|UserReviews 6Approval 100%Soundoffs 49Album Ratings 1012Objectivity 80%Last Active 07-10-18 1:12 amJoined 06-27-17Forum Posts 0Review Comments 802
|2017 - 5/5 songs|
Or, I prove how low my standards are.
|1||Do Make Say Think|
Stubborn Persistent Illusions
[yearning for something more, and finding it]
"Bound and Boundless"
The centerpiece of their latest album, this two-part suite is one of the most sublime things the band has ever recorded. It begins inconspicuously, slowly evolving over the 11-minute runtime to its glorious finale- which is one of the greatest emotional payoffs I've gotten from music this year. The production is excellent; layered without feeling cluttered, spacious without feeling vacant, pristine without being gutless.
[saying goodbye while the party rages on]
"Something to Remember Me By"
This is a really, REALLY well crafted synth-pop song. The instrumental is in a constant state of flux, always exploring new territory within itself without ever becoming sidetracked. Faris Badwan's vocals bring just the right amount of melancholia to the mix, and the chorus is truly, truly blissful.
[a flaying knife, applied liberally]
"A White Truck"
This song begins with a cello slowly peeling away layers of my skin. This song begins by unsettling me more than anything else I've heard this year. And then it explodes.
The World Is A Loud Place
[rambling on and on inside a kaleidoscope]
There's a moment towards the end of this song where everything slides into place. The instrumentals, which glide in and out of the at will, burst in a explosion of color. The lyrics, which ramble nonsensically, circle back on themselves in a gloriously clever way. The journey to that point is worthwhile as well - open and cheerful, but with hidden depths that make it worth relistening to againandagainandagainandagain.
Thin Black Duke
[hosting a banquet in a padded cell, my suit is a straitjacket]
"Letter of Note"
This song is all-encompassing, to the point that it's almost impossible for me to focus on anything else. I can't stop thinking about the buildup, how the guitar slowly climbs with the strings hovering in the background, how Eugene's voice grows higher and higher, creaking and straining until it finally snaps.
[slowly turning the 'tension' dial clockwise]
"Blacken the Other Eye"
Intricate brutality - harsh sounds orchestrated with a keen eye. Vocals that slowly lose their cool, unable to keep calm amidst the chaos, until finally, they lash out.
[an offhand story, well told]
"Police Came to My Show"
I couldn't tell you why I keep coming back to this song. It seems deliberately inconsequential - "Oh yeah, one time police were at my show," Billy tells me, "I did it up." But there's something about his storytelling here - his subtle uneasiness around the cops in the first verse, the quiet humanity towards the end of the second - that makes it truly something special.
|8||Kirin J. Callinan|
Kirin is definitely self-aware about the kind of music he makes - it'd be hard to say lines like "Wrapped up in plastic, thrown down the stairs, feeling fantastic" without a wink. Despite that, though, he still throws himself wholeheartedly into pop with his own truly eccentric spin on it. This song is the best of them, with a fantastic hook that keeps building off of itself and an instrumental that is a spectacle onto itself.
Relatives In Descent
[giving up on the world, paralyzed on a sofa]
Arguing with cashiers because there's nothing else to do. Speaking with telephone salesman because their lives are a lot more goddamn interesting, that's for sure. Desperately looking for a way, but finding none, and then pretending like you knew that all along.
A Crow Looked At Me
[i dont have any clever metaphors for this one im sorry]
I could put any song from this album on this list. I could put every song. But this song was the hardest to stomach, the hardest one to brush off.
"Nature Fights Back"
It's remarkable how active this song is considering how little is actually happening. Hauschka is able to transform a piano and the odd sounds he has lying around into something that is engaging and just fuckin' fun to listen to.
|12||Sun Kil Moon|
Common As Light and Love Are Red Valleys of Blood
[rambling at a family reunion about the good ol' days, much to everyone's chagrin]
"God Bless Ohio"
Unlike other parts of this album, every single second feels purposeful, directed. Mark Kozelek isn't so much looking back on his youth as he is vomiting the details up, unable to stop himself. It all circles back in the end, though, to Ohio. Despite the murder and the kidnappings and the hard times and the poverty and the everything, there's still something special about his home state to Mark, and I think the way he tells his story is truly beautiful.
