GorgonzolaCheese1
10.08.10 | Psh, I rule. |
Maniac!
10.08.10 | Decent list |
Wolfhorde
10.08.10 | The order of the list is kind of a mystery to me. |
GorgonzolaCheese1
10.08.10 | You're the one confused. Does this look like it's ranked? I would hope not. |
kangaroopoo
10.08.10 | drum-kick-boom-tish-beat-tap-fap list |
bungy
10.08.10 | Oh I sincerely miss those heavy metal bands
I used to go see on the landing in the summer
She fell in love with the drummer
She fell in love with the drummer
She fell in love |
deathofasalesman
10.08.10 | "You're the one confused. Does this look like it's ranked? I would hope not."
You put it in reverse order. It most definitely looks ranked. |
GorgonzolaCheese1
10.08.10 | As usual, Sputnik reads way too much into the numbers and not the list. Congrats. |
BigHans
10.08.10 | Needs dudes from Prong, Biohazard, Sepultura, and Lamb of God |
GorgonzolaCheese1
10.08.10 | Chris Adler from LOG is definitely an Honorable Mention. He gets way too much praise, though. Biohazard? Sepultura? PRONG?!?! Really?
I think not. |
BigHans
10.08.10 | settle down Pit was just trollin ya there. Those bands rule though. |
GorgonzolaCheese1
10.08.10 | Biohazard is okay, Sepultura was once great(Igor Cavalera is a great drummer, just not top 25), and Prong's was a bit boring. |
wyankeif1337
10.08.10 | 25, 23, 14, 13, 8, 5, 4, and 1 are fucking awesome.
And I totally agree with Haake's placement here: the man's a beast. |
BigHans
10.08.10 | Biohazard - Urban Discipline rules. Forgot about it for years, re-discovering now. And Prong can get boring at times but their good songs slay. |
Emim
10.08.10 | 2 and 12 are the only "Heavy Metal" drummers here. |
deathofasalesman
10.08.10 | "As usual, Sputnik reads way too much into the numbers and not the list. Congrats."
No, reverse order pretty much indicates a ranked list. |
GorgonzolaCheese1
10.08.10 | No, the indicator is a listmaker saying the list is ranked. Stop over-complicating things. |
Inveigh
10.08.10 | if the numbers don't matter why did you edit it for reverse order?
either way solid list |
BigHans
10.08.10 | Pit, do you think McBrain is the driving force behind Maiden more so than the dual guitar attack or the galloping bass? |
Inveigh
10.08.10 | haha deathofasalesman beat me to it |
WoggleBunny
10.08.10 | 23 should be 1
1 should be 2 |
GorgonzolaCheese1
10.08.10 | "if the numbers don't matter why did you edit it for reverse order?
either way solid list"
I didn't edit it to countdown, I accidentally clicked on the countdown button as well as the description button, and I'm just too lazy to edit it. Stop reading into the numbers so much.
Hans- I think it's a combination of both the bass and the McBrain. That combination is powerful. |
Inveigh
10.08.10 | oh yeah where's Meg White?!?!?! |
GorgonzolaCheese1
10.08.10 | On my penis while I'm filming. |
Emim
10.08.10 | Pansy. |
GorgonzolaCheese1
10.08.10 | I try. |
Inveigh
10.08.10 | I thought Mimsy's posts were pretty funny... |
GorgonzolaCheese1
10.08.10 | I thought they were pretty lame, hence the mass deletion. |
Inveigh
10.08.10 | mass deletion sounds like the name of a bad hardcore band |
Emim
10.08.10 | Just cause I was right ;) |
GorgonzolaCheese1
10.08.10 | Yeah, Emim. You're totally right. None of these but two of them are heavy metal drummers. SYL doesn't have any heavy metal in their music at all. I guess neither does Cryptopsy. I guess we need to change the name of death metal, too.
