Colliiiin
11.26.22 | Switch 2 and 5 and we good aha. I actually think 5 is tied for their best album with FP. |
Scornfyre
11.26.22 | For me, 5 has a few songs that I am just sorta neutral on. Whereas all of 2s actual songs hit hard. 2s only flaw is having way too many segues. (And that it was taken off of streaming...) Neither is on the level of FP tho. Granted that's relative since FP is my top album of all time. |
Masochist
11.27.22 | I fully agree with this list, honestly. I really loved 'The Heart Is A Monster' way more than I thought I would myself. "A.M. Amnesia" might actually be my favorite Failure song. |
Snake.
11.27.22 | 4 is 1 |
MoM
11.27.22 | [2]
🐸 |
Scornfyre
11.27.22 | Masochist agreed. The Heart is a Monster is far better than anyone gives it credit for being. My favorite Failure song switches a lot, but a solid 45% of the time it is off of THIAM. If FP didn't exist as a point of comparison, THIAM would probably get a 5 from me lol. |
Scornfyre
11.27.22 | Snake I have Magnified rated numerically higher than you do, so it being fourth best on my list is still better than being first best on your list lmao. |
SmashIsTheWay94
11.27.22 | Consistently solid band so my ranking isn't set in stone at all
1>5>3>4>2>7
Their last two albums both grew on me, and honestly In the Future...is about even with Fantastic Planet these days |
SomeCallMeTim
11.27.22 | 4 is 1 [2]
/thread |
JDubb
11.27.22 | Where would Replicants fit in here? |
Scornfyre
11.27.22 | Probably at the bottom. I don't even remember what they sound like, which is not a good sign. |
JDubb
11.28.22 | What!!! and Failure/FP is ur fav album of all time? go pick up the Replicants (1995) album. It is Ken Andrews and Greg Edwards with Paul D’amour. 1 is 1, but Replicants is 2. |
Scornfyre
11.28.22 | Nvm I've never heard this before. I guess I was thinking of something else. I'll give it a listen |
Scornfyre
11.28.22 | Finished it. I'd put it at 6. I guess I just prefer Failure original material over Failure-sounding covers of other songs |
