ramon.
12.10.18 | On further inspection someone opened the discussion up on the best game of the year, but that's too specific and I'm a wishy washy scoundrel so I won't apologise for anything |
Dewinged
12.10.18 | Red Dead was probably my favorite, played a shit ton of MH World too. Also Rocket League forever and recently got into Destiny 2 again, going through those DLCs now. |
Gyromania
12.10.18 | on chapter 6 of red dead 2 atm and it might be my goty. god of war and celeste are also way up there, and i'm sure smash would be in my top 5 but i have no way of playing it. gwent would also be in my top 5 probably, for how much play time i've gotten out of it. the new version is really good once you get used to it.
are there any good updates in rocket league over the last year? i used to be a diamond tier player, put about 500 hrs into the game but haven't touched it in 2018. needed a break from it |
Sinternet
12.10.18 | god of war |
mynameischan
12.10.18 | i see arthur morgan in my dreams |
Gyromania
12.10.18 | should i do all of my side quests and legendary animal hunting before i end chapter 6? i know there's a long epilogue but i'm not sure if you can return to do stuff after that |
polyrhythm
12.10.18 | Played a bunch of games I loved this year, just not many new releases.
Wish I got more out of God of War. The storytelling lowkey (Loki?) sucks and Atreus is an insufferable character. A shame so much focus was put on the father-son relationship, when that isn't a relationship I found interesting at all. We get it, aging game developers. You became dads in the last few years.
RDR2 has one of the most intricate open worlds ever, but I don't know how fun it is to play. The controls are frustrating (L1 + R3 + mash the X button to comb your horse's ballsack!) and there is almost no margin for error. When you can hardly remember what button does what, and bumping into shit (i.e. a tree or a stranger) causes absolute bedlam, then your gameplay experience is constantly grinding to a halt because your character is now injured on the ground or has half the town chasing him. I'm keen to see where the story goes, but I feel so little motivation to play. |
budgie
12.10.18 | diablo ii |
mynameischan
12.10.18 | pretty much all side activities are available, certainly the more minor ones like the legendary hunts. there might be some stranger missions that are inaccessible but i think most of them are still playable. |
polyrhythm
12.10.18 | New Gwent was pretty cool. Didn't know you played, Gyro |
Gyromania
12.10.18 | cool thnx chan
poly: yeah man, i'm really into it right now. crafted a few of the meta decks (if you're familiar with them: giant woodlands, elf control, and boar sk) and have been winning the vast majority of matches |
Gyromania
12.10.18 | also poly your gripes with rdr2 are natural. for the first few hours i played it felt very odd to me. once you get used to its systems though, it becomes second nature. did for me, at least. i still have some grievances with it, but now that i'm 6 chapters in it all feels pretty great. also the lighting in that game is god-tier |
ramon.
12.10.18 | Couldn't really comment on what's happened with RL of late to be honest. I have similar gripes with RDR2, and while I have similarly come to get used to it, it still feels like it could have done with further refinements. Game is super sick though, hoping it grows on me more with time. |
Frivolous
12.10.18 | Crosscode for me, but Obra Dinn is #2
Everything about Crosscode felt so fucking good - the action, the writing, the puzzles, the music, the characters - that I can't really pick anything else |
J() Alexander
12.10.18 | SoulCalibur VI hell yeah
If anyone wants a fighting game from this year (besides the obvious two), the new ARIKA game, Fighting EX Layer, is pretty nice too. But I can't say anything about the best game of the year because I've only played those two. Monster Hunter and Celeste look quite good tho (and God of War looks like shit). |
ramon.
12.10.18 | damn friv I love you I completely forgot crosscode existed been meaning to play it for a hot minute now
fighting EX layer was dope! a shame it hasn't really gotten any appropriate widespread acclaim. hoping it does well because I feel a lot of old school fighters coming back into the spotlight are setting their hopes on a game like EX succeeding. |
J() Alexander
12.10.18 | I'd like to see it do well, but I'm not sure if it will tbh. I like it quite a bit but like any good old school fighting game it isn't very accessible and the production isn't very good. But maybe it will do better than I expect, I hope it does. |
ramon.
