performance wise- Fellowship
EPIC battle/action wise- ROTK
Overall pick would be ROTK, but like i said, i thought fellowship had the best acting. |
wabbit
02.25.13 | The fighting is the worst part of the movies.
Like imagine how much better two towers would be if helm's deep was 10 minutes |
Mad.
02.25.13 | Hell no - 2, 3, 1, 4. Gotta be the extended ones as well...
RotK just has all the best parts of the first two x100... |
AngelofDeath
02.25.13 | I think Two Towers is probably the best movie. Return of the King is close, though. |
Hyperion1001
02.25.13 | i agree with this ranking |
AngelofDeath
02.25.13 | The book is even worse in that regard. |
ZilbelPing
02.25.13 | Two Towers was the worst/most boring one imo |
nononsense
02.25.13 | 4 could have been so much better. Too much attempted comedy and they added too much. The whole Necromancer thing was cool and made sense to add. The next one will be pretty awesome. |
ZilbelPing
02.25.13 | I need to re-watch all of them because Two Towers and ROTK are just a giant blur. |
nononsense
02.25.13 | For sure. I expect the Smaug scene in the next movie to be pretty awesome. |
AngelofDeath
02.25.13 | You sure they won't leave him out until the third film? |
Hyperion1001
02.25.13 | well you have bad taste so thats not surprising |
nononsense
02.25.13 | No the dragon scene is in the next film. They are saving the Battle of Five Armies for the third film. They should have done two films. |
Voivod
02.25.13 | I have been reading the "The Hobbit" the past few months little by little, great stuff.
Jackson does not follow the book precisely, but he did a good job anyway. |
AngelofDeath
02.25.13 | I definitely agree that it should have been two movies. |
AngelofDeath
02.25.13 | lol |
Hyperion1001
02.25.13 | ok
it is my professional opinions that andcas has bad taste and thus his opinions are not surprising |
ZilbelPing
02.25.13 | lol [2] |
nononsense
02.25.13 | If they did a third film, they should have brought back Aragorn and shown him and Gandalf hunt for Gollum and show how he escapes from the Elf's prisons. |
CaptainHadouken
02.25.13 | Hopefully the smaug scenes will be good in the next hobbit ones. I have to say andcas's comments about the gay hobbit undertones is so true. |
nononsense
02.25.13 | I'm pretty sure Tolkein didn't intend for gay undertones. Lol |
CaptainHadouken
02.25.13 | Haha, the movies had the more gay tones. Not so much in the books as in the movies though IMO |
nononsense
02.25.13 | I think Peter Jackson tries too hard. |
nononsense
02.25.13 | Sam got married at the end though. |
Atari
02.25.13 | i've honestly only seen two towers and return of the king once but i agree for the most part. |
wabbit
02.25.13 | In the book Sam is essentially retarded
So yeah all the gay undertones are imagined |
nononsense
02.25.13 | i've honestly only seen two towers and return of the king once but i agree for the most part.
I'd watch them again when you have time. |
Atari
02.25.13 | "I'd watch them again when you have time"
I will. I've seen the fellowship of the ring a few times it's my favorite and obviously the most original. |
nononsense
02.25.13 | I agree. |
wabbit
02.25.13 | Hanson is right so hard |
nononsense
02.25.13 | Who's Hanson? |
ViralOblivion
02.25.13 | Yah ranking is correct although I still haven't seen hobbit |
wabbit
02.25.13 | the man you should aspire to be |
Storm In A Teacup
02.25.13 | It's all the same fucking movie really |
FictionalFlames
02.25.13 | Silmarillion > everything else |
tiesthatbind
02.25.13 | Return>TT>Fellowship>Hobbit
All rule hard though |
Mad.
02.25.13 | Yeah, Frodo is a raging homo. |
Curse.
02.25.13 | TT>Return>Fellowship>Hobbit
Yeah, I enjoyed them all immensely |
SIMBOLIC
02.25.13 | OH SAMMM1!!!1!!11 |
nononsense
02.26.13 | Yeah you can't really go wrong with any of them. |