JesusV4
05.05.10 | Very difficult to rank. I think it might be better to rank favorite periods: 1. Dark Side Era (DS through Animals) 2. post-Barrett Era 3. Barrett Era 4. Waters Era 5. Gilmour Era |
AnotherBrick
05.05.10 | you failed |
Parallels
05.05.10 | im sick of people ranking radiohead and pink floyd
|
AnotherBrick
05.05.10 | if anyone wants to know the actual ranking you can go find my list. sputnik approved my ranking |
Parallels
05.05.10 | fantaaaaasticles! |
LiquidVelvet
05.05.10 | MOVE 7 UP |
NigelH
05.05.10 | Nice to see Animals at one, although how the fuck is Meddle worse than Obscured by Clouds? |
JesusV4
05.05.10 | Eh, I didn't expect to meet the consensus. Sorry, but Meddle has a lot of filler. Sure, Echoes is STELLAr, and One of These Days is also awesome, as is Pillow of Winds, but everything else in between is lackluster - And dear God, can we agree that Puppies sucks? |
JesusV4
05.05.10 | AnotherBrick: I went to your page, I saw lots of lists, but not your PF list. What's it clled? Or is it obvious and I missed it? I'm weary of corporate approved lists (sorry, Sputnik) but I'd like to see. These are my preferences. |
AnotherBrick
05.05.10 | http://www.sputnikmusic.com/list.php?memberid=244897&listid=37024
haha damn clever titles |
Ire
05.05.10 | 3 way too high
4 the only pink floyd record I "just don't get"
5 should be at 1
6 too high
9 too low |
JesusV4
05.05.10 | You "get" Umagumma but not Piper? Paul McCartney called it the future of music! |
qwe3
05.05.10 | meddle is their best |