fogza
12.22.22 | 13 and 14 are deffo too low, 6 is way too high. I am not as reverent of their 80's output but I understand this rating otherwise |
mkmusic1995
12.22.22 | I feel like 13 and 14 have a few really great songs on them and whole bunch of filler. I was surprised to be enjoying their records post-2000's as much as I did. |
SomeCallMeTim
12.22.22 | 1 is def 1 :) 3 gets better and better the older I get |
mkmusic1995
12.22.22 | 3 might creep up to 2 with more listens, definitely loads of great songs on there! :D |
fogza
12.22.22 | Yeah I find their 2000's records all filler but fair enough lol |
gschwen
12.22.22 | I came into my REM fandom alongside the release of Monster, and while I understand it's fairly maligned and deeply flawed, it's up there on my personal list just for the nostalgia.
Out of Time is a fun record with some flaws. Don't like seeing it so low on here but can appreciate why some people dislike it. Shiny Happy People and Radio Song are goofy tracks! I love Belong and Me in Honey.
I think Murmur should be 1 or 2 along with Automatic.
I lump Fables, Document, Pageant, and Reckoning together-- I don't have any preference between any of them. All are good records.
Collapse, Accelerate, Reveal, and Around the Sun are all those 2000 filler records.
New Adventures is a top five record. I think you're just wrong here.
Like Monster, I also like Up a lot and understand it's not popular. Conversely, I don't enjoy Green at all despite what others think of it. |
DocSportello
12.22.22 | Reasonable! |
onionbubs
12.22.22 | mine would go:
5/5 tier
automatic for the people (one of the best albums by anyone)
4.5/5 tier
lifes rich pageant
fables of the reconstruction
reckoning
new adventures in hi fi
4/5 tier
murmur
out of time (would def bump it up if radio song wasnt their worst song ever bc near wild heaven, country feedback and esp me in honey are all timer rem tracks)
chronic town
up (glad you put this so high lol i love this one)
monster (didnt dig this at first and it still has some growing to do for sure but it sure has some strong ass highs)
accelerate
3.5/5 tier
collapse into now
reveal
document
3/5 tier:
green (ya this one aint shit lol slightly warming up to it but its def the worst ive heard thus far)
have not been brave enough to jam around the sun lmao |
zakalwe
12.22.22 | Automatic
Murmur
Pageant
Reckoning
Monster
Document
Green
Fables
Out of Time
Hi-Fi
Reveal
Up
Accelerate
Collapse
Sun
|
mkmusic1995
12.22.22 | Fair enough, my friends. Honestly minus maybe Around the Sun, I enjoyed all the albums a good deal. |
onionbubs
12.23.22 | yeah chronic town rules
this list times well w my jamming as i fell into a giant rem kick this last week thats still ongoing lol fuckin amazing band. interested in seeing if/how this shifts w repeated jams. what are your fav tracks from em? |
mkmusic1995
12.23.22 | I'll have to check Chronic Town, haven't jammed that yet. So far I would say my favorite tracks are Pretty Persuasion, Everybody Hurts, Imitation of Life, Country Feedback and The One I Love. Those are just a few off the top of my head but there's so many awesome songs! |
gschwen
12.24.22 | My 10 track playlist: Leave, The Sidewinder Sleeps Tonight, Let Me In, Walk Unafraid, Fall on Me, Belong, Sitting Still, Finest Worksong, Gardening at Night, Driver 8 |
mkmusic1995
12.24.22 | Fall On me and Sitting Still are a couple of my favorites too! |
ArsMoriendi
12.24.22 | Monster is so uderrated damn
Up is WAY too high, Up mostly sucks |
fogza
12.24.22 | Up is awesome |
virpi
01.16.23 | What fogza said. |
