Flugmorph
11.27.15 | its that time again boys |
trve
11.27.15 | nomeansno - wrong
gospel - the moon is a dead world
fugazi - repeater
atdi - relationship of command
|
trve
11.27.15 | wait fuck i gotta put hüsker dü in there somehow.. replace my repeater vote with zen arcade |
Artuma
11.27.15 | oh god this is difficult
at the drive-in - relationship of command
unwound - leaves turn inside you
gospel - the moon is a dead world
the pax cecilia - blessed are the bonds
yeah i know no old-school classics like fugazi or hüsker dü or big black |
grindcorecore
11.27.15 | fugazi - repeater
thursday - full collapse
husker du - zen arcade
rites of spring - s/t |
NeroCorleone80
11.27.15 | Husker Du - Zen Arcade
Fugazi - In on the Kill Taker
Not sure if these two count but if so:
Big Black - Atomizer
The Jesus Lizard - Goat
|
Flugmorph
11.27.15 | i would say they are reserved for the noise rock list amiright? |
grindcorecore
11.27.15 | i'd pay them. i mean zen arcade is pretty noisy too but you've got that so |
NeroCorleone80
11.27.15 | Then put down my other votes for NoMeansNo - Wrong, and Fugazi - Red Medicine |
Artuma
11.27.15 | noise rock is very often considered as a style of post-hardcore (well, not a style of it but quite many of the most successful noise rock bands can also be described as post-hardcore) |
NeroCorleone80
11.27.15 | yeah theres a lot of overlap |
Flugmorph
11.27.15 | we could include all the noise rock into it if you want to but i think it will get a little to much for only 4 votes. |
Flugmorph
11.27.15 | of course |
Flugmorph
11.27.15 | as i said, lets not overwigh this list. we will have a metalcore, noise rock and hardcore punk list (and maybe mathcore if that even is a proper genre) so you can cast your votes for big black and jesus lizard there. |
StallionMang
11.27.15 | relationship of command
the argument
shape of punk
yank crime |
Flugmorph
11.27.15 | yeah its all one big family.
i was refering to the original hardcore punk stuff like dead kennedys, misfits, black flag and such.
but im also not very proficient in the punk genre so maybe im not the right person to say that.
|
NeroCorleone80
11.27.15 | True, even post-punk was around by 77, barely a year or two after punk itself |
Flugmorph
11.27.15 | yeah crazy if you think about it really. |
trve
11.27.15 | "wait fuck i gotta put hüsker dü in there somehow.. replace my repeater vote with zen arcade"
would you do this plz flugs flugs would be nice etc ty |
Greem
11.27.15 | Slint - Spiderland
Unwound - Leaves
Lowercase - The Going Away Present
Unwound - The Future of What |
magicuba
11.27.15 | slint - spiderland (2)
gospel- the moon is a dead world
refused - the shape of punk to come ( if it counts since it is very HC as well)
atdi - relationships ( not sure about this tho)
|
Flugmorph
11.27.15 | i would put slint more into the post rock category but it also fits good in here |
magicuba
11.27.15 | Add them with refused :) |
Flugmorph
11.27.15 | more love for biffy clyro hehe
just love their scottish charme |
NeroCorleone80
11.27.15 | damn didnt know Spiderland would count. Switch it with my Red Med vote please |
Flugmorph
11.27.15 | yeah its complicated |
EvoHavok
11.27.15 | At the Drive-In - Relationship of Command
The Fall of Troy - Doppelganger
Thrice - Vheissu (if this doesn't count, then The Illusion of Safety)
Thursday - No Devolucion |
Aftertheascension
11.27.15 | 1, 9, 15, 16 |
ComeToDaddy
11.27.15 | Gospel - Moon
Unwound - Leaves
Minutemen - Double Nickels on the Dime
Rites of Spring - s/t |
WellFedWhiteMale
11.27.15 | Fugazi - Repeater
Drive Like Jehu - Yank Crime
Hated - No More We Cry
ATDI - ROC |
PortraitsOfDecay
11.27.15 | Relationship of command
Moon is a dead world
Spiderland
City of caterpillar |
Sinternet
11.27.15 | Slint - Spiderland
Poison the Well - You Come Before You
Unwound - Leaves Turn Inside You
McLusky - McLusky Do Dallas |
Mort.
