ChoccyPhilly
01.03.18 | Disagree, agree, up to you. |
gryndstone
01.03.18 | Good list. Halfway through Season 4, just finished up Crocodile and liked it, to be honest. Be Right Back is my #1, personally.
A big draw to the show is I think that everyone values different things coming into it, so everyone's favorite Black Mirror episodes are often different. |
Deathconscious
01.03.18 | USS Callister, Hang the DJ, Shut Up and Dance, and White Christmas are some of my favorites as well.
Nosedive, Be Right Back, and The National Anthem would definitely be higher in my ranking. and while Crocodile wasnt one of the best, i would easily place it over Arkangel, which is probably the worst Black Mirror episode imo. |
rebeccasugar1979
01.03.18 | Haven't watch season 4 yet but White Christmas is and will always be no.1 to me. |
ConcubinaryCode
01.03.18 | I thought I'd hate uss callister but it ended up as one of my favorites. White Christmas is probably my favorite but I really like men against fire too. Also you're missing 15 million merits which rules too. |
Rowan5215
01.03.18 | Be Right Back
Metalhead
San Junipero
White Christmas
Hang the DJ
The Entire History of You
Shut up and Dance
USS Callister
Fifteen Million Merits
rest is mediocre to trash |
Deathconscious
01.03.18 | shit, i forgot about Fifteen Million Merits, that ones up there too.
"rest is mediocre to trash"
lol though |
XingKing
01.03.18 | I have two episodes left of S4 and I feel like most of the episodes would rank towards the bottom of my list. USS Callister was great but should've ended two or so minutes prior. Arkangel wasn't very inspired and the ending was lol worthy and came abruptly. Crocodile was just hysterical in how weak and absurd it was. Hang the DJ was wonderful until the last few minutes, that felt like they shit on the rest of the episode. Can't comment on the last two but hoping they redeem this rather weak season.
White Christmas and The Entire History of You are the best episodes of the whole show, IMO. |
Deathconscious
01.03.18 | the Arkangel ending didnt make any sense. so she broke the tablet. like her mom wont be able to just go to the company who did the implant and get another one? no one ever thought they might break? |
XingKing
01.03.18 | The Arkangel implant was deemed illegal in most major countries. I remember the therapist (?) saying it was being deemed illegal in the US later that year. |
Deathconscious
01.03.18 | oh yeah, i guess i forgot about that. |
XingKing
01.03.18 | As much as I wasn't a fan of the episode and have no real desire to defend it, they did at least sort of cover that aspect. |
cold
01.03.18 | The sadomasochist doctor could've totally been it's own episode. But yeah, since Netflix got a hold of this show, it's value has suffered. Seasons 3 and 4 are riddled with filler (i.e. Arkangel, Hated In The Nation, Crocodile, Men Against Fire), but do have some gems of it's own (i.e. Shut Up And Dance, USS Callister, San Junipero). Just give this show back to Channel 4. |
XingKing
01.03.18 | I have to assume it's because Netflix wants a faster release of content, so Charlie doesn't spend as much time fine tuning the scripts as he used to. We previously got 7 episodes in three years and since Netflix came in, we've gotten 12 in two years. |
cold
01.03.18 | That's true, as well as the fact that Netflix is going to cater more to an American audience, therefore the show has suffered because of it. It's still great, don't get me wrong, it just hasn't had the same bite the first two seasons had. |
ChoccyPhilly
01.03.18 | Huh
I definitely remember writing fifteen million merits but that should be no.4 tbh |
Crymsonblaze
01.03.18 | 15 Million Merits
Be Right Back
White Christmas
Haven’t watched half of S3 or any of S4 yet though. Got really burnt out after Playtest |
cold
01.03.18 | I remember Playtest being a pretty good episode. Maybe it's time for a rewatch? |
Henderson
01.03.18 | I honestly think it's statistically impossible to find another person who agrees with one's Black Mirror rating.
