Artuma
08.12.15 | where's integrity? |
Tyler.
08.12.15 | I mean... this list isn't wrong |
ZeroxSP
08.12.15 | I haven't listened to Integrity yet :/ |
zaruyache
08.12.15 | I was sorta hoping this would just be a blank list |
Deez
08.12.15 | Skycamefalling EP
Bloodlet The seraphim fall
Coalesce Give them Rope
Cave In- Until your heart stops
Morning Again - Hand of hope
I could write a million but im at work |
ZeroxSP
08.12.15 | I THOUGHT Skycamefalling deserved to be an essential. But idk. Same for Cave In. I honestly can't really get into Coalesce. I don't feel they have that hardcore feel the other bands have. The other 2 I haven't listened to |
Inveigh
08.12.15 | definitely check Integrity, they influenced the entire genre. good list though. you should also check Coalesce and Deadguy |
Inveigh
08.12.15 | also Calculating Infinity should probably be here imo |
ZeroxSP
08.12.15 | I'll check out Integrity and Deadguy. But I just can't get into Coalesce. And I see Dillinger as influential towards the technical side of metalcore (mathcore) though. That's why I didn't include |
Inveigh
08.12.15 | get what you're saying with Dillinger. Have you listened to 0:12 by Coalesce? i think that's their best personally |
Deez
08.12.15 | the SCF ep is, The album isnt. Anyone doubting cave in as essential metal core should not be doing lists :)
far more essential than 3,4,5
|
Artuma
08.12.15 | "Have you listened to 0:12 by Coalesce? i think that's their best personally"
functioning > |
Inveigh
08.12.15 | yeah functioning is awesome too, just personal preference i guess |
Deez
08.12.15 | I dont think you can go wrong with most coalesce
deadguy, Integrity [2] |
Deez
08.12.15 | Acme - To Reduce the Choir to One Soloist |
ZeroxSP
08.12.15 | @ Inveigh I have the cd. I'm trying to find their Functioning... Album though because the last track caught my ear. Maybe that'll bring me to like them
@deezer idk man. The album's good. But I just don't think it deserves a spot up there. Maybe as an honorable mention with Strongarm, but you gotta remember Cave In had that total sound change with Jupiter and Antenna. One could argue those albums were probably their breakthrough releases compared to Until Your Heart Stops. Where I stand on that, idk yet. All 3 are equally inspiring to me and I have yet to tell which is their breakthrough release |
Deez
08.12.15 | you couldnt class Jupiter or Antenna as metal core so its invalid. Youre talking albums not bands, no? Until your heart stops is one of the best metal core albums of all time period. I didnt say the SCF album I said the EP. I think the albums super overrated. Trust me, As someone who was amongst it as it was born (metalcore) that album had a HUGE effect.(UYHS) |
Inveigh
08.12.15 | can't lie, Until Your Heart Stops is classic metalcore
also, not on the level of other albums on this list, but i feel like mention needs to be made of Every Time I Die - Hot Damn!, Hopesfall - The Satellite Years and The Bled - Pass the Flask |
Calc
08.12.15 | "I would've put Strongarm but I didn't think they were that important as the others."
or you could have added a whole whopping 8 entries instead of 7... |
SIMBOLIC
08.12.15 | Avenged Alexandria - hail to the master of puppets |
BandNewbac
08.12.15 | charles bronson - youth attack |
Artuma
08.12.15 | powerviolence is definitely not metalcore even though they have a lot in common |
Artuma
08.12.15 | yeah well unfortunately that makes the charles bronson rec kinda invalid |
BandNewbac
08.12.15 | i read it as hardcore instead of metalcore, oooopsss too early. |
Mort.
08.12.15 | knut - challenger
kiss it goodbye - she loves me, she loves me not
rorschach - protestant
drowningman - busy signal at the suicide hotline
|
yep123
08.12.15 | Hopesfall - The Satellite Years |
Aftertheascension
08.12.15 | No skycamefalling, no list |
JoeMcSatanBalls
08.12.15 | A distinct lack of calculating infinity. Also, get poison the well off of here. |
YetAnotherBrick
08.12.15 | yeah well with 7 albums you can't really cover much |
JS19
08.12.15 | If this is what influenced Metalcore, why isn't Metalcore actually good? |
YetAnotherBrick
08.12.15 | it got homogenized.
also why do these lists always get so many comments when they're always the fucking same |
Artuma
08.12.15 | because sputnik loves to discuss 90s metalcore |
Space Jester
08.12.15 | Rorschach needs love. Remain Sedate was pretty punk but Protestant was a game changer. |
Space Jester
08.12.15 | Dang Mort mentioned Rorschach while I was typing my comment |
YetAnotherBrick
08.12.15 | "because sputnik loves to discuss 90s metalcore"
true, and it is good shit, but it seems like if someone makes a metalcore list that goes remotely outside these bands they get shat on. people only want the same metalcore list they've seen a thousand times. i'm prolly exaggerating a bit but whatever. listmaker, you should check out Breather Resist and Knut |
ZeroxSP
08.12.15 | I have a Knut cd. The yellow one. Forgot it's name. But I'll check out Challenger. Same for Breather Resist. I haven't checked out a lot of sludge/post metal or chaotic metalcore styled bands like them. I mostly stick to the Shai Hulud and Strongarm styled bands |
squaaab
08.12.15 | chokehold - content with dying |
Sinternet
08.12.15 | No Zao? |
Mort.
08.12.15 | "Dang Mort mentioned Rorschach while I was typing my comment"
Yeah bruh love them. I reviewed protestant
|
botb
08.12.15 | Knut, hopesfall, skycamefalling, [2]
To include integrity and not include unbroken is beyond dumb to me |
JokineAugustus
08.12.15 | Comity, Burst, Burnt By The Sun, Beecher, Johnny Truant, Curl up and Die, Gaza, Suicide Note, etc |
Mort.
08.12.15 | Jokine has you covered
|
Royl123
08.12.15 | Zao[2]
Killswitch engage
|
demigod!
08.12.15 | ACME |
ZeroxSP
08.12.15 | So I'll check out those bands then Jokine |
Space Jester
08.12.15 | Dude I was jamming Comity today, they rule
|
Deez
08.13.15 | https://www.youtube.com/results?search_query=zao+ravage+ritual
come on tho |
Space Jester
08.13.15 | Has anyone mentioned Starkweather? |
Deez
08.13.15 | Jesterhead just won the thread |
Snake.
08.13.15 | "Killswitch engage"
no |
GuanoBumbershoot
08.13.15 | Should round this out to an even 10.
Integrity, Rorschach, and Starkweather would be good choices. |
Deez
08.14.15 | Bloodlet |
alienobserver
08.14.15 | knut - challenger |
alienobserver
08.14.15 | beaten to it lol |
