Nazzadan
01.31.18 | Some stuff on here I haven't checked, bookmark'd |
DungeonBoy
01.31.18 | I am a huge fan of this list. Nice to see 51 on there, I've always dug their melodic death metal with actual death metal growls. Never any love for Crowned in Terror or Deathrace King around here, but that's cool, good to see Eternal Death made it. Also have you ever jammed Thunderbeast by Night in Gales? It's their best IMO.
A couple recs to add to this list:
Destinity - Resolve In Crimson
Cipher System - Central Tunnel 8 |
Spacesh1p
01.31.18 | 9 is one of the best albums ever. Nice list. |
Nazzadan
01.31.18 | A severely underrated band that its pretty lowly rated here and RYM and I don't see why is Ablaze My Sorrow, especially their first 2 albums. |
bloc
01.31.18 | Amazing list man. Also:
Armageddon - Crossing the Rubicon
Woe of Tyrants - Kingdom of Might
Dark Lunacy - The Diarist
Divinity - Allegory
Kälter - Spiritual Angel
Words of Farewell - The Black Wild Yonder
Aeternam - Disciples of the Unseen |
pjquinones747
01.31.18 | Great fucking list. Got a ton of good material to check out. |
DungeonBoy
01.31.18 | yeah @bloc, Words of Farewell - The Black Wild Yonder is a killer record |
foxblood
01.31.18 | great list! agreed that 48 riffs hard. 37 looks really cool |
brainmelter
02.01.18 | some really great picks, especially 29!! |
RippingCorpse1986
02.01.18 | Couldn't agree more with the descriptions on 14 and 30
Been meaning to go on a melodeath binge and jam 32 and 37 |
RippingCorpse1986
02.01.18 | Also, and just nitpicking here; no love for Omnium Gatherum and Zonaria? |
Hawks
02.01.18 | Early COB should be on any "best of" melodeath list imo but still really sweet list. m/ |
CygnusX1
02.01.18 | So many tasty riffs in this list. 7, 8, 11, 12, 29, 33, and 38 are some of my favorite albums. I have some checking out to do here |
Nazzadan
02.01.18 | Ye Hawks Hatebreeder is essential |
pyroflare77
02.01.18 | @RippingCorpse
The one Omnium Gatherum album I heard while composing this list was alright, but not list worthy. Never heard of Zonaria.
@Hawks
Kalmah fills the early COB role. Though I probably should actually listen to them instead of sort of doing what I did for Arch Enemy but not entirely. |
Grimlin
02.01.18 | If I remember correctly, Torchbearer - Warnaments wasn't too bad. Can't remember at all what the other two sounded like though. |
Hawks
02.01.18 | "Kalmah fills the early COB role."
Kalmah slays but still not the same. Props for having 46 on here though, that one is so underappreciated. |
combustion07
02.01.18 | Damn good list. Quite a few here I need to check. |
Nazzadan
02.01.18 | "Props for having 46 on here though, that one is so underappreciated."
New Absence this year, too |
pyroflare77
02.01.18 | Yooooooo featured list. And yeah Hatebreeder's fine and dandy now that I've listened to it. |
DarkSideOfLucca
02.01.18 | List is fucking m/ |
hexfix93
02.01.18 | Sick list dude. |
SpiritCrusher2
02.01.18 | sick list indeed. where tf is edge of sanity tho? nice to see some love for real melodeath. sadly, sputnik is the only place where I can see that. |
pjquinones747
02.01.18 | I already knew 6, 8, 9, 11, 12, 14, 30, and 33 so i took those off of my list. I'll be chugging through the rest of the list periodically.
