Funeralopolis
11.19.14 | you guys sure have some bad taste [7] |
BigSneakySnatch
11.19.14 | Really interesting list, proves how overrated 1 is |
ArsMoriendi
11.19.14 | I 2'd 3. lol |
Ryus
11.19.14 | lol 9 |
Ryus
11.19.14 | DAMNIT ARS |
Jots
11.19.14 | I 1'd all of these ayyyy |
BMDrummer
11.19.14 | recently un-5'd 2 |
wwf
11.19.14 | I have 4 5d. Am I a bad person |
Snake.
11.19.14 | wtf only 4.1% 5'd 20 |
SharkTooth
11.19.14 | uhh, I think you miscalculated on 20, it has 21 5's out of 509 ratings, which calculates to a 4.1% |
erizen826
11.19.14 | Only have 19 and 11 5'd. |
Funeralopolis
11.19.14 | @sharktooth and snake: Yes, thanks for pointing that out, not sure what I calculated there lol. Fixed it. |
SharkTooth
11.19.14 | also:
Trophy Scars-Holy Vacants has 23.7% 5's (134/565)
I reckon it deserves a spot here don't ya think? |
StallionMang
11.19.14 | Damn 2 Swans albums in the top 5 |
Funeralopolis
11.19.14 | @sharktooth: No because then I'd have to redo the whole list lol, I'm sure I probably missed one or two albums. |
Rowan5215
11.19.14 | Trophy Scars hell yes that deserves a spot
Surprisingly solid list I think although lol @ Diamond Eyes |
tempest--
11.19.14 | Diamond eyes lol |
tempest--
11.19.14 | Omg rowan haha |
SeaAnemone
11.19.14 | you missed Friendzone smh
would have made this list better
15.4% of the votes are 5s |
SeaAnemone
11.19.14 | oh wait you have a really dumb cutoff at 400 votes
that explains why this list is so bad, more than anything |
SeaAnemone
11.19.14 | like Smith St. Band is at 22% as well |
Kman418
11.19.14 | list sucks but 16 is cool |
Wadlez
11.19.14 | I have 4 5d. Am I a bad person
Yes |
danielito19
11.19.14 | 16 rules hard |
deathschool
11.19.14 | Dammit. I 5d one of these. How many do you have comply with before you're basic? |
danielito19
11.19.14 | 16 is acceptable to 5 death |:^) |
SharkTooth
11.19.14 | |
deathschool
11.19.14 | I gave two others a 4.5. Most of these aren't really all that 5able tbh IMO |
SharkTooth
11.19.14 | 5 and 14 are definite 5's tbh |
Shuyin
11.19.14 | i dont get whats so special about 2 and 3 tbh |
MMX
11.19.14 | "Between The Buried And Me
Parllax II: The Future Sequence
18% (metal album with biggest proportion of 5's this decade so far!)"
Jesus Christ
amen |
Veldin
11.19.14 | wait, some of you are hateful of Trophy Scars now? Holy shit, what? |
deathschool
11.19.14 | 3, 19, and 11 are 3s |
deathschool
11.19.14 | Holy Vacants is a 3 too |
deathschool
11.19.14 | No wait, shit. Diamond Eyes is a 2.5 |
deathschool
11.19.14 | Seven degrees |
Wadlez
11.19.14 | Trophy Scars could release an collection of farts and some here would eat em up. |
SharkTooth
11.19.14 | holy shit I just realized that xspongexcorex has 49% of its ratings as 5's |
Veldin
11.19.14 | Man, Trophy Scars are a bunch of sweet fellas. They're just like you and I; struggling artists who are doing their best to create something meaningful. I've been following them for 8 years now, and only with their most recent release being well received have people been bitching and pricking about them. I strongly believe they do not deserve any negative scrutiny. |
jtswope
11.19.14 | I see it all, I see it all. |
deathschool
11.19.14 | So.... Striving to make something beautiful deserves you critical acclaim? Aren't most artists doing that? |
Veldin
11.19.14 | Critical acclaim? Not necessarily. Respect? I believe so. |
titanslayer
11.19.14 | What's wrong with you people? How does 9 get any 5s |
Veldin
11.19.14 | You not a fan of space in yo metal? |
titanslayer
11.19.14 | It's overly long and some of the song writing is questionable. I'll admit it has it's moments but I really don't see how so many people love it as much as they do |
thacoconut94
11.19.14 | Kanye west and kendrick are not 5's. |
ScuroFantasma
11.19.14 | Woulda thought BWP would be here |
ChoccyPhilly
11.19.14 | It would but it's not part of this decade. |
wwf
11.19.14 | I'm not surprised Parallax 2 is on here. Most BTBAM fans think they're the best thing since sliced bread
Source: I was really into them around the time Parallax 2 came out. Don't think I would've fived it then but w/e |
Artuma
11.19.14 | congrats for your well-earned feature |
RadicalEd
11.19.14 | sputnik rules. |
zakalwe
11.19.14 | High Violet is a classic record produced from one of the decades best bands. In years to come it will be spoken about.