That would be funny, Blake. |
Emim
10.08.10 | Heavy metal is a subgenre of metal. You could say they are all metal drummers, but otherwise you might as well say they are all black metal drummers. |
GorgonzolaCheese1
10.08.10 | Emim, I like you and all, but metal=heavy metal. Heavy metal is not a subgenre of "metal." That's just redundant. |
literalsurrealist
10.08.10 | Jason Roeder is worth mentioning too. |
Inveigh
10.08.10 | lol gotta side with Pit on this one
that's like saying rock and roll is a sub-genre of rock. |
GorgonzolaCheese1
10.08.10 | ^Exactly. |
GorgonzolaCheese1
10.08.10 | Annnnndddddd Emim disappears..... |
Emim
10.08.10 | No more redundant than calling something hard or soft rock instead of just rock. |
H61
10.08.10 | 'Heavy metal is a subgenre of metal'
lol |
Emim
10.08.10 | Disappears? I don't sit here and refresh the page waiting for your answer. |
GorgonzolaCheese1
10.08.10 | Lol, Emim, but you can't just call everything rock. Hard and soft rock are completely different from each other while still maintaining a few similarities. You wouldn't put Air Supply and Guns 'n' Roses in the same category, would you? |
Inveigh
10.08.10 | nah it's different because "metal" is just short for "heavy metal" -- it was the first way the genre was ever described.
going by that logic... are you saying Strapping Young Lad aren't heavy? |
GorgonzolaCheese1
10.08.10 | "Disappears? I don't sit here and refresh the page waiting for your answer."
Why not? All of my answers are very important. |
Emim
10.08.10 | "Lol, Emim, but you can't just call everything rock. Hard and soft rock are completely different from each other while still maintaining a few similarities. You wouldn't put Air Supply and Guns 'n' Roses in the same category, would you?"
And yet I look at the list, and you have Sabbath next to Meshuggah and Maiden next to Mayhem. Seriously, what is the point you're arguing? |
Emim
10.08.10 | "nah it's different because "metal" is just short for "heavy metal" -- it was the first way the genre was ever described. going by that logic... are you saying Strapping Young Lad aren't heavy?"
Going by what logic? |
Inveigh
10.08.10 | I think his point is that death metal, metalcore, melodeath, black metal etc. are all sub-genres of heavy metal |
GorgonzolaCheese1
10.08.10 | The point I'm arguing is that they're all heavy metal, just like every hard rock and soft rock band are still rock. Heavy Metal is not a subgenre of metal. That's just ig'nant. |
Emim
10.08.10 | I accept and appreciate your opinion. |
GorgonzolaCheese1
10.08.10 | My opinion is widely accepted as fact. |
Emim
10.08.10 | Yeah I'm sure it is. |
GorgonzolaCheese1
10.08.10 | President Obama comes to me when he has issues with the country. What does that tell ya? |
fr33convict
10.08.10 | That Obama needs a new advisor.
Also, list needs the drummer of Gojira. |
GorgonzolaCheese1
10.08.10 | Mario's a definite honorable mention, fr33 |
trailofdead91
10.08.10 | 2 owns all |
deathofasalesman
10.08.10 | This is ranked. |
botb
10.08.10 | 1 is incredible but god he's overrated |
Torii
10.09.10 | Good one. |
fr33convict
10.11.10 | NO GENE HOLGAN?!?! |
ShadowRemains
10.11.10 | learn to spell his name right fr33 |
deathofasalesman
10.11.10 | Yeah, def needs more Hulk Hogan. |
GorgonzolaCheese1
10.11.10 | Don't tell him that shadow. If he learns to spell the name right, he might notice it on the list, like everyone else did. |
Pastor of Muppets
10.13.10 | 1. You forget Danny Carrey on purpose to get us Tool fans all hot & bothered, didn't you?
2. I haven't heard Glass Caket, but Blake Richardson is not very impressive with BTBAM.
3. Gavin Harrison is NOT close enough to a metal drummer. He has more taste than that. |
FadeToBlack
10.13.10 | yah cos the world revolves around angsty 12 year old Tool fanboys |
GorgonzolaCheese1
10.13.10 | Tool's the most over-blown, overrated band I've ever heard. I still like some of their work, but no, my world doesn't revolve around Tool fanboys. They should be pissed off enough already. |
