Review Summary: Pleasant country for casual listeners
Grew up playing this CD in my mom's car when it came out and long after. This is a great example of a modern country band with genuine personality without excessive over-dubs and country radio-friendly production (because those stations are so great right guys?).
On Bear Creek, Brandi Carlile proves that she is more than a one hitter (The Story) and showcases material that is both trendy and timeless, these lyrics could come from any contemporary cowboy rockstar without a second thought ("Keep Your Heart Young" and "Just Kids") and is simultaneously poetic and sometimes profound ("Hard Way Home", "Raise Hell" and "That Wasn't Me"). Despite initially not coming off very cerebral, there's a clear presence of heartfelt Americana within her approach to writing.
While the band is doing the absolute bare minimum during their studio time, they get the job done leaving zero complaints. I even saw them live with my mom and it was a great show. They're no E. Street Band, and certainly don't take risks like a Grateful Dead or Phish. However for a straightforward country act like Brandi, they're perfect. Some standout moments include "Rise Again" and "100" which include emotional undertones and amazing hooks and riffs.
"That Wasn't Me" is the song that truly defines this singer for its brilliant piano chord progression and structure. Her particular voice on this song remains unmatched on her other songs or albums. The genius of this song is in its vague relatability. Brandi wrote it describing her friend's struggle with addiction, but still incredibly relatable. Personally, it's difficult to connect with my family as important as they are to me. My job and schedules get in the way of valuable time and it brings a sense of shame because if your family loves you, time spent together is one of the most helpful and meaningful things that exist.
If you have already checked out Lucinda Williams and want something more, Bear Creek is the way to go.
