lucazade22
02.07.12 | in no particular order! |
Trebor.
02.07.12 | 1 very true |
Beachcoma
02.07.12 | I agree with 1,4, and 6, but not the rest really. |
Yotimi
02.07.12 | 3 is awesome and 2,4,10 are good |
twlight
02.07.12 | 1 and 9, yeah
all the weeknd releases were wayyyy overrated on this site |
Ire
02.07.12 | how
the
fuck
is
pj
over
rated
? |
wabbit
02.07.12 | how is pj harvey or nicolas jaar overrated at all when neither made any list.
^seriously how did the staff fuck that up? |
DinoX
02.07.12 | list is poop |
AGuyIsWatchingYou
02.07.12 | Define overrated and give me the criteria for an album to be overrated. |
lucasjcockcroft
02.07.12 | 8 and 4 rule.... hard |
lucazade22
02.07.12 | the pj harvey record is ranked #1 on RYM for 2011. I don't think it's THAT good, that's all...! |
immortalizepain
02.07.12 | I expected 1. But I still like it. Why 5? |
lucazade22
02.07.12 | It's a good record, but their self-titled is much better in my opinion. I just don't get why people are calling 'Helplessness Blues' their defining album. |
DeafMetal
02.07.12 | fleet foxes all night |
Eclecticist
02.07.12 | 2 and 8 rule, the rest were very over-hyped |
EyeForAnEye
02.07.12 | As much as I love it, Defeater's EDSN should be here too. |
Eko
02.07.12 | 1, 2, 5 agreed |
Scoot
02.07.12 | "As much as I love it, Defeater's EDSN should be here too."
when it came out sure, not anymore though |
IAmHollywood
02.07.12 | 4 8 and 10 are the only ones I disagree with |
MasBarHigeuoris21
02.07.12 | I understand why Mastodon and TV on the Radio are on this list but could you not list Cynic? |
DinoX
02.07.12 | operataionalizing is needed here. |
Deviant.
02.07.12 | Awww, did someone spend a year disagreeing with everyone else? |
MasBarHigeuoris21
02.07.12 | I think so |
julien
02.07.12 | I'm going to go out on a limb and say that number 1 shouldn't be on this list.
The rest of it, I'd agree with. |
MasBarHigeuoris21
02.07.12 | I agree with some of this list but it just seems like so much more should be on here |
iambandersnatch
02.07.12 | I don't think 6 is overrated, and I'm not even a big Mastodon person. That album is a genuinely fun listen. Agree w/ 1 though. |
qwe3
02.07.12 | forgot cunninlynguists, protest the hero, foo fighters |
devious
02.07.12 | you're a faggot for having 1, 4, 5, and 8 on here. |
XingKing
02.07.12 | I'm honestly shocked that Wildlife is still making appearances on the popular albums list. It was just on there earlier today. Agreeing about Defeater's new album belonging on this list. Overrated as fuck. It was merely... average. |
modernman2
02.07.12 | 4, 6, 8 , and 10 for sure |
anarchistfish
02.07.12 | 4 and 6 were what I had in mind when I clicked this |
Deviant.
02.07.12 | You don't have to keep reminding us that you have terrible taste in music, we know |
TechieCore
02.08.12 | Sorry but Echoes of Silence was baws. And I don't even like hardly any rap and r & b. |
Douglas
02.08.12 | clicked expecting The Weeknd, saw Weeknd. |
luschlotz
02.08.12 | agreed on 2,,6,7 and 9. I Hate you for 10 |
PGST3
02.08.12 | I like some of these ablums... |
EasyModeDX
02.09.12 | 1 is soo overrated, but I don't think mastodon's release is overrated, I've been digging it for some time |
PHATJ
02.13.12 | Noel Gallagher's High Flying Birds is in no way over rated. |
Hawks
02.13.12 | I can agree with 4, but not 1, 5, 6, or 8. |
FrankRedHot
02.13.12 | The Weeknd is hardly overrated. |
Dolving999
05.20.12 | Hell no, 1 is not overrated, not at all! |