12.10.18 | for real. I feel like old school fighters can really make a resurgence if they step away from that old school mentality of "2.5D is the future!" and just make something that looks appealing but works on a budget (pocket rumble being a notable recent example of something very straightforward that has sold remarkably well). if a dev team could fit modern fgc ingenuity into a simple but tonally consistent and understandable package I have little doubt a complex fighter could sell very well. |
budgie
12.10.18 | ok mine was a joke obvs but best 2018 game is europa barbarorum II for me, huge patch came out last week |
tyman128
12.10.18 | yea, there was a BO3... about as memorable as you saying that tbh |
DamnVanne
12.10.18 | Zero Dawn. Did that release in ‘18? |
ThyCrossAwaits
12.10.18 | I was about to say “lol who picked the card game in the Witcher” and then I realized they actually made a Hearthatone-thingy out of Gwent wtf is games |
zakalwe
12.10.18 | Pillars of Eternity II Deadfire.
|
Dewinged
12.10.18 | Oh and Dark Souls Remastered, fcourse. |
polyrhythm
12.10.18 | If remasters are allowed, then Spyro Reignited is an absolute joy |
Zig
12.10.18 | Shenmue I & II (HD Remasters)
Those games are legendary, and the hd remaster is very good. |
polyrhythm
12.10.18 | @Gyro I believe you when you say RDR2 gets better, I know I’ve barely scratched the surface of that game. It’s simply whether or not I’ll find the motivation to push on to that point. Haven’t played too many ranked games in HC actually, mostly playing Arena until I get truly familiar with all the new abilities. Then maybe I’ll feel like I can competently deck build again. I could just play netdecks of course, but I’d rather not |
DungeonBoy
12.10.18 | Hollow Knight is the best game I've played since Super Metroid on SNES. |
theNateman
12.10.18 | Dude Spider-Man and Horizon Zero Dawn need to be on this list. Two of the best games I've ever played.
Also play DeltaRune. |
DarkSideOfLucca
12.10.18 | I don't know about 2018 games, but that KEN Mode album is fucking fire
Also the best game is God of War |
mynameischan
12.10.18 | horizon came out last year |
Winesburgohio
12.10.18 | Shaun Tan eh |
budgie
12.10.18 | "Pillars of Eternity II Deadfire."
are they ever going to make pillars multiplayer
i had fun with the first game but it's losing so much potential by not being playable with your buddies like icewind dale or bg |
Mendross
12.11.18 | Best games . Not looking . It has to be red dead redemption. Am I wrong ??? |
Mendross
12.11.18 | I haven't played it. |
Chortles
12.11.18 | horizon was kinda lame anyway
Haven't played that much from this year but my favorite is probs The Messenger. gud list, gonna check out Gorogoa and a few others |
Get Low
12.11.18 | Ultimate sucks ass. |
ramon.
12.11.18 | u coulda just said "it isn't melee" fam smh my head |
Get Low
12.11.18 | I really wanted to drive home the point that I didn't like it though. |
ramon.
12.11.18 | I hate you for having an opinion of which I disagree, kindly, sir. |
Gyromania
12.11.18 | anyone who says melee is better than ultimate is completely full of shit |
ramon.
12.11.18 | I prefer Melee but I think Ultimate is the better game |
Gyromania
12.11.18 | i played melee and brawl competitively back in the day at local gaming tournaments. won a decent number of them. i get the appeal for melee being that it's lightning fast, but i think mechanically speaking ultimate is every bit as complex, if not more so with added mechanics and frame-perfect shield blocking. given that, it's just weird to me when people pick melee over ultimate, a game whose systems are arguably deeper that comes with like 30x the content melee has to offer |
Get Low
12.11.18 | But you can combo people in Melee for more than two hits. |
J() Alexander
12.11.18 | Pretty sure you can do that in every Smash game. |
Get Low
12.11.18 | From Brawl onward, if you get consecutive hits on someone it was because you made a read. In Smash 64 and Melee, that shit was guaranteed. |
J() Alexander
12.11.18 | Reads are good. |
ramon.
12.11.18 | there's a good reason smash gets two games in the main evo roster and other fighters don't. the smash games on a competitive level have minute community overlap because they are fundamentally different competitive experiences. it is why street fighter 4 isn't played at evo, or tekken 6, and so on. it isn't really that unreasonable for someone to pick melee over ultimate. melee is about as fundamentally different to ultimate as street fighter is to kof, and no one is surprised when players of those communities have such little overlap. |
Keyblade
12.11.18 | ultimate barely been out a week, not sure how anyone can say it is or isn't better than a 17 year old game |
Morningrise767
12.11.18 | My fav games of the year:
- God of War
- Red Dead Redemption 2
- Detroit: Become Human
- Spider-Man |
ramon.
12.11.18 | easy! like this
ultimate is a better game than melee imo |
Keyblade
12.11.18 | its a better game for sure, i meant from a competitive perspective
there's always gonna be melee weirdos who won't budge ofc, but once the meta starts to settle i feel like ultimate would become my favorite in the series tbh |
WatchItExplode
12.11.18 | So nobody here plays Vermintide 2? That's lame |
ramon.