1 Not on spotify
2 Not on spotify
3 I didn't mind the clean vocals in their most recent LP from a few years back, but i can't enjoy them at all here
4 I wasn't prepared for tech death, so i'll have to revisit this while I'm on a tech death kick.
23 Absolutely fascinating. Riffs on riffs. You can feel the iron maiden coursing through their veins
24 Also incredible. more riffs. This makes me want to move to Scandinavia and grow my hair out.
I am lazy and unless I'm at home I won't listen to anything directly from YouTube so 1, 2, and any others not on Spotify will have to wait. |
Keyblade
02.01.18 | this is a sick list. can't think of anything that shouldn't be here. has all of the underrated gems u could think of |
foxblood
02.01.18 | nice feature |
rodrigo90
02.01.18 | CTRL+F children of bodom, no album by them fuck you |
BobaFettyWap
02.01.18 | Glad to see Burning Bridges on here. AE may be the most mainstream melodeath band out there, but that doesn't make their earlier albums any less essential. |
foxblood
02.01.18 | glad some people are diggin Vehemence God Was Created, i always had the impression that album wasn't that respected. |
DungeonBoy
02.01.18 | [2] I think it's just unknown man, there are a lot of gems around here that still need to be discovered by the masses IMO. A lot of them reside on this list. |
pjquinones747
02.01.18 | That Horrendous artwork is fucking incredible. That'll probably be my next kill after I wrap of Garden of Shadows after work. |
SpiritCrusher2
02.01.18 | ^ that Horrendous artwork was my av on multiple websites back when it was released, it's so cool |
SpiritCrusher2
02.01.18 | edit: lol nvm |
DungeonBoy
02.01.18 | "If you wanted to hear what Dismember or Entombed would sound like playing melodic death metal, this album answers that question."
If you want to hear what Dismember sounds like playing melodic death metal, check out the vastly underrated/questionably named Dismember - Death Metal. |
Keyblade
02.01.18 | "Glad to see Burning Bridges on here. AE may be the most mainstream melodeath band out there, but that doesn't make their earlier albums any less essential."
word |
SpiritCrusher2
02.01.18 | "If you want to hear what Dismember sounds like playing melodic death metal, check out the vastly underrated/questionably named Dismember - Death Metal."
Of Fire rules so hard, and yea it's 100% melodic death metal |
InFlamesWeThrash666
02.01.18 | List has many great albums but misses the best one,The Jester Race |
Keyblade
02.01.18 | "Lists has many great albums but misses the best one,The Jester Race"
wow i retract my first comment |
SpiritCrusher2
02.01.18 | Purgatory Afterglow too |
pyroflare77
02.01.18 | Sorry I don't like In Flames that much. And Swanö stuff feels more prog to me. |
ShadowRemains
02.01.18 | good list
deceased - as the weird travel on (death/thrash but very melodic)
unmoored - indefinite soul-extension
fertilizer - a painting of annoyance
moaning wind - visions in fire
oh and sarcasm put out a new record last year that was pretty great |
Keyblade
02.01.18 | "Sorry I don't like In Flames that much. And Swanö stuff feels more prog to me."
odd cuz there are a few jester race ripoffs on here. also purgatory afterglow is pure melodeath |
Nazzadan
02.01.18 | Subterranean > TJR if there had to be a single In Flames on the list |
Dmax28
02.01.18 | Nice!! I have a lot of stuff to check out now, but no Omnium Gatherum - New World Shadows??? |
frozencarl
02.01.18 | yup, needs in flames |
Doctuses
02.01.18 | COB hatebreeder, cmon boi |
DungeonBoy
02.01.18 | Really enjoying all of the where is TJR and COB comments, but you guys, the gold in this list is checking out the albums you haven't heard because there is some stuff in here and in the comments that rarely sees the light of day around here.. and we already know Swano is king. |
Nazzadan
02.01.18 | All this Hatebreeder love, Follow the Reaper blown the fuck out
Edit: @ Dboi all the love for those albums is because the name of this list is best of melodeath, not hidden gems of melodeath but yeah this list has some obscure gems. |
Donchivo
02.01.18 | I am not a great fan of melodeath, but thorough list with some interesting choices!
If you don't know them you might want to check out those underappreciated gems from the late 90s melo death heydays:
Mortum (SWE) - The Druid Ceremony
Taetre - The Art
Malevolence - Martyrialized
|
EvoHavok
02.01.18 | This is fantastic. I remember your previous versions. |
Thibs
02.01.18 | love that hypocrisy virus made it in here. a few to check for sure, well done. does need Edge of Sanity, one of my favs. and well.. jester race *ducks* |
Keyblade
02.01.18 | "This is fantastic. I remember your previous versions."
