SymbolicInTime
08.14.18 | Load and reload are basically the same album so idk how there’s 2 albums in between them. 8 is 6 |
J() Alexander
08.14.18 | "Best song: Motorbreath
Worst song: Hit the Lights"
Did you accidentally switch up those two? |
DadKungFu
08.14.18 | KEA and RTL are the only great Metallica albums. There, I said it. |
J() Alexander
08.14.18 | Come on, man, Master of Puppies is great too.
|
kalkwiese
08.14.18 | It has some great songs, let's agree on that |
AntonTati
08.14.18 | TheWonderSoFar: I just think Load has a lot more good songs than ReLoad. All the best tracks from those two albums are on Load. Just a personal opinion.
AlexanderMR: No, I didn't. Actually I think that songs on KEA are all almost equally good. I really like Hit the Lights too but I had to choose one. |
ColonelWang
08.14.18 | 8 is 6 [2]
I actually love All Nightmare Long and listen to that individual song as much as I would their classic material. |
TheClansman95
08.14.18 | would put Death Magnetic higher but the rest is accurate, although MOP is the best to me |
Risodo
08.14.18 | make a ranking arguing about the top 4.
the rest doesn't even matter. |
SymbolicInTime
08.14.18 | @Colonel yesssss All Nightmare Long is such a banger |
TheGreatQ
08.14.18 | Fun fact: in high school I took an acapella version of the Linkin Park/Jay-z Numb/Encore mashup and put it over Suicide & Redemption |
Doctuses
08.14.18 | 8>7 |
AlexKzillion
08.14.18 | Switch 5 & 6 and switch 7 & 8 and this is mine |
kalkwiese
08.14.18 | 7 has the better songs, let's face it. Some stuff on 8 drags too, I should relisten though. 7 has too much filler, but the good songs in it make it the better record |
Morningrise767
08.15.18 | Totally agree with your top 4. Though Ride The Lightning could've easily been #1. That album is probably the best they've ever released.
And yes I agree, Load isn't THAT bad, it's still got some great songs. It's not the classic Metallica sound, but still good lol. |
Casavir
08.15.18 | "the worst Metallica album with too long songs"
Metallica fans have some ridiculous tunnel vision. |
Djang0
08.15.18 | Disposable Heroes is the best song on MoP, thank you. |
Disorderly
08.15.18 | I agree on Load. It has some filler, but when it's great, it's amazing. The Outlaw Torn is easily one of their best songs. I also agree on The God That Failed being the best song on The Black Album, although Wherever I May Roam is a contender for that too. If 1 had the production that 2 had, it may be my favorite, but the production is inexcusable to me, and a few of the songs feel a little bloated. While MOP is their best to me, I think Ride The Lightning will always be my favorite album. |
AlexKzillion
08.15.18 | "Spit Out the Bone" is probably better than anything on Death Magnetic, but the second best song on HTSS ("Halo on Fire" imo) would be like the 5th or 6th best on DM. |
AlexKzillion
08.15.18 | "Load and reload are basically the same album"
Not true at all. |
kalkwiese
08.15.18 | Lol, the songs on DM aren't bad, but they're not THAT good imo. Sure, there is The Day That Never Comes and All Nightmare Long, but Halo On Fire roasts basically everything else on DM while being on par with those songs |
RippingCorpse1986
08.15.18 | List needs more men. |
RippingCorpse1986
08.15.18 | ''"the worst Metallica album with too long songs"
Metallica fans have some ridiculous tunnel vision.''
Didn't expect to see someone defending St. Anger of all things on this list. Wow... |
Casavir
08.15.18 | "Didn't expect to see someone defending St. Anger of all things on this list. Wow..."
I wasn't defending St. Anger. I'm pointing out the vacuous nature of this criticism being leveled at St. Anger when supposed "peerless classics" like Master of Puppets have similar issues. |
RippingCorpse1986
08.15.18 | Oh, I see. My bad. |
J() Alexander
08.15.18 | To be fair, St. Anger has pieces that are "too long" in the sense that they're much longer than they should be. It becomes repetitive, which is even worse considering that even if the songs were shorter they'd still be bad. |
kalkwiese
08.15.18 | Sad butt true |
TheClansman95
08.15.18 | MoP's songs aren't too long |
kalkwiese
08.15.18 | Well, some habe a chorus too much tbh. |
TheClansman95
08.15.18 | hmmmm |
Casavir
08.15.18 | "MoP's songs aren't too long"
What's next? Are you going to tell us that The Thing That Should Not Be is a thrash classic?
|
TheClansman95
08.15.18 | chill bro, wtf. btw TTTSNB is far from being "bad", although it's probably the weakest song on the album |
kalkwiese
08.15.18 | Even the MoP t/t - a real classic - could have benefited from a little trimming. Songs on that album are a bit too long, I absolutely agree |
JDubb
08.15.18 | I have a hard time listening to ...And Justice for All, knowing the crap Lars pulled with Jason's bass. As a former guitar and bass player myself, it is inexcuseable. |
TheClansman95
08.15.18 | ^^ agree |
veninblazer
08.16.18 | St. Anger > Reload
Also hot take: DM and HTSD > KEA |