Cipieron
11.04.11 | this has all my fav metalcore bands too... none of them |
Pharoh
11.04.11 | |
seedofnothing
11.04.11 |
|
AfterTheBreakdown
11.04.11 | Some good ones here...... |
seedofnothing
11.04.11 |
|
whywontyoudie
11.04.11 | this list again, only it's done right |
Cipieron
11.04.11 | no way 3 is better than 6 |
Pharoh
11.04.11 | |
whywontyoudie
11.04.11 | Jake Fleming m/ |
seedofnothing
11.04.11 |
|
Cipieron
11.04.11 | aw you ruined the conversation we were having, and with such a shitty list too |
Escapedmyfate
11.04.11 | Im Sorry about the other list guys i should of said "My top MTALCORE/DEATHCORE/ROCK Albums instead of "Top 50 Albums Of 2011".
and these are some of the best metalcore bands going around. |
AfterTheBreakdown
11.04.11 | these all suck imo exept 2's early stuff |
AfterTheBreakdown
11.04.11 | and some of 1's albums are good |
seedofnothing
11.04.11 | my name is afterthebreakdown and I like Northlane |
Acrosstheshield13
11.04.11 | this whole list sucks...with the exception of 1. they have a few good records. |
Lolgical
11.04.11 | It's ok op. we all listened to shitty music when were freshmen too. I mean my favorite band back then was Throwdown. So there's still hope even for you. |
djunior
11.04.11 | cool list |
Escapedmyfate
11.04.11 | It doesn't say the best metalcore bands ever it says top 10 metalcore bands dont by me so i you go die you waste of fucking space. :) |
whywontyoudie
11.04.11 | Listen to Botch, Zao, The Dillinger Escape Plan, 7 Angels 7 Plagues, Amia Venera Landscape, and Deadguy.
"dont by me so i you go die you waste of fucking space"
..what? |
Escapedmyfate
11.04.11 | The only decent band in that is Amia Venera Landscape. |
Lolgical
11.04.11 | Yea, fuck botch. They're not good metalcore. |
AfterTheBreakdown
11.04.11 | Lolololololol |
EyeForAnEye
11.04.11 | LOL |
GreyShadow
11.04.11 | 10 is great and 9 isnt terrible. the rest is shit |
ILJ
11.04.11 | Most of 1, 10, and 9's recent album are good. Rest is bad.
Oh wait, 4 is good too. |
Acrosstheshield13
11.04.11 | "Yea, fuck botch. They're not good metalcore."
the fuck?!...you can't be serious. |
AfterTheBreakdown
11.04.11 | Yeah what the fuck.. |
pcar
11.04.11 | fucking botch |
Pharoh
11.04.11 | botch fucking |
IAmHollywood
11.04.11 | why did I click on this |
xevman
11.04.11 | are you actually serious? |
dimsim3478
11.04.11 | He doesn't defend his tastes sincerely enough, so it sounds like he's just a troll (but a shitty one at that). |
Hocmat
11.04.11 | I come for trollin |
Persist
11.05.11 | just gtfo sputnik escapedmyfat |
sspedding
11.05.11 | definitely an alt |
jackalope11
11.05.11 | Where the fuck is Underoath and August Burns Red? Those guys, Parkway, and TDWP are like the kings of metalcore. |
Trebor.
11.05.11 | ugh |
Winsomniac
11.05.11 | :|
|
Winsomniac
11.05.11 | He sure escaped a horrible fate. |
inspectorK
11.05.11 | "Yea, fuck botch. They're not good metalcore."
the fuck?!...you can't be serious.
[2] |
witchxrapist
11.05.11 | To be more real:
1. Converge
2. Botch
3. The Dillinger Escape Plan
4. Coalesce
5. Buried Inside
6. Drowningman
7. Deadguy
8. The Secret
9. Curl Up And Die
10. Underoath
|
NWOAHM666
11.05.11 | ^Half of those bands are noisecore |
Relinquished
11.05.11 | yeah cuz noisecore is real genre |
ShadowRemains
11.05.11 | haha |
witchxrapist
11.05.11 | lmfao |
jackalope11
11.06.11 | Dillinger is fucking great, but I wouldn't call it metalcore.
|
NWOAHM666
11.06.11 | "yeah cuz noisecore is real genre"
Tell me wrong then. |
FrankRedHot
11.06.11 | They're metalcore you fucking idiot.
God, you're so fucking dumb. |
NWOAHM666
11.06.11 | "They're metalcore you fucking idiot."
[facepalm]
You're the one who can't distinguish noisecore from metalcore and I'm the dumb one?
I confess that noisecore draws heavily from metalcore, but so does deathcore yet nobody calls metalcore to Whitechapel or All Shall Perish.
|
FrankRedHot
11.06.11 | "You're the one who can't distinguish noisecore from metalcore and I'm the dumb one?"
NOISECORE DOESN'T EXIST!
As I said, you're a fucking idiot.
"I confess that noisecore draws heavily from metalcore, but so does deathcore yet nobody calls metalcore to Whitechapel or All Shall Perish. "
THat's because they are deathcore. |
NWOAHM666
11.06.11 | "NOISECORE DOESN'T EXIST!"
On that case how do you classify those bands? (don't say metalcore because it's obviously not)
|
NWOAHM666
11.06.11 | "classify which bands exactly. you've thrown out metalcore and deathcore."
Bands whose sound draws from metalcore but has a more experimental vein, often with elements of noise rock. The Dillinger Escape Plan, Converge and Coalesce serve as example. |
FrankRedHot
11.06.11 | "On that case how do you classify those bands? (don't say metalcore because it's obviously not)"
Since you seem to be going with the wikipedia definition, NWOAHM, why don't you look up all ten of those bands' wiki pages, and you tell me what they are... |
NWOAHM666
11.06.11 | "Since you seem to be going with the wikipedia definition, NWOAHM, why don't you look up all ten of those bands' wiki pages, and you tell me what they are..."
