MyRatingisLaw
09.16.10 | I only posted Runner Ups for the years where there were many really good albums. |
AngelofDeath
09.16.10 | Pretty good picks minus the BTBAM. Not so sure about DEP for this year either. |
Dryden
09.16.10 | some good stuff |
Lunarfall
09.16.10 | Not too fond of the 80s picks, but the 90s are mostly spot on. |
Countess
09.16.10 | i agree for the most part
i prefer #7's runner up
29 is a bit surprising |
MyRatingisLaw
09.16.10 | 29 owns |
BallsToTheWall
09.16.10 | Too much Celtic Frost but not bad. |
climactic
09.16.10 | Oh the times they are a changin' |
Countess
09.16.10 | Massive Conspiracy Against All Life-4.5
guess i should check it out since YourRatingisLaw
|
Hyperion1001
09.16.10 | Leviathan are really hit or miss. This list if pretty agreeable though. |
whywontyoudie
09.16.10 | i'm a fan of this list. |
climactic
09.16.10 | It is rather awesome. |
Hyperion1001
09.16.10 | Only thing this needs is Ashes Against the Grain in the '06 spot. |
FeralMemories
09.16.10 | Awesome, although I would've given a year to Death. |
Bfhurricane
09.16.10 | 86 is far off, but that's just because I'm a Metallica fanboy. Great list, interesting choice for 30, I may agree. |
MyRatingisLaw
09.16.10 | oh yeah! ASHES! i forgot! omfg. thanks. |
MyRatingisLaw
09.16.10 | and I'm a big fan of Celtic Frost |
MyRatingisLaw
09.16.10 | and since i already have a btbam for 2005 i'll give 2007 up to The Ocean |
AnotherBrick
09.16.10 | ehhh |
MyRatingisLaw
09.16.10 | and Below the Lights is a great album but I don't actually think it should be album of the year, although I am very fond of Enslaved. I think I will change it. |
demon of surveillance
09.16.10 | A little too much black metal but good list. |
ArizonaBay97
09.16.10 | Great list |
MyRatingisLaw
09.16.10 | nevermind. 2003 sucked overall so Enslaved takes the cake. and I think I evened out the genres pretty well, although I am a fan of the black metal genre. |
chaos17
09.16.10 | There were a lot better metal albums released in 07 than Precambrian.... |
liledman
09.16.10 | some pretty good choices here. |
acorncheese
09.16.10 | too much metal |
LepreCon
09.16.10 | 1 and 18 are the only ones I'd absolutely agree with but that isn't to say most of the list isn't sweet |
wyankeif1337
09.16.10 | Panopticon deserves more than runner-up status, if you ask me. But good list. |
MyRatingisLaw
09.16.10 | Panopticon is a very very close runner up. so is Miss Machine. All three of those albums are pretty much equal, I chose Worship because it makes me look cool and hip. |
zarquan99
09.16.10 | 2000 should be runner up. Awesome list. |
Sheeple9000
09.16.10 | List is solid.
*brainfart*
...but
...can't
...quite
...figure out
...what
...moar
...it kneedz.
hmmm |
RippingCorpse
09.16.10 | list is good |
NeutralThunder12
09.16.10 | where's
metallica |
RippingCorpse
09.16.10 | lol |
neilk101
09.16.10 | 1991 -Carcass - Necroticism - Descanting the Insalubrious
1997 - Emperor - Anthems to the Welkin at Dusk
2003 - Ephel Duath - The Painters Palette
2009 - Hacride - Lazarus |
HenchmanOfSanta
09.16.10 | 2001 produced three amazing albums (Blackwater Park, Imaginary Sonicscape and Bath), and you don't even have them as a runner-up to fucking Converge? |
Hawks
09.16.10 | Don't Break the Oath for 1984. |
ThyCrossAwaits
09.16.10 | my only discrepancy is that Discordance Axis would have beaten out Immolation, no questions. |
Baphomet
09.16.10 | Amazing list, agree on mostly all of them but Colors should be 2007 MAOTY.
No Opeth? That's a sputnik first... |
Gmork89
09.16.10 | Great list, just awesome. |
Emim
09.16.10 | Great list, just awesome. [2] |
Ted
09.16.10 | still life > calculating infinity |
BigHans
09.16.10 | No Metallica = massive fail. |
Maniac!
09.16.10 | Bighans is homosexual for James Hetfield |
RippingCorpse
09.16.10 | who isnt?
o wait just everyone except hans and progmaster |
BigHans
09.16.10 | oh I dont know, maybe any of the 100 million people that have bought a Metallica record |
BigHans
09.16.10 | Also, no mention of Megadeth, Testament, Anthrax and Maiden = epic fail as well. Hell, even Death isnt on here. |
Baphomet
09.16.10 | I bought a Metallica record, hell even their whole discog. (yes, including St. Anger.) and I still
love the 'tallica, but there's no room for them in this list. Nor Megadeth, Anthrax, fuck no
Testament. An argument for Death could be done, though. |
Jesuslaves
09.16.10 | 3 is overrated as fuck. |
Jesuslaves
09.16.10 | Yeah you'd think Maiden would get at least one spot on there. |
Poet
09.17.10 | But they're not Venom, Celtic Frost, or Bathory. Nor are they br00tal enough |
DonniSharK
09.17.10 | MFW Death was beaten by Darkthrone --> :-|....
MFW Dillinger Escape Plan aren't a metal band --> ...
MFW the rest of the list is epic win --> :D |
TheyTookOurJobs
09.17.10 | Weird 80's picks |
geng
09.17.10 | Axe To Fall >>>>>> Wavering Radiant. |
RippingCorpse
09.17.10 | theres many better metal picks for 2009 than both albums anyway |
tokilltheking
10.31.10 | Great list, I would have more Death, and Toby Driver of some sort. |
ThyCrossAwaits
10.31.10 | now that i see this again, I also disagree on your 2009....but yeah, '01 had so much good stuff. |
outline
10.31.10 | needs moar opeth |