[something's not right, maybe it's guy muttering in the corner]
On this song Jamie dances along the fine line between surrealism and insanity, muttering and screaming as he does so. There's something tentative about his vocals, which is highlighted by the ocean of reverb surrounding them. Something's off, and Xiu Xiu revels in that.
|14||The Mountain Goats|
[empowering the weirdo, or maybe just joining in]
"Rain in Soho"
This song is grandiose, epic, and that's what it makes it weird. It's grand in unusual ways - background vocals that pipe in and out, ominous piano playing. It works not because John Darnielle wholeheartedly embraces its oddities, it flourishes because of it.
[alpha-male posturing, now with bongos]
Alex has a knack for fusing seedy, sometimes revolting characters with blissful electropop. Marlon Brando is the best example of this - the protagonist is a homophobic stalker, desperate for attention from a woman who has no idea who he is. If I had a nickel for every time I've muttered "I feel like Marlon Brando", I'd have a lot of nickels.
Rap Album Two
[let me sit down, and i'll tell you my story]
This is Jonwayne at his most exposed. He's not going to shy away from this - quite the opposite. But it is his bluntness that makes the song so effective, as well as the amazing feature from Low Leaf at the end.
Turn Out The Lights
[isolating myself, focusing inwards]
"Turn Out The Lights"
Anything I say about this song is going to be said much more eloquently when one of you nerds reviews this album. You know who you are.
"Confessions Pt III" (released officially in 2017)
Can we just all agree that Colin Stetson is a god, and leave and that? BBNG are great too don't get me wrong, but it's Stetson incredible performance that's the star of the show here.
[dancing around the bonfire]
I don't get outdoors much, but something about this song makes me really wish I did. It's gloriously paganistic, as he builds into a dizzing, group-vocal chorus that rides out the final half of the song. Dawson's voice is perpetually unsteady - sometimes barely able to get the notes out, other times absolutely nailing falsettos. It's a strange song by a strange man, and I couldn't be happier being part of the ritual.
|hi this is wildly self-indulgent but i wanted to do it so here we are|
|you should go outdoors more|
forests are cool
|also 3 is a top 5 song this year agreed|
|what is 2|
|im not sure but it might be a really well-crafted synthpop song? idk i shouldve been more clear :/|
|i meant the album, description was g! is it all synth pop?|
|sort of yeah its a mix of synthpop and neo-psych-y shoegaze stuff its really cool|
|Good list, a little sad tho, but I guess I'll keep on chucklin'|
|hey friv i have a thing toSAYY:: .................good list good blurbs good shit|
|ah shit i can't argue with that gg|
|Just started jamming these. I've been sleeping on dmst :saddab:|
|Oh, man. I hated that Kirin song lol.|
|lmao his music isnt for everyone |
|17 gonna be good son.|
|List has a serious lack of Drake |
if this list had drake on it, it wouldnt be a list of 5/5 songs now would it
|List is mostly pure fire. Can't wait to check out DMST, The Horrors, High Plains, Landlady, Protomartyr, Haushka, and Richard Dawson.|
Will be avoiding Kirin at all costs though lol.
|This needs more attention. Deserves a feature, imo. Playlist rules and most of it isn't my standard fare.|
|i didnt even realize julien baker has a 2017 release|
|You have three of my 5/5 tracks of 2017 but I’m not saying which...|
|You have zero of my 5/5 tracks of 2017 but I won't tell you which.. |
|I'm really getting the urge to make a listttttttt jusssssstttttt liiiiiiiiiike thiiiiisssss.|
Idk why I typed like that.
|agreed hard on 7. |
RAPPERS HALF MY AGE TRYIN' TO TRADE CASSETTE TAPES
|people on this site are slurping 16 so hard. cool list though bud|
|is slurping a good or a bad thing|
|it's more good than bad.|
|ill take that|
|i probably would have chosen a different song for most of these lmao but this list is still pretty sweet so im not complaining gj|
|"if this list had drake on it, it wouldnt be a list of 5/5 songs now would it"|
Yeah it would