Jane's Addiction
The Great Escape Artist


3.0
good

Review

by MassiveAttack USER (91 Reviews)
October 25th, 2011 | 24 replies


Release Date: 2011 | Tracklist

Review Summary: What becomes of 'The Great Escape Artist' is a absence of the noticeable hooks and joyous erratic moments Farrell once provided into a middling and sometimes dry experience that never quite reaches its potential.

At the forefront of Jane’s Addiction’s newest concoction, titled ‘The Great Escape Artist’, it becomes incessantly pushed in the back of everyone’s mind that Farrell & co. are shrouding their sound with electronic cloud amidst the traditional hooks of early 90s prominence. Much can be said the legacy of Jane’s Addiction, but the Farrell’s curios innuendos and Navarro’s guitar work are staples of their sound. Nonetheless, even with a far more straight-forward ‘Strays’, which still carried some semblance of those glory days within the band, it becomes painfully obvious Jane’s Addiction’s ‘The Great Escape Artist’ seems to have a lapse of judgment on what exactly it is striving for.

It’s regrettable that most of the work put into the album can be splendidly brought back to classics, but the veil that is over Navarro’s guitar work and Farrell’s panache is all but dubbed down to a middling affair of an album. We can’t be surprised though, after all Farrell is the man behind the band and his recent taste for newer, modern musical endeavors is evident throughout a tight 40-minutes of heavy electronic that becoming cyclic in nature and tiring in many aspects. Most of this album is consequently trapped under the very audible force. Seeking to crawl out of his hole, Navarro suffers the most, while the bass is considerably a highlight on here, much of the album lacks any type of energetic fervor ‘Strays’ incurred or even the memorable moments of their early 90s work. Navarro does get his moment upon the closer “Words Right Out of My Mouth,” but it is overdue and eventually unbecoming of the entire atmosphere of the rest of the album.

The band looks to be in a too comfortable position throughout, as if they’ve thought of this conventional modern sound and decided to sit back despite some surely to view it in pure contemns. ‘The Great Escape Artist’ is very much within that realm of inoffensive, un-sporadic moments. “Twisted Tales,” may be what the group was striving for and it’s lyrical past confessions of Parrell and his screams are a must within not only the song, but are needed to create a thorough Jane’s experience, yet it is nowhere to be found. Farrell sounds all too satisfied and Navarro seems practically missing with the sheath that covers over every track. Some will cringe, others will embrace the new direction, but it still aches for those subtle moments that are a dime a dozen. Muddled and in need of dire peculiarity of Farrell’s within the first half and some type aperture for Navarro to break out for most of the album, sadly it never quite happens, and ‘The Great Escape Artist’ turns into a “what-if” in the Jane’s Addiction discography.



Recent reviews by this author
Savages Silence YourselfMission of Burma Unsound
Clark IradelphicDoomtree No Kings
Gang of Four ContentNine Inch Nails Pretty Hate Machine: 2010 Remaster
user ratings (200)
3.1
good


Comments:Add a Comment 
mallen-
October 26th 2011


1245 Comments


Markooo, nice

MassiveAttack
October 26th 2011


2754 Comments

Album Rating: 3.0

Mallen...who may you be? MIKE! Hey, buddy.

Valerius
October 26th 2011


1137 Comments


I like JA so I'm biased. I doubt they ever top the first two albums unless they get Eric Avery back recording with them. His bass-work is pretty sick. I can't really disagree with you, but I do think this is better than Strays, though. I like the synth and depth of sound in this album.

greg84
Emeritus
October 26th 2011


7654 Comments

Album Rating: 3.8

Yeah. I don't really know why this album is getting such lukewarm reviews from critics. Great write-up nonetheless.

MassiveAttack
October 26th 2011


2754 Comments

Album Rating: 3.0

Well, honestly the murkiness of the whole thing really masks Farrell's work on here and Navarro isn't anywhere near where he should be. It's disappointing, but nonetheless a decent effort from a group that has been at it for quite some time.

Valerius
October 26th 2011


1137 Comments


I will agree on Navarro. I was expecting a bit more flash on the guitar. He comes through in places, though.

porch
January 13th 2012


8459 Comments


album's awful. broken people is the only semi-worthwhile track and even that sounds like a U2 ballad

Lalka
April 16th 2012


172 Comments

Album Rating: 2.5

can't get over the feeling of wasting my time while listening to this. no purchase.

DarthMarshall
August 16th 2012


22 Comments


Yes, the Zeppelin-esque bombast has been traded in for something more spacey and trippy, but it's just another angle on the fact that Farrell has always been a 70's love child.

Disagree with your opinion, because I really like the new direction, but I do think your review is very thoughtful and well written. Pos.

jayt851
December 17th 2012


413 Comments


People are gay on here. shut up!

anarchistfish
February 9th 2013


30298 Comments


Liking End To The Lies much more than I did when I first heard it over a year ago

Might have to give this a full listen after all

anarchistfish
February 9th 2013


30298 Comments


This doesn't read at all like a positive review

VermicideReloadead
February 9th 2013


1432 Comments


Not at the level of nothing shocking or ritual de lo habitual. Anyways, still has some good songs.

jefflebowski
February 9th 2013


8573 Comments

Album Rating: 3.0

lame compared to their classic stuff

anarchistfish
February 9th 2013


30298 Comments


The first three songs are great and then it kinda drops off

sinsexsodomy
March 29th 2013


263 Comments

Album Rating: 3.0

Good album, much better then their last.



ok I take this statement back, this album starts and ends well but most of the in between is terrible

claygurnz
January 16th 2017


7540 Comments

Album Rating: 2.5

Having recently got into this band and absolutely loving Nothing's Shocking and Ritual, it's disappointing that they couldn't translate that energy into similar results on this and Strays (although at least that album is fun). This has a few good moments but feels incredibly safe and middle of the road.

SitarHero
June 21st 2021


14697 Comments


Gotta say, Strays and this are incredibly underrated. This one especially.

Grungil
June 21st 2021


601 Comments


Safe album, not close to their 2 classics, but still better than 99% of what other alternative metal bands were doing around 2010.

SitarHero
June 21st 2021


14697 Comments


I dunno about safe necessarily. More streamlined perhaps, but I think that's actually good for and Farrell in particular. Less stream of consciousness and more melody focused. Plus, I think I like older Farrell's lower register more than his younger version's caterwauling. And the rest of the band's playing is still top notch.



You have to be logged in to post a comment. Login | Create a Profile





STAFF & CONTRIBUTORS // CONTACT US

Bands: A B C D E F G H I J K L M N O P Q R S T U V W X Y Z


Site Copyright 2005-2023 Sputnikmusic.com
All Album Reviews Displayed With Permission of Authors | Terms of Use | Privacy Policy