12.11.18 | I mean, I think you can just not like the mechanics or game feel as it stands. I adore the way aerials feel in melee. I love wave dashing and all the movement tech that game offers. If those elements are your entire reasoning behind playing the game competitively, it shouldn't surprise anyone that you think melee is the better competitive game.
never got round to vermintide, how is it? |
Keyblade
12.11.18 | my point is that there could be elements in ultimate that surface that could sway your opinion, it's too early to write off. could be movement options that are even better than wavedashing, who knows...the game definitely seems deep enough |
butcherboy
12.11.18 | backgammon.. |
WatchItExplode
12.11.18 | Vermintide is uniquely visceral and satisfying... I never get tired of turning rat men into red mist |
Gyromania
12.11.18 | ramon: that's the thing though, i've played at a decently high competitive level with both melee and brawl, and i think there's a lot of elitism surrounding the former when talk of which game is best. as someone who's poured hundreds of hours into both, and a decent amount of time on the recent ones, i really don't get why people can't adapt to either style. it's still fundamentally the same thing, one is just faster than the other. if anything i think melee allows for a lot of cheap bullshit that later games have rightly balanced |
Gyromania
12.11.18 | vermintide! dude, i thought i was the only one. games more than satisfied my longing for a new left 4 dead game. |
WatchItExplode
12.11.18 | Right on gyro...incredibly fun coop |
ramon.
12.12.18 | gyro, I feel like you are ignoring "If those elements are your entire reasoning behind playing the game competitively, it shouldn't surprise anyone that you think melee is the better competitive game."
Brawl isn't being played competitively anymore because Smash 4 does a lot of what Brawl did but better. I feel the Smash 4 community will largely transition to Ultimate and stay there because it does a lot of what 4 did but better. Melee does a fair few things that no other entry in Smash (or game for that matter) does. I agree that Melee is about as bullshit as they come in many aspects, but the community isn't being destroyed from the inside out by a Metaknight/Cloud doubles/Bayo equivalent. Once again; we had two Smash games at EVO these last few years. Neither were Brawl, and I'm doubtful 4 will come back to the main stage this coming year. There has to be more to this longevity than a bit of community elitism and "it's still fundamentally the same thing, one is just faster than the other", no? |
DamnVanne
12.12.18 | I’m like 30 hours deep into Yeehaw Skyrim and it’s definitely top 3 for me |
ramon.
12.12.18 | thats the best desc for red dead ive ever heard pos |
Gyromania
12.12.18 | i've played nearly as much of 4 as brawl and i agree it is better, i just listed those two because those were the ones i played competitively. i much preferred 4, i just never got entrenched in the competitive scene. melee has a significant amount of bullshit tho. especially the ice climbers grab. i cannot believe they let that shit fly at the highest level. |
Gyromania
12.12.18 | lol yeehaw skyrim, i like that. real talk tho, skyrim is and always been a pretty average game, esp when you compare it to the witcher series... or several other rpgs tbh |
beefshoes
12.14.18 | Celeste and Hollow Knight rightfully belong here, with the later easily being one of my favourite games of all time at this stage, but Dragon Quest XI (seriously one of the best, consistent, and most underrated JRPG series) and Mega Man 11 really need to be on this list. Bloodstained: Curse of the Moon was wonderful as well, and I am ridiculously excited to play Dragon Ball FighterZ |
theNateman
12.14.18 | "horizon came out last year"
Shit man you right. My bad. |
Saros
12.14.18 | 2 and 5 are great, and I'll probably get 4 too. Overall, I'd say Smash Ultimate is my GOTY, with Yakuza Kiwami 2 close behind it. Fist of the North Star: Lost Paradise was great too. |
unclereich
12.14.18 | Damn I kinda wanna go get the new cod game now because I’m so bored of rdr2. |
unclereich
12.14.18 | I’ll give u a fat 2 |
neekafat
12.14.18 | There was a 3 and it was great you penis |
Sinternet
12.14.18 | oh shit i compoletely forgot slay the spire went early access this year its probably my pick actually (although full release is january) |
Frivolous
12.15.18 | slay the spire is great |
Saros
12.15.18 | 2018 has been pretty good for games, although it was hard to beat 2017. |
Funeralopolis
12.15.18 | slay the spire is incredible yea |
theNateman
12.15.18 | I read somewhere that Detroit: Becoming Human was basically a cyberpunk Heavy Rain. That true? |
Sinternet
12.15.18 | wait detroit was this year too wasn't it
goddamn it's been a long long year |
Gyromania
12.15.18 | "Curse of the Moon" - seriously dude, how fucking great was this game? i love how imposing the boss fights are at first, until you learn their patterns. really brought it back to that hardcore difficulty i remember from the nes days. some of the hitboxes were a little frustrating, and most sections that required pixel perfect inputs (like jumping gaps) could be mad frustrating, but overall a hard 8.5/10 for me. beat it thrice over. mega man 11 disappointed me a little. some of the art was fantastic, and some was just so kiddish and boring looking. the boss fights left a lot to be desired too. and can we please talk about how dogshit the collision detection was on some sections that require you to move as fast as possible?
