macman76
User

Soundoffs 4
Album Ratings 142
Objectivity 62%

Last Active 09-25-20 9:08 pm
Joined 11-12-11

Review Comments 2,122

 Lists
06.14.18 World Cup 2018 04.16.18 Model Talk
04.09.18 Who wants to be a model?* 03.11.18 Most m/'s
02.28.18 Stat Tank 02.27.17 Blog Needs a Name
02.10.17 2016: To Be Sputnik Is to Be Nowhere 12.10.16 Sputnik: A Genre History
12.06.16 The Polls Did Alright12.04.16 Paired Genres
11.27.16 Album Rankings If Only Trve Fans Counte11.23.16 The Top 250 Users: The App
10.30.16 The Top 250 Users10.28.16 The Sputnik Years: The App
10.18.16 The Sputnik Years: The Uncharted10.17.16 2015: We Sputnik?
10.17.16 2014: Sputnik, Like NoPlace Is There10.16.16 2013: Sputnik Will Find Me
More »

How often do you change your ratings?

Back again, I scraped all of the staff/contrib/emeritus data (including users not listed as staff on the staff page that I've learned were once staff members including the users Hep Kat, morrissey, and pixiesfanyo) to see how often their review ratings vary from their listed rating. I'll publish this data later today, but I want to ask you guys how often you change your ratings, how often you think other people do, and guess how often the staff do. Note that the results will be an underestimate since a staff member may change their rating back to their original rating (which would be detected as no change in rating), or changed it twice or more to different ratings each time (which would be detected as only one rating).
1Sparta
Wiretap Scars


I'm fairly certain this is the first review still on the site.
http://www.sputnikmusic.com/review/30/Sparta-Wiretap-Scars/
2Method Man
Tical


It is impossible to know, based on a users’ rating, if they have changed it at any point. If you change a rating, the time stamp of when you updated the rating is not recorded. So, one way to see how often users change their ratings is to see how their review ratings and listed rating differ. Getting a representative sample of users is difficult (I mean, I could randomly search user id #s until I had a decent sample) so I opted to trust that they staff members, contibs, and emeritus are a representative sample. Most if not all started as regular users, and most probably became staff members because what they reviewed and rated were relevant to the site’s user base (either a niche within it or as a whole). So I scraped all of the staff members listed on the http://www.sputnikmusic.com/staff.php page, and a couple others that I learned were staff. The following data is from 7060 album review rating/listed rating pairs of the staff users:
376 Percent Uncertain
Nothing But Love Songs


1252 ratings differences (17.7 % of review ratings and listed ratings differed)
4The Changes
Today is Tonight


Average difference between rating and review score when there was a change = -0.173 (rating-review)
5Grower
Grower


829 of the 1252 ratings (66.2 %) changes were +.5 or -.5
6Absolution
The Beginning


Average absolute rating change = 0.580 (when they differed, what was the average of that absolute difference)
7Every Time I Die
Ex Lives


Average days difference between rating date and review date (rating date-review date):

When they had changed a rating: +269 days

When they had NOT changed a rating: +20.1 days
8Eminem
Relapse


Album is the biggest positive difference between rating and review: Iluvatar (4.0 rating difference)
9Porcupine Tree
Fear of a Blank Planet


Album is the biggest negative difference between rating and review: Mikesn (-3.5 rating difference)
102Pac
Greatest Hits


Album is the biggest positive difference between rating date and review date (review came first): Hep Kat (rating 3122 days after review)
11Emperor
In the Nightside Eclipse


Album is the biggest negative difference between rating date and review date (rating came first): Crysis (review 2580 days after rating)
Show/Add Comments (49)

STAFF & CONTRIBUTORS // CONTACT US

Bands: A B C D E F G H I J K L M N O P Q R S T U V W X Y Z


Site Copyright 2005-2023 Sputnikmusic.com
All Album Reviews Displayed With Permission of Authors | Terms of Use | Privacy Policy