Morningrise767
04.11.19 | Great list bro I would add Blackest Eyes, Trains, Open Car, Deadwing, Fear of a Blank Planet, .3
Also for #9 did you mean Prodigal or Wedding Nails haha? |
gardenbus
04.11.19 | oops, I meant wedding nails lmao. |
BlazinBlitzer
04.11.19 | Ahh, a satisfying amount of In Absentia! Looking back through the discography again, these are probably mine:
1. The Sky Moves Sideways (Both Phases)
2. Arriving Somewhere But Not Here
3. Buying New Soul
4. Anesthetize
5. Gravity Eyelids
6. Russia on Ice
7. Dark Matter
8. Radioactive Toy
9. Trains
10. Heartattack in a Layby |
zruF
04.11.19 | Decent list but some songs like Waiting, Drown with me or Time Flies are missing :P
I also think that Sentimental and Lazarus are getting boring the more you listen to it.
#7 would be my #1 |
Zig
04.11.19 | Arriving Somewhere, Anesthetize, and Glass Arm Shattering are my favs. |
JohnnyoftheWell
04.11.19 | A PT list with no Dark Matter is no list at all :O |
CugnoBrasso
04.11.19 | Somebody mentioned "Buying New Soul". I'm satisfied. |
Faraudo
04.11.19 | Ok, I'm in.
1: Arriving Somewhere Not Here.
2: The Sky Moves Sideways.
3: Drown With Me.
4: Cheating the Polygraph.
5: Time Flies.
6: Dark Matter.
7: Anesthetize.
8: The Creator Has a Mastertape.
9: Lightbulb Sun.
10:Trains/Bonnie The Cat/Strip The Soul |
ChoccyPhilly
04.11.19 | 4 is criminally underrated but is it top 10 material? Hmm, not so sure about that tbh |
JohnnyoftheWell
04.11.19 | The fact that this has nothing pre-In Absentia disturbs me a little in general but these are okay picks from that period. Mellotron Scratch is the only song conspicuously missing |
Alucard125
04.11.19 | That's because Mellotron Scratch is the worst song on Deadwing. |
Faraudo
04.11.19 | My list should be the correct list if I'm perfectly honest with y'all. |
JohnnyoftheWell
04.11.19 | Worst song on Deadwing is a tough call but I guess it goes to Open Car for shit lyrics or Lazarus for super corniness. Album is best at its most haunting and Mellotron brings that the hardest
And Faraudo, your list is most of the way there tbh |
Faraudo
04.11.19 | Glad you liked it, Johnny. What would you add/take from it? I'd like to add Russia On Ice but I don't know which one to remove. |
JohnnyoftheWell
04.11.19 | I'd cut Trains, Creator and Drown With Me and add in Chloroform, Mellotron, Sleep of No Dreaming and maybe Burning Sky (although somehow I still haven't heard Lightbulb Sun!! Need to fix this soon) |
Faraudo
04.11.19 | Very reasonable corrections, I'd only stick to my guns with Drown With Me. Could go with the rest of them, tho.
Definitely do so, it is one of their best records. |
JohnnyoftheWell
04.11.19 | Yeah I've always felt like not loving Drown With Me was going against the grain tbh, not sure why it never clicked...and will do! I've been hooked up on so much Japanese stuff lately that SW's dour British tones would probably feel as refreshing as they ever will ;]
|
Faraudo
04.11.19 | Some songs or sounds just never click my man, nothing wrong with that. I would love to listen to that album as if I've never heard it before to rediscover it's intricacies and sounds, but that's not possible lol. You have a great opportunity to do so yourself, so enjoy!
When you do get to listen to it, of course. |
Kalopsia
04.11.19 | no Trains? no deal |
