CaliggyJack
10.21.22 | Book of memories doesn't exist
Homecoming is a fantastic game but other than the name it's not a SH title, so I'm not adding it here |
Zig
10.21.22 | nice they're doing a SH2 remake. although a proper SH1 remake would be amazing. |
Trebor.
10.21.22 | 2 > 1 > 3 >>>4 > trash |
wojodta
10.21.22 | Homecoming feels like more a SH game than Downpour and Shattered Memories. Also, they should have started with a SH1 remake and then went to SH2, but whatevs. At least it's something. |
DungeonBoy
10.21.22 | Silent Hill 2 remake tho |
Sharenge
10.21.22 | based - also have more love for the first one... I think having the most love for 2 is the most common which is I imagine why that's the one getting the remake
still need to play 3... I've only gone through like the first half hour or so... might try to sit down with that soon
technically also need to beat 1... I rage quit towards the very end so now I have that monkey on my back |
Sabrutin
10.22.22 | I want to play this series so badly but I wish to obtain the originals legally and it's kinda impossible especially the first one.
also Silent Hill F mega hype for my g Ryukishi07 |
DrGonzo1937
10.22.22 | Downpour higher than 4?! You out your mind |
Sharenge
10.28.22 | curious on your reasoning for choosing 3 for your number one
started it up last night and fuck man, I know you can say the same about its predecessors as well, but it's just like this hellishly disorienting fever dream... like it really doesn't wanna let you get your bearings ever
I guess part of it is A. this is basically my first playthrough and B. the setting/environment, which is a lot more claustrophobic right off the bat than 1 & 2 which both have you on the streets out in the open a fair bit at the beginning (well aside from the opening sequence of the original, but that's one of those things where once you experience it the first time and know how it goes and what to expect, it loses a lot of its impact) |
DrGonzo1937
10.28.22 | It’s considered by many to be the most superior SH title, next to 2. I myself find it a little weak from the main 4 titles — I’d probably go 2-4-1-3. In honesty though, chiding between the 4 is like splitting hairs; they’re all masterpieces |
foxblood
10.30.22 | I think Origins is underrated, the ost is too. the first 4 games are all 10/10 |
DType
10.30.22 | 0rigins gets better near the end, it's overall solid but not very memorable imo |
DType
10.30.22 | For me goes like: SH2 > SH4 > SH > SH3 > SH0 > the rest |
Gyromania
10.30.22 | Wow, SH1 before 2, Downpour before 4... Predictably shit list |
Gyromania
10.30.22 | And yeah Homecoming has way more SH DNA than Donwpour or Shattered Memories (or 4, for that matter) |
FreakMachine
01.03.23 | I definitely agree with SH2 being not top. 1 will always be my favorite |
