|UserReviews 3Approval 92%Soundoffs 52Album Ratings 1922Objectivity 93%Last Active 12-19-19 2:55 pmJoined 09-24-05Forum Posts 22Review Comments 3,098
|07.07.20 ||Top 25 of 2020: So Far! (Aug.)||06.11.20 ||Favorite Metal of 2020 (So Far)|
|05.27.20 ||FILM: tectac's Hayao Miyazaki, Ranked ♦||05.12.20 ||MUSIC: tectac's Swans, Ranked ♦|
|03.15.20 ||FILM: tectac's Tsai Ming-liang, Ranked||02.25.20 ||FILM: tectac's Robert Bresson, Ranked|
|01.21.20 ||MUSIC: tec's Top 50 of 2019 ♦||12.18.19 ||FILM: tec's Noah Baumbach, Ranked|
|12.09.19 ||MUSIC: tec's Top 100 Songs of 2019 ♦||11.25.19 ||FILM: tectac's Sergio Leone, Ranked|
|10.30.19 ||FILM: tectac's Darren Aronofsky, Ranked||10.24.19 ||FILM: tectac's Top 10(0) Films of the D|
|10.17.19 ||MUSIC: tectac's Top 20 Metal Albums of ||10.15.19 ||FILM: tectac's Gus Van Sant, Ranked|
|10.09.19 ||FILM: tectac's David Fincher, Ranked||09.27.19 ||14 Years on Sput/mx: Top Albums of the |
|09.09.19 ||FILM: tectac's Christopher Nolan, Ranke||08.28.19 ||FILM: tectac's Coen Brothers, Ranked|
|MUSIC: tectac's Swans, Ranked|
Have been a favorite of mine for a while now, and while I'd normally be prepping to see them live in a month - but won't, thanks to Coronavirus - I figured I'd just listen to their discography front to back and rank it. (I'd heard everything prior to this, but have never taken the plunge to go chronologically through them all, back to back to back ad infinitum.) Honestly enjoy everything on this list, even the ones at the very bottom. No live albums included.
While this is arguably just an annex of 'Cop', which ranks quite a bit higher on this list, I somehow never completely jelled with the four songs offered up here. Doesn't help that I prefer the first two over the last two, meaning that I rarely make it through this four-track EP in its entirety. Overbearing and grim, but Swans have done those two things to significantly more devastating effect imo.
BEST TRACKS: I Crawled; Raping a Slave
WORST TRACKS: Young God; This Is Mine
The Burning World
The ubiquitous black sheep of the Swans discography, and why not? Sounds like some hybrid of gothic folk and alt-country, darker and more brooding than Angels of Light but not nearly as energetic or demanding as typical Swans stuff. Not sure what the purpose of this was, as it feels more like a dry run for something that never came to fruition, but alas: There are a handful of worthy tracks as well as a handful of forgettable ones. Nothing superlative, nothing offensive.
BEST TRACKS: See No More; God Damn the Sun
WORST TRACKS: Saved; I Remember Who You Are
A surprisingly "soft" release compared to its relentlessly bleak predecessor, plus we have the additional of Jarboe which is sometimes charming and sometimes frightening. This is, to my mind, a warm up for 'Holy Money', where they'd whittle down a lot of what they were going for here, even if it's not a sound that generally gets me excited.
BEST TRACKS: Fool; Stupid Child
WORST TRACKS: Anything For You; Heaven
I actually think this is half-great and half-okay, resulting in an overall experience that's slightly underwhelming, but still plenty favorable. In fact, if you combined the best tracks from this with the best tracks from 'Greed', you'd have a composite that might rival 'Filth' for the top "early Swans" release. The industrial overtones are bit more polished and appropriately distributed here, making it my preferred of the two by a little bit.
BEST TRACKS: A Hanging; Another You
WORST TRACKS: You Need Me; Money Is Flesh (#2)
Love of Life
Feels exactly like what it probably was: Collective overflow from the creation of 'White Light'. But there's nothing wrong with that, because Swans b-sides are better than a lot of bands' top-tier efforts. This is like the awkward teenage years of their discography, but looking back, there's something strangely endearing about that.
