SlothcoreSam
09.30.22 | Let the VOTING begin.
3 points. Jaki Liebezeit Best, gets 3 points
2 points. Danny Carrey 2nd best gets 2 points
1 point. Gene Hoglan 3rd best, gets 1 point. |
SlothcoreSam
09.30.22 | Also, you can still nominate, and vote on that drummer, I will add to the list. |
evilford
09.30.22 | 3. Tomas Haake
2. Sean Reinert (nom)
1. Lille Gruber |
evilford
09.30.22 | Changed my vote, sorry! Nominating Sean reinert, played in Cynic and Death (on Human) |
SlothcoreSam
09.30.22 | @evilford, great idea, if you nominate someone not on the list, let me know, and what band they are in. Makes it easier for me. |
evilford
09.30.22 | Which btw is the single greatest percussion performance ever recorded imo |
evilford
09.30.22 | Np yea thanks! Cool idea here, haven't caught on that this was even going on til now |
SlothcoreSam
09.30.22 | This will be the first position of the band, you can add other nominations for the other positions here.
https://www.sputnikmusic.com/list.php?memberid=1137253&listid=200857 |
Clumseee
09.30.22 | 3. Jimmy Chamberlin
2. John Bonham
1. Bryan Devendorf
|
Josh D.
09.30.22 | 3 Gavin Harrison
2. Reinert
1. Roseboom |
DamnVanne
09.30.22 | 1- Vincent Roseboom
2- Gavin Harrison
3- Stewart Copeland |
DavidYowi
09.30.22 | 3. Lille Gruber
2. Sean Reinert
1. Neil Peart
So with this ranking would Lille get 3 points or 1 point? (edit: Sawpped Lille with Neil) |
mkmusic1995
09.30.22 | 1. Alex Camarena
2. Neil Peart
3. Matt Cameron |
ArsMoriendi
09.30.22 | 3. Jimmy Chamberlin
2. Stewart Copeland
1. Jaki Liebezeit |
SlothcoreSam
09.30.22 | Sorry for the confusion.
3 points for your highest, favorite,
2 points for second fav
And 1 point for 3rd fav.
So reverse yours Ars. |
SlothcoreSam
09.30.22 | Lille would get 1 point David |
YoYoMancuso
09.30.22 | 3. Jimmy Chamberlin
2. Billy Rymer
1. Tomas Haake |
ArsMoriendi
09.30.22 | Fixed it |
BitterJalapenoJr
09.30.22 | 3. Bill Stevenson (Descendents, Black Flag) [new nominee]
2. Bran Dailor
3. Thomas Haake |
SlothcoreSam
09.30.22 | Updated, and fixed the spelling, thanks Johnny |
TVC15
09.30.22 | 3. Sara Lund
2. BMDrummer
1. Dewinged |
Deez
09.30.22 | 3 Jamie St Merat
2. Sean Reinert
1. Bill ward |
egads
09.30.22 | no votes for the goat ben koller is crazy
anyway
1. DJ Quik
2. DJ Quik
3. DJ Quik |
Vercetti
09.30.22 | 3 Dave Lombardo
2 Lars Ulrich
1 Dewinged |
Minortimbo12
09.30.22 | 1. Jen Ledger
2. idc
3. idc |
SlothcoreSam
09.30.22 | Any single drummer ratings will just get 3 points. Jimmy and Sara are currently battling it out. |
TVC15
09.30.22 | #SaraSweep |
botb
09.30.22 | Real talk it completely depends on the other band members, itβs absolutely impossible to choose separately |
egads
09.30.22 | |
nash1311
09.30.22 | 1. Rymer
2. Improta
3. Blake Richardson BTBAM |
PotsyTater
09.30.22 | β Real talk it completely depends on the other band members, itβs absolutely impossible to choose separatelyβ
I think that is kind of the point my brother |
PotsyTater
09.30.22 | I vote Helen Wiggin from the Shaggs |
SlothcoreSam
10.01.22 | List is updated.
botb, the fun is choosing members to form a random supergroup. The further we get into this, the crazier it might become. |
normaloctagon
10.01.22 | 1. Gavin Harrison
2. Gavin Harrison
3. Gavin Harrison |
SlothcoreSam
10.01.22 | @norm8, that only counts for 3 points, but you can do that if u want. |
PotsyTater
10.01.22 | My 3 points go to the shaggs
2 point to Meg white
1 point to ringo starr |
SlothcoreSam
10.01.22 | Keep them votes coming, list will be up for 3 days, then we move on to Bass player. |
Madbutcher3
10.01.22 | 3 christian vander
2 lille gruber
1 brad wilk |
Shemson
10.01.22 | 3 points Dailor
2 points Flo
1 point Grohl
They were the three I was toying between before my submission so Iβm happy to see Flo and Grohl got mentioned elsewhere |
fogza
10.01.22 | I nominate Kurt Dahle and give him 3 votes.
