Artuma
04.22.16 | wrong wrong wrong wrong |
Ocean of Noise
04.22.16 | Switch 1 with 2 and 4 with 5 and you're good. |
romulanrancor
04.22.16 | yeah ashes is my favourite too
top 3 are all 5/5 |
Sevengill
04.22.16 | wrong wrong wrong wrong |
Maniac!
04.22.16 | The Mantle is their best. Your opinions are incorrect. |
benkim
04.22.16 | 21354 |
benkim
04.22.16 | I know people here will not agree about Ashes and The Mantle though |
SCREAM!
04.22.16 | All I'd switch is 3 and 4, otherwise I agree. |
zaruyache
04.22.16 | 1/2 > 3 > 5 > 4 |
someguest
04.22.16 | The White EP
6/5 |
Sevengill
04.22.16 | Faustian Echoes though |
someguest
04.22.16 | 3/5 |
benkim
04.22.16 | Just for Sowilo Rune, White EP 9/5. Probably Agalloch's best track right there |
Atari
04.22.16 | yeah, the white is too good to leave out of an agalloch ranking |
Ocean of Noise
04.23.16 | Pretty much all of the EPs should be on this list |
Thor
04.23.16 | spot on ranking tbh |
chinesewhispers
04.23.16 | Bump 5 up to 3 and we good |
hal1ax
04.23.16 | Marrow is better than 3 and 4 |
Sevengill
04.23.16 | ^ this |
zaruyache
04.23.16 | I'll fight you on 3 but they might be pretty equal. idk I haven't jammed either in forever. |
Gameofmetal
04.23.16 | Marrow is better than 3 and 4 [2] |
oltnabrick
04.23.16 | 1 5 3 4 2 |
Keyblade
04.23.16 | brick knowssss |
Relinquished
04.23.16 | no way 4 is over 2 |
Ashen
04.23.16 | 2 is last yeah |
Asdfp277
04.23.16 | right list |
Keyblade
04.23.16 | i havent heard 4, but the rest of it is spot on |
Asdfp277
04.23.16 | 4 is kinda good imo but most people absolutely hate it and think it's boring af |
TheFourthCircle25
04.26.16 | I go away for a weekend and come back to find so many comments lol |
Artuma
04.26.16 | band is very popular here so that's not really surprising |
Cimnele
04.26.16 | ashes against the grain always struck me as a bunch of lacklustre "emotional" compositions with equidistant strumming that went on forever and ever
(not that there's anything wrong with that 2/5) |
benkim
04.26.16 | "ashes against the grain always struck me as a bunch of lacklustre "emotional" compositions"
lol no |
Keyblade
04.26.16 | that sounds like the mantle agreed |
Ocean of Noise
04.26.16 | Ashes Against the Grain is flawless and so is The Mantle. |
TheFourthCircle25
04.26.16 | They are both fantastic, fantastic albums Ocean. Ashes is perfect and The Mantle is only at #2 by a little bit. If I were doing ratings out of 10, AATG would be 10/10 and Mantle would be 9.5/10 |
oltnabrick
04.26.16 | the mantle always seemed like a lesser version of pale folklore to me |
benkim
04.26.16 | They are very different to me with The Mantle being vastly superior |