shit, thought i was hallucinating. i knew i've seen this list a couple of times before lol
also hatebreeder > ftr for sure |
teamster
02.01.18 | Fractal Gates is currently my favorite mdm. They are so good. You guys should check them out. |
Keyblade
02.01.18 | mannnn u just reminded me of them. been on a kick of what I used to listen to when I first got into metal...thanks a lot man, gonna add them to my playlist
I somehow stumbled upon fractal gates debut when it came out...used to find a lot of obscure bands for someone so new to metal now that I think of it lol. first couple of songs were killer but the album as a whole was just ok. same goes for the follow up that came out a few years later that I was really excited about. unless they got some new shit I haven't heard, I wouldn't put them on par with even most of this list tbh |
Keyblade
02.01.18 | Dark Lunacy was another band I found in a similar way that I loved. metal archives served me well back in the day |
pyroflare77
02.02.18 | Yeah Subterranean is best In Flames |
zaruyache
02.02.18 | Apparently I need to hear a lot of these. |
Nazzadan
02.02.18 | Ye this list and the albums in the comments are all bangers from what I've heard |
dathvada321
02.03.18 | In Flames? Excellent list otherwise though. Edit: I would also recommend Edge of Sanity if you haven't heard them already. |
Royl123
02.03.18 | Old In flames? |
Donchivo
02.03.18 | Everybody who likes their melo death with a BM edge please check out 'The druid ceremony' by the virtually unknown swedes of Mortum. It has energy, grooves, Melody and very strong cohesive songwriting. Some people could be put off by a very clean feeling, and the very clear female voice in some songs, but if that doesn't bother you guys, give em a jam!
|
Willie
02.03.18 | Great list. I'm going to have to make an Apple Music playlist of all of these. Night In Gales is back together and releasing a new album very soon. Easily their best album. |
Keyblade
02.03.18 | i would also add Dimension Zero's debut ep to this. short and sweet gothenburg record featuring Fredrik Johansson aka the December Flower solo guy on guitars |
DungeonBoy
02.03.18 | [2] Silent Night Fever is also a ripper, but everything after that was not as great.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2A0OTso_np0
Kinda surprised Mors Principium Est - The Unborn didn't make the cut.
https://listenable-records.bandcamp.com/album/the-unborn
@Willie Didn't know there's a new Night in Gales coming out! thanks for the heads up on that. I really enjoyed their reunion album Five Scars. It had some questionable tunes but overall a pretty great record.
|
Keyblade
02.03.18 | i used to love The Unborn but the production gives it zero longevity. it's so thin and weak
thanks for reminding me tho, there's a couple of songs on there i should add to my playlist |
HarryBoBerry
02.03.18 | This list is great, I've been meaning to check out some lesser known MDM bands |
Kusangii
02.03.18 | Really good list man, nice to see bands such as The Crown and Inferi here |
ffs
02.04.18 | big trems on this list |
Raust
02.07.18 | Wow an actual decent list. None of the top 50-100 lamest album of the year lists. Some stuff I'll definitely have to check out. |
Metz
06.29.18 | Excellent list with many hidden gems I never knew existed. Also:
Withering Surface - Scarlet Silhouettes
Ouroboros - Yatrogeny |
lalchimiste
01.15.19 | Oh man what a nice list, some really overlooked stuff on there and glad some Québécois made the cut. Props for Sarcasm, I jammed Within the Sphere of Ethereal Minds so much but never checked out their back catalogue. |
hexfix93
01.15.19 | A Touch of the Burning Red Sunset is amazing. Or get their Burial Dimensions comp. I've yet to jam Within the Sphere..., but I think I should get on that. |
Casavir
01.15.19 | "the more famous but far worse Slaughter of the Soul"
This guy knows. |
Metz
11.23.19 | God-tier list, so much stuff that's as overlooked as it is brilliant |
teamster
11.24.19 | Whew a lot to digest. |
pyroflare77
11.28.19 | Should probably make a part 2 of this list at some point with some of the recs here, along with including some 3.5 albums to avoid the "where's Bodom" comments and such.