11.27.15 | hot cross - cryonics
alexisonfire - alexisonfire
gospel - the moon is a dead world
fear before - the always open mouth |
Avagantamos
11.27.15 | gospel - the moon is a dead world
fugazi - the argument
fear before - the always open mouth
glassjaw - worship & tribute |
Sinternet
11.27.15 | one more to add to your already large cancer collection then |
MyNameIsPencil
11.27.15 | 16 11 5 1 |
Wolfhorde
11.27.15 | 1 3
glassjaw - worship & tribute
fear before - the always open mouth |
Gameofmetal
11.27.15 | uh i guess ill give a vote to repeater but im ashamed to say i havent heard most of these |
TheWrenKing
11.27.15 | Spiderland
The moon is a dead world
Leaves turn inside you
Travels with myself and another
forgive me for I have sinned |
SwallowShotguns
11.27.15 | The Moon is a Dead World
Red Medicine
The Argument
Repeater |
HeckToPay
11.27.15 | shape of punk |
Aftertheascension
11.27.15 | "this thread gave me prostate cancer"
Another insightful and well thought out comment from the site troll, Hep Kat. |
adr
11.27.15 | The Moon is a Dead World
Leaves Turn Inside You
Big Black - Atomizer
Indian Summer - Science 1994 |
Archael
11.27.15 | "noise rock is very often considered as a style of post-hardcore (well, not a style of it but quite many of the most successful noise rock bands can also be described as post-hardcore)"
white heat/white light |
NorthernSkylark
11.27.15 | leaves turn inside, in on the kill, spiderland, zen arcade |
altertide0
11.27.15 | Fugazi - Repeater
Slint - Spiderland
Minutemen - What Makes a Man Start Fires?
Husker Du - Zen Arcade |
Artuma
11.27.15 | it's like you didn't even read my comment but oh well
hep getting satisfaction again for knowing more about obscure punk than anyone else itt |
KILL
11.27.15 | zen arcade |
Artuma
11.27.15 | i know lightning bolt. i'm not pretending to know about the genre nearly as much as you but you seem to think sput only knows fugazi and like three other bands which is ridiculous |
Futures
11.27.15 | refused- the shape of punk to come
at the drive-in- relationship of command
thrice- illusion of safety
the fall of troy- the fall of troy |
deathschool
11.27.15 | Future of the Left - Travels With Myself and Another
Look What I Did - Atlas Drugged
Unwound - Leaves Turn Inside You
Fugazi - The Argument |
trve
11.27.15 | wrong needs more love ;-; |
Aftertheascension
11.27.15 | "most of the bands I mention ain't obscure there bud. just because sputnik is ignorant of a genre don't make its best bands "obscure." ur literally on an INDIE music website whining about how someone outindie'd u, like u don't scoff when someone tells u their life revolves around Trace Adkins and Nickelback. spare me THAT horseshit"
https://i.imgur.com/iWKad22.jpg |
Calc
11.28.15 | hep's a little asshole now awwww. like in a bad way. |
Futures
11.28.15 | haha cool meme XD |
CapnJizz
11.28.15 | zen arcade
relationship of command
repeater
argument |
deathschool
11.28.15 | Wrong is top ten, trve |
cb123
11.28.15 | Jawbox - For your own special sweetheart
Thrice - The Illusion of Safety
At The Drive-In - Relationship of Command
Finch - Say hello to sunshine |
FitToSwing
11.28.15 | Glassjaw - Worship and Tribute
Thrice - The Illusion of Safety
Saosin - Translating the Name (not sure an EP counts)
Refused - The Shape of Punk to Come
Hopesfall - Satellite Years |
hal1ax
11.28.15 | Jawbox - For your own special sweetheart
gospel - the moon is a dead world
city of caterpillar - s/t
off minor - heat death |
TheMagicalBlender
11.28.15 | Repeater
Red Medicine
The Argument
Spiderland |
StreetlightRock
11.28.15 | Gospel - The Moon Is a Dead World
Rites of Springs - Rites of Spring
Slint - Spiderland
Drive Like Jehu - Yank Crime |
Archael
11.28.15 | noise rock isn't post-hardcore you nonces |
ShadowRemains
11.28.15 | shift (ny) - spacesuit
embrace - s/t
choke - there's a story to this moral
unwound - leaves turn inside you |
deathschool
11.28.15 | Bands that blend post hardcore and noise rock are probably just as common as bands that play one or the other at this point. MAYBE even more so. |