19. The Waldo Moment
18. Black Museum
17. Playtest
16. Crocodile
15. Arkangel
14. White Bear
13. Metalhead
12. Shut Up and Dance
11. Men Against Fire
10. Nosedive
9. Hated in the Nation
8. USS Callister
7. The National Anthem
6. 15 Million Merits
5. White Christmas
4. Be Right Back
3. Hang the DJ
2. San Junipero
1. The Entire History of You |
cold
01.03.18 | ^ that's pretty accurate, though I don't think "Black Museum" wasn't that bad. |
Henderson
01.03.18 | I didn't think it was bad per se (unlike The Waldo Moment), but I didn't really enjoy it much. Anyway, aside from "Hang the DJ" which was an instant hit, I'll rewatch S4 soon enough and some of those lower ones could move a bit. |
Papa Universe
01.03.18 | Toby Kebbell is a great goddamn actor... not a smart one, seeing the terrible roles he keeps on picking, but still a great one. |
Papa Universe
01.03.18 | Top 5 tho:
1. White Christmas
2. The Entire History of You
3. San Junipero
4. Shut Up And Dance
5. USS Callister |
cold
01.03.18 | 19. Crocodile
18. Arkangel
17. Metalhead
16. The Waldo Moment
15. Men Against Fire
14. Hated In The Nation
13. Nosedive
12. The National Anthem
11. White Bear
10. Playtest
9. Black Museum
8. 15 Million Merits
7. White Christmas
6. USS Callister
5. Shut Up And Dance
4. Hang The DJ
3. San Junipero
2. The Entire History Of You
1. Be Right Back |
cold
01.03.18 | "Toby Kebbell is a great goddamn actor"
I loved that dude in Rock N' Rolla |
WatchItExplode
01.03.18 | I find it interesting that you have San Junipero near the bottom and Hang the DJ near the top. Two sides of the same coin, and both top-tier imo.
15 mil
Hang
San Junipero
Men Against Fire
USS
Playtest
These are my faves and agree some of this is borderline unwatchable trash, including White Christmas, which actually left me angry I had spent so much time watching. I love Mad Men but John Hamm is nothing but a jawline and pomade. |
cold
01.03.18 | Jon Hamm can be a pretty funny dude tho |
Satellite
01.03.18 | ^ this. jon hamm is a consistently solid comedic actor. see also his cameos on 30 rock, wet hot american summer and unbreakable kimmy schmidt. |
cold
01.03.18 | DUDE, he's sooooooo funny on Unbreakable |
StallionMang
01.03.18 | i still have a few to go but 1 is probably 1. fuck that one was difficult to watch, and toby's performance is unbelievably good |
cold
01.03.18 | I think Be Right Back broke something in me, haha |
StallionMang
01.03.18 | white bear is way up there too, idk what that one gets so much flak for. i think the point of the ending is to leave it up to the viewer as to whether or not the punishment is too indefensibly hellish |
CygnusX1
01.03.18 | I'm the only one who didn't care for Hang the DJ? It was interesting enough but kinda boring throughout. Overall it felt like a "safe" season for Black Mirror. USS Callister was one of the best, and I really liked "The Pain Addict" part of Black Museum. |
StallionMang
01.03.18 | be right back fucked me up too. i think the best episodes are the ones where the right decisions are left ambiguous
ill see if i can come up with my own ranking but its gonna be a doozy |
cold
01.03.18 | San Junipero left me with all the sad wholesome feelings, and I'll never recover |
StallionMang
01.03.18 | entire history of you
be right back
hated in the nation
white bear
15 million merits
san junipero
waldo moment (underrated)
shut up and dance (despite the stupid ending)
nosedive (overrated, but still good)
playtest
black museum (everything past this is good to ehh)
men against fire
arkangel
metalhead |
guitarded_chuck
01.03.18 | so s4 has both the best and the worst of bm huh, and here i was hoping theyd finally reach a point of consistency, not sure ill even bother now idk |
Papa Universe
01.03.18 | Nosedive was the first episode to not make me feel anything. Not even anything uncomfortable or sorrowful, not even a bad feeling. It was just so mellow and non-descript. |
cold
01.03.18 | ^thissssss |
furpa
01.03.18 | USS Callister is unquestionably the best of the new season for sure. Agreed on #1 too btw. Good list! |
Deathconscious
01.03.18 | Nosedive was liberating, i love the ending.