Wikipedia thinks Slipknot are nü-metal and Chimaira are metalcore just because the retarded music journalists do. And BTW I didn't say ALL of those bands were noisecore. |
FrankRedHot
11.06.11 | "Wikipedia thinks Slipknot are nü-metal"
That's because they are.
"Chimaira are metalcore just because the retarded music journalists do. "
No, they're metalcore because they make metalcore music. If you don't want to call them metalcore, that's because you don't want them to be associated with a genre with such a bad reputation nowadays. |
botb
11.06.11 | lots of trolls in this thread |
FrankRedHot
11.06.11 | Except NWOAHM isn't a troll, breakdown. |
botb
11.06.11 | i'm not convinced |
FrankRedHot
11.06.11 | I am.... check out my shoutbox from about 2 months ago
|
FrankRedHot
11.06.11 | Believe it or no, breakdown, there are completely oblivious idiots on this planet. Not everyone is trolling |
Scoot
11.06.11 | gotta love noisecore |
botb
11.06.11 | ya and their username rhymes with raftertheshakedown |
FrankRedHot
11.06.11 | "ya and their username rhymes with raftertheshakedown"
Or it could be 999MHAOWN backwards |
botb
11.06.11 | i just try to give people the benefit of the doubt yknow. but sucks that they actually think noisecore is a genre |
botb
11.06.11 | botch is such norma jean worship amiright |
FrankRedHot
11.06.11 | What are you talking about? If it weren't for As I Lay Dying, we wouldn't have bands like Shai Hulud and Rorschach! |
anarchistfish
11.06.11 | lol username |
Outnumbered
11.06.11 | came for the trollin', stayed for the lawls. |
NWOAHM666
11.07.11 | "That's because they are."
Yeah, right. They're totally like LB or Papa Roach. Exactly the same and all.
"No, they're metalcore because they make metalcore music. If you don't want to call them metalcore, that's because you don't want them to be associated with a genre with such a bad reputation nowadays."
While I have to admit that you're right in your last 16 words, I'd honestly ask you if you consider Machine Head, Fear Factory and Slayer to be metalcore as well.
Plus, if you want a proof that noisecore exists (from journalists, yes, but from journalists I actually approve):
http://www.decibelmagazine.com/hall-of-fame/coalesce/
I start quoting: "Coalesce had just cut a deal with Relapse that promised to break them out of the burgeoning so-called 'noisecore' movement (Converge, the Dillinger Escape Plan, Botch, Isis, the National Acrobat, et al) and place them atop the commercial heap."
Now argue with this.
|
Zorak
11.07.11 | This list is basically identical to that shitty one your2diefor created. I believe this is the work of a troll alt |
anarchistfish
11.07.11 | ""That's because they are."
Yeah, right. They're totally like LB or Papa Roach. Exactly the same and all."
you don't have to sound like another band to be in the same subgenre as them wtf
anyway Papa Roach aren't really nu metal anymore |
fr33convict
11.07.11 | YOU CAN'T EVEN HANDLE THE PROG-JAZZ-FUSION |
FrankRedHot
11.07.11 | "While I have to admit that you're right in your last 16 words, I'd honestly ask you if you consider Machine Head, Fear Factory and Slayer to be metalcore as well. "
If you're really Sonic's friend and not another Sonic alt, for once, I feel bad for Sonic, because that is one of the most ridiculous questions/statements I've ever read.
"I start quoting: "Coalesce had just cut a deal with Relapse that promised to break them out of the burgeoning so-called 'noisecore' movement (Converge, the Dillinger Escape Plan, Botch, Isis, the National Acrobat, et al) and place them atop the commercial heap."
I will. It's called Decibel magazine. If you want to read a magazine that doesn't cater to scene kids and uninformed morons, then read something else. "Noisecore" might have a certain sound(which it doesn't), but that doesn't mean it's an official genre.
Hey guys, have you heard of the blackened-noise-post-death-metalcore movement? |
Maniac!
11.07.11 | this thread reminded me that I need to re-acquire coalesce. Thanks |
MO
11.07.11 | good 'ol genre debates, always worth a good laugh |
BigHans
11.07.11 | saw metalcore list. Knew it would have alot of comments and that Pit would be owning someone. Seriously Sputnik is so fucking obsessed with the "cores" its gay. |
FrankRedHot
11.07.11 | It's not a genre debate when the genre isn't real. |
Scoot
11.07.11 | only the faggy members^^ |
BigHans
11.07.11 | I know, was just saying I think the most popular genres on here aside from Indie are metalcore, post hardcore, hardcore, death core, etc etc etc. If not, they get the most comments. |
BigHans
11.07.11 | also "core" discussions attract way more idiots |
UnnamedOcean
11.07.11 | I didn't even know you could make a list of 10 good metalcore bands!
Oh, I see what you did there... |
lucasjcockcroft
11.07.11 | this is my list from a year ago, scenefag me and you would have been great friends :) |
BigHans
11.07.11 | I cant say Im a metalcore expert but I do know that The Devil Wears Prada and Bring Me The Horizon are two of the worst artists in the history of music. |
FrankRedHot
11.07.11 | "I know, was just saying I think the most popular genres on here aside from Indie are metalcore, post hardcore, hardcore, death core, etc etc etc. If not, they get the most comments."
Be careful how you talk about hardcore around me, Hans. Might have to give your Yankee ass a good ol' southern beatdown. |
witnessesUK
11.14.11 | No ABR or Misery Signals or Counterparts? *sigh* |
Zorak
11.14.11 | witness, we've been through this. OP sucks, let's all move on. |