hollow knight is def the best metroidvania i've ever played and i put around 125 hours into it all told. nightmare king grimm is probably my favourite boss fight of the year (i realize it came out last year, but i played it this year) |
Gyromania
12.15.18 | also re curse of the moon: do you also feel that the main game they're making (what's it called, ritual of the night?) looks fucking awful by comparison? |
Storm In A Teacup
12.15.18 | One of the best things in gaming in 2018 was definitely Project AHO for Skyrim finally releasing. Probably the most beautiful journey Elder Scrolls has ever had. |
Flugmorph
12.15.18 | tfw i have literally played no game from 2018
and probably not 1 from 2017 either
|
Storm In A Teacup
12.15.18 | I definitely did not play an official 2018 game. They most recent game release I bought was Fallout 4. lol |
Gyromania
12.15.18 | still find bethesda mediocre as fuck. they continue using the same antiquated engine that's riddled with bugs and graphical inconsistencies. fallout 4 was a very boring game imo, but at least it's nowhere near as bad as fallout 76. for me, the only truly enjoyable fallout game was new vegas |
Sinternet
12.15.18 | 1 and 2 are classic bruh |
Flugmorph
12.15.18 | i might check out Gorogoa, looks like my kinda game
also im probably gonna get banner saga 3 for christmas and since i still havent finished banner saga 2 and its been like 2 years since ive played that im just gonna go ona trilogy binge this christmas and its gonna b glorious. |
Gyromania
12.15.18 | tried the first banner saga and thought it was dreadfully boring. not a fan of turn based games in general unless they're really good, like earthbound or persona 5. i know it's a different style, since it's more like a chess board than just basic turn based games, which lends it more strategy, but it still felt slow as hell to me and not very enjoyable. conversely, i think xcom 2 is a great time |
Flugmorph
12.15.18 | well just not your kinda game then, i was enthralled by it from the word go. |
beefshoes
12.15.18 | @Gyromania I cannot agree with you more! Curse of the Moon is absolutely incredible, and can definitely relate with your concerns about Ritual of the Night. I don't like the art style that they used for it, the gameplay footage that has been shown looks incredibly sluggish, and I think that it is safe to approach it with a strong sense of caution, after what happened with Mighty No. 9 for example. Honestly, I would have been much happier if Igarashi had just done a few games in the style of Circle of the Moon instead. o:
Mega Man 11.....idk, I honestly don't have any complaints with it, and it is my third favourite in the classic series after 3 and 9. It feels incredibly good to play, I personally love the art and the boss fights, the addition of the gear system, and Wily's Castle was even fun to get through, though I think that everyone could have done without another Yellow Devil fight. I even like the art style, where the 2.5D games usually don't appeal to me much at all. |
beefshoes
12.15.18 | Ah and Hollow Knight......it is seriously that fucking incredible, and everyone needs to experience that game. It is the perfect Metroidvania. |
Flugmorph
12.15.18 | oh ye i guess i did play hollow knight earlier this year, doesnt feel good at all that i didnt finish that.
its from 2017 tho right? |
beefshoes
12.15.18 | Yeah. The console ports were released this year though, and it didn't get much mainstream attention prior to that. |
lalchimiste
01.08.19 | Damn I'm still not done with Breath of the Wild (although I started it a couple months ago). Still have Hollow Knight/Celeste/Messenger on my wishlist, radical.
Also, I was convinced Dead Cells would have been mentioned, it looks awesome |
DungeonBoy
01.08.19 | "also re curse of the moon: do you also feel that the main game they're making (what's it called, ritual of the night?) looks pretty awful by comparison?"
dude. yes
@lalchimiste dude, I beat Hollow Knight last week. One of the best games i've ever played. Celeste and Dead Cells are on my list. Really dig some indie games |
lalchimiste
01.09.19 | Nice dude! I'm all in for some indie Metroid/Castlevania or platformers as well! I just started Owlboy last week, it's pretty rad so far. I think my fav from the last couple of years is Ori, but yeah I've only heard good things about Hollow Knight so might just get it after Owlboy |
DungeonBoy
01.09.19 | oh man, I got Owlboy and Megaman 11 for Christmas this year.. and last night I was looking at the two and just decided on Megaman 11 cause I wanted something familiar I could just chill out to after work.. but no, this is not the case, Megaman 11 is freaking hard as crap. I'm pretty stoked on it at the moment though |