deathofasalesman
11.28.15 | Hüsker Dü - Zen Arcade
Fugazi - The Argument
Fugazi - End Hits
At the Drive-In - Relationship of Command |
ftinside
11.28.15 | NOMYGOD
WTF IS GLASSJAW |
deathschool
11.28.15 | There are Glassjaw votes. He just hasn't upadated the list. |
ftinside
11.28.15 | pitchforks |
ftinside
11.28.15 | rumor is he's producing the new tool album
that's whats taking so long |
Flugmorph
11.28.15 | i consider big black & future of the left as noise rock
@FitToSwing four votes dude read the discription
@hep fun
ill do a noise rock list so that we cover that problem |
Flugmorph
11.28.15 | also:
funny that no one has mentioned brand new so far. |
Lowder91bird
11.28.15 | My vote goes to Gospel. |
Flugmorph
11.28.15 | you have 4 votes dude |
Flugmorph
11.28.15 | also The Vertigo of Bliss needs more love. they recorded that album live in the studio. can you believe it? no you cant cause its fucking amazing. |
Lowder91bird
11.28.15 | City of Caterpillar, Envy and Poison the Well get my other three votes then. |
Flugmorph
11.28.15 | i honestly would consider poison the well more metalcore than post hardcore but i guess its still fitting on here |
NeroCorleone80
11.28.15 | All we need now is someone to vote for Steady Diet and the whole Fugazi discog will be here |
Flugmorph
11.28.15 | 13 Songs tho |
NeroCorleone80
11.28.15 | thats a comp |
trve
11.28.15 | wrong only got 2 fucking votes??
shame on you guys |
NeroCorleone80
11.28.15 | hard |
Rolling Girl
11.28.15 | 4
13
49
52 |
worthlessscab
11.28.15 | Hüsker Dü - Zen Arcade
Slint - Spiderland
Fugazi - Repeater
Big Black - Atomizer |
sadchild
11.28.15 | At The Drive In - Relationship Of Command
Thursday - Full Collapse
Alexisonfire - S/T
Dance Gavin Dance - Downtown Battle Mountain (I don't care about absence of this album in the list) |
EasterInTheBatcave
11.28.15 | Shape of Punk to Come, Vheissu, Worship and Tribute, Say Hello to Sunshine |
deathschool
11.28.15 | Why didn't you add my other vote?
"i consider big black & future of the left as noise rock"
But you put McLusky on here? |
Flugmorph
11.28.15 | i can't know all the albums bro dude. |
deathschool
11.28.15 | McLusky is literally a more noise rock Future of the Left. |
SharkTooth
11.28.15 | Nomeansno - Wrong |
deathschool
11.28.15 | Put my fourth vote to Gospel then |
Flugmorph
11.29.15 | updated your votes once more |
Flugmorph
11.29.15 | gospel is in the lead followed by slint and ATDI |
Calc
11.29.15 | not sure how thank you scientist is hardcore in anyway much less post hardcore but ok. I'll vote for the finch album |
BMDrummer
11.29.15 | unwound- fake train |
brainmelter
11.29.15 | yeah thank you scientist is superb but not really post hardcore lel |
hal1ax
11.30.15 | all-seeing negrodamus, i thought jawbox is post-hardcore? have i been living a lie?
|
FitToSwing
11.30.15 | Need to include letlive - Fake History.
|
TheCrocodile
11.30.15 | plz don't die Hep |
BMDrummer
11.30.15 | how is sdre not post-hardcore by definition come on |
BMDrummer
11.30.15 | always thought of it as an umbrella term |
deathschool
11.30.15 | Emo and post hardcore overlap a shitload though. |
deathschool
11.30.15 | Sunny Day Real Estate is post hardcore/Emo as fuck man, come on. Why do are you acting like a band can only be one genre? |
Futures
11.30.15 | sdre is not even close to post hardcore lol |
deathschool
11.30.15 | Diary is supposed to be the quintessential post hardcore to Emo bridge. That's how it's typically viewed in like every database I can think of. |
Futures
11.30.15 | because off minor isn't really post-hardcore. screamo and post hardcore aren't the same |
Masochist
11.30.15 | Spiderland
Relationship of Command
The Shape of Punk To Come
Catch For Us The Foxes |
deathschool
11.30.15 | "Diary (1994)
Diary is the debut studio album from the Seattle-based alternative rock band Sunny Day Real Estate. The album is considered by many to be a defining emo album of the second wave. It has also been called the missing link between post-hardcore and the nascent emo genre."
