Feather
09.22.16 | Kurt > Jonny > Tillian
(I still really enjoy IG and the new singles tho) |
SteakByrnes
09.22.16 | Kurt is best
I can never choose between Jonny or Tilian being 2nd and 3rd tho, but for now I guess I'll say this
Kurt > Jonny > Tilian |
Futures
09.22.16 | Jonny>Kurt>Tillian
this or foad |
Rowan5215
09.22.16 | Kurt > Jonny > Till |
YakNips
09.22.16 | kurt > jonny > tilian
very hard for me to decide between kurt and jonny |
TheSpirit
09.22.16 | Tilian = Kurt > Jonny |
Snake.
09.22.16 | tillian is so awful |
Futures
09.22.16 | so are you |
Snake.
09.22.16 | lol gud 1 |
brainmelter
09.22.16 | Jonny wins this by a long shot and Kurt and Tillian are both good, same level for me |
Trebor.
09.22.16 | can we never talk about dance gavin dance ever again we're not in high school anymore
for real though, tillian is straight garbage and barely deserves to be a footnote in a band's sentence. Kurt is very good and has the most diversity and fit the band the best. Jonny is good at being Jonny but he's very one note and can't really hang for several albums
In an ideal world Kurt would have never left and they would have continued progressing from Happiness
|
captaincrunch11
09.22.16 | Jonny |
brainmelter
09.22.16 | Kurt is amazing but Jonny's voice is honestly the best. but if you're talking about 'for the band' yeah probably Kurt. Tillian isn't garbage but he's def the weakest of the three |
Futures
09.22.16 | jonny one note? lol treb |
ConcubinaryCode
09.22.16 | Kurt is the best and its a shame he got kicked out of 2 bands now. |
SteakByrnes
09.22.16 | Tilian fit better in Tides of Man |
omgbecky
09.22.16 | 1st - Tilian. 2nd - Kurt. 3rd - Jonny. All you guys hating on Tillian are just bitter. |
Futures
09.22.16 | lol yeah we don't like a guys voice as much as the other two means we're bitter |
Feather
09.22.16 | I should have been more clear on scoring, how about this:
K > J > T (K=1, J=.5, T=0)
K = J > T (K=.75, J=.75, T=0)
K > J = T (K=1,J=.25, T=.25)
K = J = T (Void) |
Snake.
09.22.16 | "All you guys hating on Tillian are just bitter."
if i was a fan of this band before 2013 i'd be bitter too because then i'd have to put up with shitty vocals |
G0atC0re
09.22.16 | Kurt > Jonny > Tillian |
Sinternet
09.22.16 | none |
brainmelter
09.22.16 | how are you guys ducking up this bad, Jonny is #1 |
Futures
09.22.16 | true |
omgbecky
09.22.16 | Seriously? Calling Tillian garbage is definitely a bitter move. |
Futures
09.22.16 | lol |
TheSpirit
09.22.16 | "for real though, tillian is straight garbage and barely deserves to be a footnote in a band's sentence. "
Also you :
"To be fair I'll probably never enjoy a new Dance Gavin Dance record as much as I did back in the mid to late 2000s, but Instant Gratification is solid enough, and fresh enough to knock the cynicism right out of me - and believe it or not, Tillian's vocals grew on me." |
Futures
09.22.16 | shhh treb is elite af dude |
ellagos
09.22.16 | Kurt > Tillian > Jonny |
oltnabrick
09.22.16 | oltna > |
spookynewghostfriend
09.22.16 | oltna> |
oltnabrick
09.22.16 | dance gavin dance is my favorite user-related musical project |
AdoreSwancore
09.22.16 | Jonny>Kurt>Tilian, Jonny is just naturally the better vocalist (he can be completely drunk/ drugged up to all hell and back and still not disappoint live), Kurt and Tilian actually have quite similar ranges with Tilian being slightly higher though so between the 2 I have to give it to Kurt just because he could also bring good harsh/unclean vocals. |
kris.
09.22.16 | the only dgd i give half a shit about is happiness so kurt > tillian (even tho his voice is annoying) > jonny (because he's a piece of shit)
|
Trebor.
09.22.16 | "To be fair I'll probably never enjoy a new Dance Gavin Dance record as much as I did back in the mid to late 2000s, but Instant Gratification is solid enough, and fresh enough to knock the cynicism right out of me - and believe it or not, Tillian's vocals grew on me."
I was wrong tbh. That album grew off me super hard |
calmrose
09.22.16 | probably kurt>jonny>tilian
i enjoy all three pretty equally though, which is probably lame and boring to say, but my three favorite albums by this band are DBM, Happiness, and IG, so... |
Feather
09.22.16 | @Calmrose 2/3 of your faves happen to be Kurt's only 2 records :-) |
GreyShadow
09.22.16 | Tilian > Kurt > Jonny |
GreyShadow
09.22.16 | And as much as I love new DGD, Tides of Man's first two albums suited Tilian the best |
MyNameIsPencil
09.22.16 | Kurt > Jonny > Tillian |
calmrose
09.22.16 | @Feather I think you misread one of my three favorites:
DBM=Jonny
Happiness=Kurt
IG=Tillian
Edit: so the list you have haha |
TheCharmingMan
09.22.16 | idk i feel like each album suits the individual singer best. the best singer in my opinion depends on which dgd album im in the mood for. |
Feather
09.22.16 | @Calm lol you're right, for some reason I read DBM and thought of Death Star? Idk what I was thinking. |
hobblepot
09.30.16 | Tilian > Jonny > Kurt |
JohnnyoftheWell
09.30.16 | I have never actually heard a DGD song with Kurt, but to judge from his work with A Lot Like Birds:
Jonny > Kurt > Tillian |