FUUUUUUUUCCK YYYOOUUUUUUUUUUUUUUU |
BlackMalachite
01.03.18 | I really need to give this show a whirl eventually. |
ConcubinaryCode
01.03.18 | 1. White Christmas
2. 15 Million Merits
3. Entire History of You
4. Uss Callister
5. Black Museum
6. San Junipero
7. Hang the DJ
8. Men Against Fire
9. Playtest
10. Shut up and Dance
11. Nosedive
12. White Bear
13. Be Right Back
14. Hated in the Nation
15. The National Anthem
16. The Waldo Momemt
17. Crocodile
18. Archangel
19. Metalhead
|
brainmelter
01.03.18 | White Christmas seems to be the best for most of u? I've seen 4 or 5 episodes from random season and I've seen white Christmas and it was good but nothing mind blowing. now I know I'm not missing anything by not watching the rest lol |
neekafat
01.03.18 | Where tf is S1E2? |
WatchItExplode
01.03.18 | Black Mirror is supposed to make you question your existence, not offer any catharsis dude. |
Feather
01.03.18 | I'm finishing up these shows this week probably. I watched em all out of order so I need to figure out what I havnt seen. Just watched Waldo Moment and Archangel the other day and thought they were both fine.. not good but eh. I thought the ending of White Bear made it all worth it for that one. |
ChoccyPhilly
01.03.18 | I already said for some reason fifteen million merits got deleted but it should be #4 as it's easily one of the best episodes |
Crymsonblaze
01.04.18 | Daniel Kaluuya’s performance alone makes it worth the watch. So so fucking mesmerizing. |
Deathconscious
01.04.18 | Waldo Moment and Arkangel are bottom tier. |
ChoccyPhilly
01.04.18 | It's the small things though like how reserved Bing is about the whole world. Like, he knows it's a pile of shit but also knows there's nothing realistic he can do to change his situation. |
Ryus
01.04.18 | 1. 15 million merits
then be right back, san junipero, entire history of you
then idk |
ChoccyPhilly
01.04.18 | I don't get the appeal for San Junipero. There was little chemistry between the actors on screen unlike Hang The DJ and I just didn't feel very immersed in the world, unfortunately |
someguest
01.04.18 | You have to be a bit older to appreciate the world in San Junipero.
No way in hell Hang the DJ > San Junipero. |
Rowan5215
01.04.18 | "USS Callister is unquestionably the best of the new season for sure."
ha....... nah. |
XingKing
01.04.18 | I don't get the appeal for San Junipero. There was little chemistry between the actors on screen unlike Hang The DJ and I just didn't feel very immersed in the world, unfortunately [2]
It is a visually beautiful episode but other than that, it does nothing for me. |
DarkTyler
01.04.18 | worst show |
Deathconscious
01.04.18 | BlackTyler |
zakalwe
01.04.18 | This entire thing is all built up around the speech made in 15 million merits and the thing isn’t even on the list. Black Mirror indeed. |
Deathconscious
01.06.18 | Watching Black Museum, holy shit. Ties with USS Callister imo and its one of the best episodes of the show. Douglas Hodge is great. |
GhostB1rd
01.06.18 | Black Mirror ranges from "that was okay" to "nah" |
TheSpaceMan
01.06.18 | Agreed |
hal1ax
01.06.18 | yea i very much dislike this show |
GhostB1rd
01.06.18 | From what I've seen the one with BDH was okay... others were pretty shit. |
TheSpaceMan
01.06.18 | It's insulting how not subtle it is, themes of smartphones are bad obvious from the start while a weak plot plays out around it. Idk it's not awful but it's not as great as it was hyped to be for me |
GhostB1rd
01.06.18 | Alice Eve tho. |
Chortles
01.06.18 | yeah the whole show is way wayyy too heavy handed for its own good |
Crymsonblaze
01.06.18 | Watched Shut Up and Dance and San Junipero after being stalled out for months due to Playtest
Uhh, both were alright I guess. This show almost constantly fails to stick the landing, which I guess is better than botching the dismount. But it’s pretty normal for me to just expect a shitty ending now because they have no idea how to finish a story 9 times out of 10 |
someguest
01.06.18 | Crymson lookin' for that happy ending and not getting it. |
Papa Universe
01.06.18 | that's who the fourth season was made for.. |
Crymsonblaze
01.06.18 | No no, Guesty, I don’t want a happy ending, I want any ending. San Junipero’s ending was pretty “happy”, but it was super unearned and dumb
Most episodes feel like “whoops, ran out of film. Let’s cut it here”. |
Crymsonblaze
01.06.18 | I like nihilism as much as the next internet douche but not when it feels like a byproduct of bad writing and not the point the writer’s trying to make |
ChoccyPhilly
01.07.18 | Actually most episodes feel like DID YOU SEE THAT EASTER EGG!?!?!
Kind of annoying now |
Royl123
01.10.18 | Top ten: 15 million merits, Play test, entire history of you, Be right back, shut up and dance, nose dive, the national anthem, San Junipero, arkangel, hang the dj |
Ryus
01.10.18 | "Actually most episodes feel like DID YOU SEE THAT EASTER EGG!?!?! "
ugh yeah i hate this it's pointless and just obnoxious |