ieatbabies795
12.22.20 | Amirite?! |
Sinternet
12.22.20 | no
especially considering acceptance speech is by far their best record |
ieatbabies795
12.22.20 | Wut |
Pikazilla
12.22.20 | Happiness fucking sucks |
Relinquished
12.22.20 | kurt travis sucks
dbm 2 > 1 |
Colton
12.22.20 | this but post-hardcore as a whole |
ieatbabies795
12.22.20 | Don’t worry guys I won’t delete your comments for disagreeing the way @fatihcoskuny does on his lists |
ieatbabies795
12.22.20 | “this but post-hardcore as a whole”
You’re not wrong |
Lasssie
12.22.20 | everything with tillian is bad |
ieatbabies795
12.22.20 | I think their first two with him are p bad
The last three seem like they were taking cues from A Lot Like Birds |
SteakByrnes
12.22.20 | I've liked pretty much everything they've released, but they need to change things up for the next album |
CygnusX1
12.22.20 | They do what they do rather well and pretty consistently. For me ArSe was more of "same old formula" type record, more like Mothership b-sides. At least Afterburner has Clentamiento, say hi, nothing, and into the sunset. Jon Mess is a national treasure |
Snake.
12.22.20 | band sucks
happiness is honestly the only one of theirs I can get behind |
Lasssie
12.22.20 | Jon Mess and Will Swan are the only reasons i even bother listening to DGD when they release new stuff |
ieatbabies795
12.22.20 | @Cygnus maybe it was fatigue that made me give Afterburner a lower score but I kind of agree with you |
ieatbabies795
12.22.20 | “Jon Mess and Will Swan are the only reasons i even bother listening to DGD when they release new stuff”
Through all the lineup changes, those two guys helped hold the band together |
SteakByrnes
12.22.20 | Don't forgot Mingus bro |
ieatbabies795
12.22.20 | Shit you’re right |
rufinthefury
12.22.20 | Tillian is really bad and it's just that simple |
GringoSuave89
12.22.20 | Secret Band > DGD |
Lasssie
12.22.20 | Tillian tried for both Emarosa and Saosin if i remember correctly and i wish one of them would have taken him in instead |
SteakByrnes
12.22.20 | He was also the first vocalist for Night Verses but they never made music together |
ieatbabies795
12.22.20 | Whoa well I’m glad Night Verses went with Doug at the time |
Lasssie
12.22.20 | I wasnt really into Tides of Man either |
SteakByrnes
12.22.20 | I loved Tides with Tilian, I still think that's his best work. His songwriting is pretty cool, he wrote a lot of the Tides songs but doesn't write any of the dgd stuff outside of vocals and structuring. Apparently whenever he wrote stuff it sounded too much like Tides of Man to him so he stopped writing |
Lasssie
12.22.20 | I even remember some of his solo stuff being decent |
tellah
12.22.20 | >:( |
rockarollacola
12.22.20 | Dreadful band name. Really gives me the impression that this is some pretentious bullshit that I "just wouldn't understand". |
ieatbabies795
12.22.20 | @tellah sorry man, not a fan of your fav album of theirs :l |
GreyShadow
12.22.20 | 7 is like the best album in the world tbh |
GreyShadow
12.22.20 | also are you implying both afterburner and arse are better than instant grat and acceptance speech cuz that's silly silly |
AtTheGates92
12.22.20 | I absolutely loved Mothership and Artificial Selection, but Afterburner really didn't do it for me. Like, I felt physically repulsed by it. |
AtTheGates92
12.22.20 | Also what GreyShadow said, Acceptance Speech is a pretty strong effort, idk what you're on about |
ieatbabies795
12.23.20 | This was my first time listening through their whole discog, so in the moment Gratification didn’t stand out to me
[edit] wait you said Acceptance Speech? Nah that one is kinda trash |
ieatbabies795
12.23.20 | To be fair I made the list to try to shit on @faithcoskuny but I ended up enjoying their music a bit more than I thought I would have |
ieatbabies795
12.23.20 | @GreyShadow Ye, 7 was the one I enjoyed the most |
AtTheGates92
12.23.20 | Mothership is undeniably peak DGD. I gave it a spin after seeing this thread. I still love it to bits, this album. |
JeetJeet
12.23.20 | Band is ass |
BookoftheFallen
12.23.20 | I agree, white trash circa survive are not that great of a band. Jonny MacBook craig is a great singer though. |
MillionDead
12.23.20 | Yeah overrated af. It's kinda just pop rock with screams tacked on. You could throw out the whole "Swancore" wing of post-hardcore and not lose much. Post-hardcore is an incredible genre though. |
conesmoke
12.23.20 | The vox aren't my cup of tea |
cold
12.23.20 | Afterburner ruined the entire band for me |
ieatbabies795
12.23.20 | @cold Interesting, lots of people say that. I found it to be predictable and more of ‘same old formula’ so I thought it was something their fans would eat up |
zakalwe
12.23.20 | Second best band of the last twenty five years |
AtTheGates92
12.23.20 | @cold I feel the same. Today was the first time I had listened to them since I first heard that hot pile of garbage. I'd rather just pretend it doesn't exist. |
LeddSledd
12.23.20 | good list |
cold
12.23.20 | "Don’t worry guys I won’t delete your comments for disagreeing the way @fatihcoskuny does on his lists"
glad I'm not the only one whose noticed |
Pangea
12.23.20 | i have only heard death of a strawberry but that was possibly the worst song i have ever heard |
cold
12.23.20 | If you're gonna listen to any DGD song, make sure it's not a Tilian-era track |
ieatbabies795
12.24.20 | Mm they can have some shitty songs in every era not just Tilian |
ieatbabies795
12.29.20 | I was about to update the ratings but I’m gonna keep it for posterity sake
My opinion on these records is mostly the same |
ieatbabies795
12.29.20 | Also I actually ended up liking some of their music lol |
cold
12.29.20 | how the turntables |