BEST TRACKS: Amnesia; Love of Life
WORST TRACKS: Identity; God Loves America (not including the useless interludes)
Not what most people excepted, but then again, given how many different sounds Swans have embodied over their multi-decade romp through various lineups, what the hell was anyone expecting? It's like Swans with the distortion turned off and the mood lighting turned way down. And part of me kinda likes that, even if I was hoping for something just a bit more...aggressive? But I can't complain - all the Swans albums are my children.
BEST TRACKS: The Hanging Man; My Phantom Limb
WORST TRACKS: Hums; Some New Things
My Father Will Guide Me Up a Rope to the Sky
A strange "comeback", if you will, but one I've grown to appreciate more and more with time. Used to think it was Gira trying too hard to pull his Angels of Light tendencies into the spotlight, but every time I revisit this, it sounds increasingly like a Swans record and not a strange Gira side project. Still, hard to believe 'The Seer' was released merely two years later.
BEST TRACKS: No Words / No Thoughts; Eden Prison
WORST TRACKS: Reeling the Liars In; Little Mouth
Absolutely brutal. And honestly, if you're looking for an album to kick your teeth in, bludgeon your head to death, bury you underground, and shit on the cold earth where your lifeless body lay, this is *perfect* for that. It just so happens that I'm not (always) a psychopath, and rarely find myself in the correct state of mind to endure this grueling beast. But - BUT! When I *am* in that particularly gloomy mood, there's nothing like this.
BEST TRACKS: Half Life; Your Property
WORST TRACKS: Job; Thug
White Light From the Mouth of Infinity
Clearly the better counterpart of the 'White Light'/'Love of Life' diptych - don't trust anyone who believes otherwise. You can listen to this and hear a lot of Angels of Light (and that general direction in which Gira was headed) - it's lovely and beautiful at times, and depressing and melancholic at others. Not an album I listen to often, but one I'm always happy to revisit.
BEST TRACKS: Power and Sacrifice; Song for the Sun
WORST TRACKS: Song for Dead Time; When She Breathes
The Great Annihilator
You could trim some of the fat on this bad boy and turn it into a phenomenal 11 or 12 track album. As it stands, it's a great album with a bit of filler. There was a day when I preferred this to 'Soundtracks for the Blind', but that day is clearly no longer. Unmissible for Swans fans, though.
BEST TRACKS: Mother / Father; She Lives!
WORST TRACKS: In; Out; Blood Promise; Alcohol the Seed
The Glowing Man
Not as unique or unprecedented or interesting or gripping as the previous two records from the "post-rock-drone" Swans trilogy, but still excellent, and still plenty to love for those of us who enjoyed this iteration of Swans. Perhaps too cyclic and calm by comparison, but if *this* had come out before 'The Seer', I wonder if its appraisal would be different?
BEST TRACKS: The Glowing Man; Cloud of Unknowing
WORST TRACKS: People Like Us; When Will I Return?
Children of God
Took me a while to see what everyone else saw in this, but once I finally saw it, it cannot be unseen. Achieves a catheral-like atmosphere built of both beauty and doom, and acts as a fine bridge between early-Swans and mid-to-late-Swans. Or....well, depends on how many eras you want to define, I guess.
BEST TRACKS: New Mind; Like a Drug (Sha La La La)
WORST TRACKS: Sex, God, Sex; Real Love
This is super fucking underrated and no one ever talks about it when they talk about Swans. WHY?! The closest approximation they have to the true essence of New York's no wave scene, but with their own gritty spin on it. Might only be four tracks long but goddamn it's great.
BEST TRACKS: I mean there's only four songs. They're all fantastic. 'Laugh' is probably my favorite and 'Take Advantage' my least favorite, though.
Soundtracks for the Blind
When people say this is one of those albums that you need to "be in the mood for" and "submit yourself to" and "listen to in a dark room with headphones" and all that other pretentious rhetoric...well... they're actually absolutely correct. Though I'll admit I've listened to this album white mowing the lawn and driving across the state on several occasions. It fucks either way, but devoting proper headspace to it really does heighten the experience.
BEST TRACKS: Helpless Child; The Sound; Hypogirl
WORST TRACKS: Yum-Yab Killers; Mellothumb; Yrp 2
I remember when this came out and I looked up the track list and saw that the title track was over thirty minutes long and laughed it off as some mega try-hard wankery. Then I listened to it and was pretty much in tears by the end, so there you have it. After having been somewhat weirded out by the Swans revival album ("My Father"), I was mostly blown away by this.