Or maybe actually get on redoing the melodic black list that's been in the pipelines for years. |
NoHellsNoHeavens
04.08.20 | This is a crazy ass list. |
JWT155
04.08.20 | Modern In Flames blows, but their older material is desperately lacking on this list. |
pyroflare77
11.18.20 | Things have been put into motion now for a part 2 of this list. It's going to take a while since I have about as many albums as this list itself to sift through. I'll honor the wording of the title and put Bodom and In Flames in (and Heartwork), but hopefully I mine up plenty more hidden gems in this forthcoming journey. |
combustion07
11.18.20 | Lots of awesome albums here. 23 and 31 are pretty overlooked. 23 is probably my favorite in the genre. Love that Vehemence album too |
zaruyache
11.18.20 | nice list 123 |
Nazzadan
11.18.20 | nice list 123 [2]
Looking forward to part 2 |
Keyblade
01.07.21 | [3] |
Keyblade
01.07.21 | 37 is sick |
BallsToTheWall
01.07.21 | Why the fuck Intestine Baalism
So low? |
Keyblade
01.07.21 | i dont think it's ranked |
DungeonBoy
01.07.21 | there's a clear pattern to the order my dudes |
Kusangii
01.07.21 | Pyroflare, you are one of the coolest dudes with some of the best tastes out there. Just so you know |
pyroflare77
01.14.21 | Thanks bro. And if this was ranked, without even considering it heavily, Intenstine Baalism would at least be in the 20s, and that's just because there's fierce competition and I'm probably overestimating how much there is. |
combustion07
09.01.22 | Rediscovering this list has me going down a melodic death metal wormhole so cheers for that! The bass on that Pandemonium album is fucking ace. I'm checking Rellik right now and it's pretty solid also |
pyroflare77
09.02.22 | Cheers mate. I'll make that second list some day~ |
evilford
09.02.22 | Not a huge melodeath fan but this list deserves hella respect |
evilford
09.02.22 | Garden of shadows and intestine baalism slay tho |
Hyperion1001
09.02.22 | Yeah there’s good stuff here |
combustion07
09.02.22 | Also not a big melodeath guy but this list is a great little roundup of some highlights for sure. Agreed on Garden of Shadows and Intestine Baalism too! For me them, Arghoslent and Red in the Sky era At the Gates are the peak examples of the genre. That Cenotaph album after the debut deserves a mention also.
On another note it makes me very happy to see that Desultory album here. That one is real slept on and it's a shame.
Excited to see part 2 whenever you get around to it |
ShadowRemains
10.01.22 | bumping this because that grenadier album from this year is amazing, simply the best arghoslenting i've heard outside arghoslent themselves |
combustion07
10.01.22 | What album you talking about man? I'm always prepared for some arghoslenting |
ShadowRemains
10.01.22 | grenadier - trumpets blaring in blazing glory (it's basically arghoslent but war themed)
they have the more complex melodic riffing/epic sound that bands like house of atreus can't quite match |
Emim
10.01.22 | Schaliach |
ShadowRemains
10.02.22 | should also mention the lyrics are just about as creative and historically inclined as arghoslent, without the... turn-offs if you will
title track is one of the best melodeath songs i've ever heard |
combustion07
10.02.22 | Damn even the cover reminds me a lot of Arghoslent. You're right those this shit is killer! Great stuff to hold me over until they drop their next one |
Piglet
10.02.22 | gonna finally get around to hearing arghoslent, hypocrisy, arsis and garden of shadows becuz of dis list m/ m/ |
DungeonBoy
10.02.22 | Arghoslent is racist garbage |
Dedes
10.02.22 | The people are racist but the riffs are innocent
|
ToSmokMuzyki
10.02.22 | lol as if mdm has any best |
Emim
10.02.22 | Incorrrect |
ShadowRemains
10.02.22 | "Arghoslent is racist garbage"
well listen to grenadier then because they are arghoslent without the racism |
ToSmokMuzyki
10.03.22 | all mdm is racist garbage founded in white supremacy |
combustion07
10.03.22 | I heard the vocalist for Dark Tranquility is Hitler's long lost son |
ToSmokMuzyki
10.03.22 | its trv |
BookoftheFallen
10.04.22 | Wheres Ceremonial Oath?? |
pyroflare77
10.13.22 | Oh yeah Grenadier will definitely go in the next list. I'm the one that added them to the site's database (or at least first rating, I don't remember), so I'm familiar-- unlike with Ceremonial Oath (but, checking they are on the to listen list). |
ShadowRemains
04.10.24 | not sure if you're ever gonna make another one of these but bereaved (japanese band) is an excellent example of melodic death metal keeping the edge |
pyroflare77
04.13.24 | I've been slacking pretty hard but it's added to the list of stuff to check. |
StormChaser
04.13.24 | bookmarked, will czech |