SCREAM!
07.13.16 | I'm no expert in the genre but something seems "off" here |
iloveyouall
07.13.16 | bring back "other" |
iloveyouall
07.13.16 | 21 is kinda okay for half a disc, but yeah, the rest of this is fucked. |
Keyblade
07.13.16 | lol
bring back "other" [2] |
SCREAM!
07.13.16 | Two genre system: Rock and other
It is clear to me now that we cannot handle any more responsibility than that |
Relinquished
07.13.16 | for a few of these groups it works if only categorized from their artist pages |
Sowing
07.13.16 | somewhere Deviant just felt a horrible disturbance in the force |
Ocean of Noise
07.13.16 | This is what it's been for ages. It needs to change. |
SCREAM!
07.13.16 | "for a few of these groups it works if only categorized from their artist pages"
I'm aware but this sort of shows quite just how flawed that system is. Also, should our charts be looking at second and third genres for a band? (so a rock album with some electronic elements somehow ends up being the top electronic album on the site) |
SCREAM!
07.13.16 | This did get me to put on the donkey kong country soundtrack so at least some good came out of this |
Ocean of Noise
07.13.16 | The problem is that the genre labels should be for individual albums rather than for artists. Ulver's first 3 albums aren't even remotely electronic, but they still end up on the list because Ulver is now labelled an electronic artist. |
Ocean of Noise
07.13.16 | I made a post about this specifically in the help/bugs/suggestions forum, and it was ignored. |
BallsDeep
07.13.16 | 24 is the pinnacle of electronic music |
Relinquished
07.13.16 | this place has been flawed forever and the guy who can fix it only comes to fix the copyright |
Relinquished
07.13.16 | damn right it should be ignored cuz no one moderating can do shit |
Relinquished
07.13.16 | jom's like I got the phone here next to me just in case mx calls back from thailand |
SCREAM!
07.13.16 | almost defeats the point of having genre charts when this is what they end up looking like yknow. But hey, who cares right ¯_(ツ)_/¯ |
p4p
07.13.16 | i told someone to browse the electronic charts yesterday and didn't know it was this bad lol |
Flashmobba
07.13.16 | No. 2 is the best trip hop album ever, quite possibly my favorite of all time. |
BallsDeep
07.13.16 | Hey its all great stuff atleast |
blacklightjer
07.13.16 | lol donkey kong 2.
|
SCREAM!
07.13.16 | "i told someone to browse the electronic charts yesterday and didn't know it was this bad lol"
Was looking for some inspiration as to what to listen to and well, I'm listening to the Donkey Kong OST haha
"lol donkey kong 2."
Best thing on the list m/ |
iloveyouall
07.13.16 | "Two genre system: Rock and other"
I'd lean more towards: guitar music and non-guitar music/other |
Relinquished
07.13.16 | that's great sach that's really great |
SCREAM!
07.13.16 | "I'd lean more towards: guitar music and non-guitar music/other"
Would bands that use guitars and electronics be classified as guitar music by default though? Important distinctions to be made here |
iloveyouall
07.13.16 | yes. |
AlexKzillion
07.13.16 | Thats why you got to use the rym charts. |
osmark86
07.13.16 | Bring back other [3]. Why complicate? |
Flugmorph
07.13.16 | Amazing list idea. |
osmark86
07.13.16 | Agreed though, this chart system is flawed at best. |
Chortles
07.13.16 | this is y rym exists |
Conmaniac
07.13.16 | haha yes I was told to browse through the electronic charts in my electronic recs list. its very silly |
SCREAM!
07.13.16 | I hope you at least checked that DK album ;) |
Conmaniac
07.13.16 | nah but that Heroin Party album is legit |
Conmaniac
07.13.16 | oh shit p4p commented on this, the guy who told me to do this. at least you admit it man lmao |
Keyblade
07.13.16 | dude scream when's the next round of the tourney |
SCREAM!
07.13.16 | Tourney went the way of Chuck man RIP |
LotusFlower
07.13.16 | burzum is my favorite dubstep producer |
TVC15
07.13.16 | We should do this like RYM and vote genres per album rather than band tbh |
BallsDeep
07.13.16 | Without Burzum Skrillex wouldn't exist |
BallsDeep
07.13.16 | Rate your music is just a more accurate sauce in general truth be told and album ratings there are rarely as inflated or unnecessarily panned as they are here i.e there don't seem to be as many lemmings (im definately guilty of this too) |
LotusFlower
07.13.16 | "or unnecessarily panned as they are here"
80% of pop and electronic albums disagree with you |
BallsDeep
07.13.16 | I meant there's less variance in ratings throughout bands discogs on rym as there is here and sometimes that can give the impression that an album is relatively worse than it actually is if that makes sense |
Typhoon24
07.13.16 | air - moon safari
so nice |
HarrySmalldini97
07.15.16 | This site definitely jacks off too violently over prog metal |
Rik VII
07.15.16 | nah |
DoofusWainwright
07.15.16 | one prevailing genre tag applied to individual albums is the way to go |
p4p
07.15.16 | i'm callin ethnic cleansing to get rid of the metalcore/alt-rock guys |
Mystletainn
07.15.16 | how embarrassing |
SCREAM!
07.15.16 | Alt rock has it's own main genre tag along with Metal, Rock, Electronic, Pop, etc
So good luck on your cleansing, you've got your work cut out for you |
Ryus
07.15.16 | who tagged godspeed as electronic tell me
|
SCREAM!
07.15.16 | they're tagged as ambient and drone |
DoofusWainwright
07.15.16 | Sigur Ros too...? |
Keyblade
07.15.16 | "80% of pop and electronic albums disagree with you"
or any music after 1995 |
Boyproblems
07.15.16 | Donkey Kong is higher than burial wtf |
Tunaboy45
07.15.16 | emooooooooootional landscapes |
SCREAM!
07.15.16 | "Donkey Kong is higher than burial wtf "
Deservedly so tbh |
Tunaboy45
07.15.16 | what a soundtrack |
Keyblade
07.15.16 | dkc1 has aquatic ambiance which is like the greatest ambient song ever |
SCREAM!
07.15.16 | oh damn someone removed the electronic tag from the David Wise artist page rendering this list (slightly) inaccurate! |
Boyproblems
07.15.16 | the shock horror |