BEST TRACKS: Mother of the World; The Apostate
WORST TRACKS: The Wolf; The Daughter Brings the Water
Perhaps no Swans album has grown on me quite as much as Filth, but I'll be damned if this thing isn't very nearly perfect. Contains much of the grit spackled into the three releases that would follow while maintaining a sense of...not "catchiness", but...something. There's *something* here that makes me want to, I dunno, groove? Dance? Occasionally smash my face into a wall? Sounds about right.
BEST TRACKS: Stay Here; Power for Power
WORST TRACKS: Freak; Gang
To Be Kind
The first time I heard this, not long after its release in 2014, was at the gym. It was back day and I hurt something in my lower back doing really heavy deadlifts that day. I remember wanting to die while the climax of 'A Little God in My Hands' was going on. Pretty fitting. Album rules, I'm sorry to neo-Swans haters. Probably one of my favorites of the last decade, too.
BEST TRACKS: Bring The Sun / Toussaint L'Ouverture; She Loves Us
WORST TRACKS: Some Things We Do; Kirsten Supine
|Turns out the only thing you guys like talking about less than Tsai Ming-liang is Swans.|
|I'm here, I'm here.|
I've never heard 5 actually, will check it.
Filth is always #1 though.
|swans more like|
|bump for exposure|
|'Filth is always #1 though.'|
Filth and TBK are such different beasts with such drastically opposed goals that I'd be totally fine awarding them each a "Co-#1" space that share an equal amount of respect and admiration in my head. And, to be completely honest, I'm 99% certain I've listened to Filth way more (if for no other reason than its far more accessible length).
But if forced - gun to my head - to keep only one Swans record and forfeit the rest forever, TBK would be the one I'd hold onto (I think), if only because it's the one that I find myself still discovering new things in each time I listen.
Filth is amazing
TBK amazes me.
Does that make sense?
|And also Sandwich, please do check their debut EP. It's really quite lovely.|
|It's kind of cool that you put the s/t ep so high. |
|"Does that make sense?"|
I get you.
I think my Co-#1's would be Filth and Soundtracks.
|I can't pick between Cop and Filth. I always like to say Cop because it's the underdog.|
|IN A SWANS-ASS RESTAURANT / HURRY UP WITH MY DAMN TOUSSAINT|
also we have the same favourite, niiiiiice
|At this point I feel like TBK is a kind of unexciting, expected first choice, but I'll be damned if I'm not the lame-ass honky who goes nuts for that kind of monolithic self-importance ;o)|
Picking 'Cop' as #1 is the manliest thing ever. Honestly I wish I could say 'Cop' was my favorite, that's an atypical-but-not-unfathomable pick for first. Something kind of mysterious and alluring about having that at the top. And there are some times when I listen to 'Cop' and am bowled over by how awesome and crushing it truly is. But goddamn you've gotta be in the right mood for that shit.
you've gotta be in the right mood for this shit!
|Big ol' undertaking, props. No clue how I'd rank them, post rock Swans gets the most traffic, but sometimes Great Annihilator and White Light sneak in their and really hit the damn spot|
|Nice writeups. I'd place their nineties stuff above the newer albums though|
|It'd be difficult for me to choose between neo-Swans and early-Swans, again because they're such starkly different styles of music. I think it's safe to say that 90s-Swans is my "least favorite" of their incarnations, but only comparatively so. Obviously SOUNDTRACKS and THE GREAT ANNIHILATOR (and even WHITE LIGHT / LOL, to a lesser extent) are awesome. |
|9 being behind all that new stuff is literallyyyy disgusting|
|my ex-gfs cat seemed to like Filth, he'd always come and snuggle when i put it on |
|SWANS: Music to snuggle to.|
|Public spooning is a good idea :) :) :)|
|Public Displays of Aggression (?)|
|Oh, featured. Yay - muchas gracias to whichever admin bestowed this lovely privilege upon thee :o)|
|some good swancore|
|This is one of the bands I owe a discog run. Great list tec.|
|I'd probably swap TBK and Soundtracks, but... man, this is a great list. I like the write ups, too. Nice work!|
|Top 4 is top 4|
|@aydross: Smart man. (Or...woman?)|
Thanks Deadwing and Dewi. I'm shocked the 'The Seer' is the only Swans album you have rated, Dewi. If you ever decide to take the plunge, you're in for a treat.