The others won't.
|
adr
11.19.14 | lol 4 and 10
also The Greatest Generation have more 5's |
Artuma
11.19.14 | btw the monitor has a 22.9% and everyone of you missed it. shame on you |
adr
11.19.14 | Hubardo and the new Trophy Scars have ton of stupid 5's aswell D: |
Sniff
11.19.14 | Man you guys suck |
ChoccyPhilly
11.19.14 | Hubardo doesn't have 400 ratings.
That number is too high. It should be at least 250 or something |
IntriguingSergei
11.19.14 | This is truly lamentable. |
SharkTooth
11.19.14 | "Hubardo and the new Trophy Scars have ton of stupid 5's aswell D:"
except the 5's for Trophy Scars are smart |
letme69johndarnielle
11.19.14 | Titus Andronicus - The Monitor |
letme69johndarnielle
11.19.14 | nevermind someone already said that |
Funeralopolis
11.19.14 | added trophy scars and titus |
theacademy
11.19.14 | ugh NO
this is a listing of 'highest percentage of 5.0 ratings (of all ratings for albums rated 400 times or more)'
definitely not a list of most 5'd albums |
Funeralopolis
11.19.14 | I'd argue it is, out of everyone who listened to these albums, they 5'd these the most. If you listen to these you are more likely to 5 them, I'd say that's a much better indicator than simply number of 5's. |
SeaAnemone
11.19.14 | lol dat logic |
MO
11.19.14 | don't understand how anyone can consider 20 a classic it's fucking terrible |
theacademy
11.19.14 | jesus unfeaturing because of that logic |
SeaAnemone
11.19.14 | "If you listen to these you are more likely to 5 them"
classic |
ChoccyPhilly
11.19.14 | 20 is brilliant
"If you listen to these you are more likely to 5 them"
umm... how do these albums differ to others? |
UnderTheNorthernScar
11.19.14 | all of these albums kick major ass except for 20 and 3. don't be ridiculous. |
SharkTooth
11.19.14 | " If you listen to these you are more likely to 5 them"
Please tell me that wasn't a serious statement |
klap
11.19.14 | dying |
MO
11.19.14 | "I'd argue it is, out of everyone who listened to these albums, they 5'd these the most. If you listen to these you are more likely to 5 them, I'd say that's a much better indicator than simply number of 5's. "
I'm sorry wtf is this |
Funeralopolis
11.19.14 | From a literal statistical stand point you are more likely to 5 these albums than any other albums from this decade if you listen to them, seeing as how each % is a proportion of everyone who listened to it. Not sure what is so hard to understand. |
SharkTooth
11.19.14 | That conclusion simply makes no sense, there could be plenty of factors when it comes to the # of. 5's, perhaps they all are alts, perhaps they are crazed fanboys who haven't visited the site since, there is no reasonable basis for one to assume that people are more likely to 5 something recent if a lot of other accounts 5'd it |
ChoccyPhilly
11.19.14 | @under what's wrong with 20? it kicks arse in its own way.
@funeral yeah, you're right actually. The title is still a little misleading |
chinesewhispers
11.19.14 | 4 a classic over 5, 8, and 9? I like Devin too but damn, that's a little steep |
Funeralopolis
11.19.14 | Casualties of Cool seems to get a disproportionate amount of love around this site. |
laughingman22
11.19.14 | Casualties of Cool seems to get a disproportionate amount of hate around other sites. |
Wadlez
11.19.14 | Hardly a 'classic' album. |
ChoccyPhilly
11.19.14 | A good one, maybe not a classic but I can definitely see how others might think it is |
SpiritCrusher2
11.19.14 | lol 11 |
Veldin
11.19.14 | Hubardo deserves a 5, frigg off Ricky. |
Veldin
11.19.14 | 2,5-10 are some of the sexiest albums of the last ten years tho |
VaxXi
11.19.14 | Good list tho |
mortifierftw
11.30.14 | The Greatest Generation: 26.2% |