2 votes to Keith Moon
1 vote to Stewart Copeland |
Heppasodge
10.01.22 | 3 points: John Bonham - it has to be. The complexity disguised as simplicity is genius
2 points: Haake - the goat metal drummer
1 point: George Kollias - the goat death metal drummer |
Kompys2000
10.01.22 | 3 points Matt Cameron (huge array of styles across multiple bands, proven to collaborate well as a songwriter)
2 points Steven Drozd (twang gang babyyy)
1 point Dewinged (UwO) |
RadioSuicide
10.01.22 | 3. Vincent Roseboom
2. Danny Carey
1. Billy Rymer |
SlothcoreSam
10.01.22 | Updated list |
PitchforkArms
10.01.22 | 3 points Rymer
2 points Coller
1 point Richardson |
SlothcoreSam
10.02.22 | Last day for voting on the drummer. Looks pretty close at the moment |
ArsMoriendi
10.02.22 | Who is winning |
SlothcoreSam
10.02.22 | Not gonna say, as it might influence the final outcome.
I'll put results up tomorrow |
Emim
10.02.22 | 3. Gavin Harrison
2. Travis Orbin (nomination)
1. idk me |
SlothcoreSam
10.02.22 | Looking good, 12 hours left |
someone
10.03.22 | 3p Christian Vander
2p Sara Lund
1p Aric Importa |
Josh D.
10.03.22 | Wrap this up so we can move on to the next position. Fuckin...guitar, Kurt Coabin |
Trifolium
10.03.22 | 3p. Jaki Liebezeit
2p. Dewinged
1p. Tomas Haake |
Pangea
10.03.22 | 3. Bill Ward
2. Vincent Rooseboom
1. Bryan Devendorf |
ItsTheSquirrel
10.03.22 | 3. Jamie St Merat
2. Bryan Devendorf
1. Vincent Roseboom |
SlothcoreSam
10.03.22 | Will tally up votes and put up the next position at lunch. You can keep on voting until then if you haven't already. |
wham49
10.03.22 | 3Bill Kruetzman
2 Bill ward
1 Bonzo
how in the hell is Lars on this |
SlothcoreSam
10.03.22 | Tomas Haake is the winner and Drummer.
2 Guitarists voting up soon. |
nash1311
10.03.22 | Shocker! |
ArsMoriendi
10.03.22 | The Meshuggah guy? ugh is the supergroup just gonna end up prog metal |
pjquinones747
10.03.22 | Tough stuff here. 1 is my top favorite in this instance.
1. Billy Rymer
2. Jamie Saint Merat
3. Sean Reinart |
brainmelter
10.03.22 | 3. Lille Gruber |
ArsMoriendi
10.03.22 | Idk Johnny 2 of my votes are going toward my noms (Jerry Harrison and Frank Zappa) sooo 3rd one can maybe be janky psych |
SlothcoreSam
10.03.22 | New list up!! |
Kompys2000
10.04.22 | I'm just along for the ride until the singer rounds then it's claws out |
Kompys2000
10.04.22 | That said I will accept a prog guitarist but NOT a prog bassist |
Kompys2000
10.04.22 | Mmmm do you have a foil in mind? Could she sing with Carly plzplzplz |
ArsMoriendi
10.04.22 | "Frank Zappa is already janky psych you are gud hmmmm"
Eh...he's more jazz informed |
Kompys2000
10.04.22 | Squinting to see if that's a double entendre about Carly's coke habit or just a reference to her sugary musical style |
SlothcoreSam
10.04.22 | Kompy, stop sitting on the fence, and vote on 3 guitarists. |
evilford
10.04.22 | This is gonna be such a Frankenstein band lol |
Minortimbo12
10.07.22 | No one else voted for Jen :-( |
Zig
10.09.22 | 3 points: Max Roach
2 points: Bill Bruford
1 point: Vinnie Colaiuta |
gg901goody
11.07.22 | Chad Smith
Bonham
Peart |
TheHamburgerman
11.07.22 | 3 points Gavin Harrison
2 points Virgil Donati
1 points Dave McGraw (ps. it's Dave, not David) |
Bigwill2k
11.12.22 | deleted |
Bigwill2k
11.12.22 | 1. Daney Carey
2. Jimmy Chamberlin
3. Gavin Harrison |