|
User
Reviews 1
Approval 100%
Album Ratings 178
Objectivity 67%
Last Active 05-06-08 5:05 pm
Joined 09-28-07
Review Comments 803
| Tmfbdm?
i'm trying to figure out which black dahlia murder album that most people like overall. which is your favorite? | | 1 |  | The Black Dahlia Murder
Unhallowed
I gave this a 4. I've heard a lot of people say this is their best album, but it's boring for me at times. And a few of the riffs sound like something As I Lay Dying would write. | | 2 |  | The Black Dahlia Murder
Miasma
I gave this a 4.5. This was the first album I bought by them, and it's easily my favorite. Most people only talk about Unhallowed and Nocturnal being good, and I think this is better than both of them. There is a lot of memorable stuff on here. It may eventually become a 5 for me. | | 3 |  | The Black Dahlia Murder
Nocturnal
I also gave this a 4.5. I've only listened to it all the way through twice, but I like it a lot. The vocals are better on this one than the last two, in my opinion, but it just didn't have the awesome riffs Miasma had. This is my second favorite of theirs. | |
Slaytan
04.18.08 | Nocturnal | jrowa001
04.18.08 | even though i dont like them, 3 probably held my attention the most | Crimson
04.18.08 | This band is pretty average. | HighandDriving
04.18.08 | Nocturnal | botb
04.18.08 | 2 or 3. they are both good. i'd probably say 3 though. | Altmer
04.18.08 | why don't you do yourself a favor and skip this band | willfellmarsy
04.18.08 | Nocturnal and shush nay-sayers this is a solid band | combustion07
04.18.08 | Nocturnal. | spoon_of_grimbo
04.18.08 | miasma is my favourite, it's got the least metalcore influence (although there isn't a huge amount of that in the other two, but less in miasma), and the artwork and lyrics have less of the metal cliches than the other two.
and also "statutory ape" will tear you several new ones. | rasputin
04.19.08 | Unhallowed is the one I enjoyed the most, but generally the band isn't that good |
|