Literally the first thing that came up on an internet search. I know sometimes these things are debatable, but they're also tagged as post hardcore on every music site I've seen them on. |
deathschool
11.30.15 | Note I did not vote for Diary, but I think its inclusion on the list is pretty warranted. |
Futures
11.30.15 | lol |
Futures
11.30.15 | why should sdre be compared to refused or glassjaw? it makes no sense |
Keyblade
11.30.15 | ""Diary (1994)
Diary is the debut studio album from the Seattle-based alternative rock band Sunny Day Real Estate. The album is considered by many to be a defining emo album of the second wave. It has also been called the missing link between post-hardcore and the nascent emo genre."
[citation needed] |
deathschool
11.30.15 | Refused and Glassjaw came later in the game for one thing. Okay, yeah it's from wiki. So what's an acceptable source then? |
Keyblade
11.30.15 | your ears |
BMDrummer
11.30.15 | if you've ever heard early sdre singles there's a stronger argument for post-hardcore by what you might think, but still they overlap a lot in general. plus futures big black and husker du are both considered post-hc, same era |
Futures
11.30.15 | ok something from the same era. why should sdre be compared to drive like jehu or indian summer? |
deathschool
11.30.15 | Okay, Hep. Well I see them described as post hardcore all the time. And, Key, I think they fit the sonic palette of early post hardcore very well. Second wave Emo had a lot of post hardcore influence anyway. Was it as aggressive? Nah, but you can definitely hear the link |
deathschool
11.30.15 | Anyway, fuck Diary. Listen to Atlas Drugged. |
eliminatorjunior
11.30.15 | Glassjaw - Worship & Tribute
Slint - Spiderland
Unwound - Leaves Turn Inside You
Indian Summer - Science 1994 |
deathschool
11.30.15 | Guilty as charged, Hep. But I still think they fit the label. The problem with post hardcore as a strict genre is that it got to a point where it was bands building off of other post hardcore bands that never really had the hardcore roots in the first. Idk, it's a crazy wide genre is all. But for me, I'm never strict with labels anyway. I never listen to something and say shit like "oh I can't listen to this bull shit, that's not REAL *insert genre of purity here*". |
Keyblade
11.30.15 | death i dont really know much about phxc or sdre tbh, but my point was you were literally posting a wikipedia excerpt that said "other people think this is phxc/emo". might as well go with what your ears tell you, just as valid and more authentic of an opinion |
deathschool
11.30.15 | Yeah, you may be right. Didn't realize it didn't have a source. That's my bad. But I'd say it seems like the general concensus. |
Futures
11.30.15 | my ears say no |
deathschool
11.30.15 | Well, it's debatable, and it doesn't really bother me that much. I just kinda figured that once Hep started commenting that they ain't the real thing, that everyone would either give up or start agreeing with him. So I thought I would pick up the torch. There isn't really definitive proof either way, so whatev |
Rawmeeth38
11.30.15 | real gangstas know 5 is the best here |
UnderTheNorthernScar
12.07.15 | La Dispute, Relationship of command, and moon |
Flugmorph
12.11.15 | updated this once more |
anarchistfish
12.11.15 | relationship of command, worship and tribute, daisy by brand new (i aint gonna shoehorn in tdag as post hardcore), no devolucion by thursday |
DungeonBoy
12.11.15 | Pianos Become the Teeth - The Lack Long after
Defeater - Travels
Touche Amore - Parting the Sea..
Thursday - No Devolucion |
Source
12.11.15 | Downward is Heavenward
Zen Arcade
For Your Own Special Sweetheart
Relationship of Command |
Flugmorph
12.12.15 | shoehorning in december |
Flugmorph
01.09.16 | wat |
BlueandOrange
01.09.16 | Letlive. - Fake History
Slint - Spiderland
Alexisonfire - Alexisonfire
Embrace - Embrace
|
KingdomOfTyrant
01.09.16 | spiderland
relationship of command
the shape of punk to come
Leaves Turn Inside You |
