Quicksand is so good, I don't know why I didn't like them the 1st time I listened to them.

[QUOTE=REINER]Pat, strictly on musicianship, who is better Minor Threat or Metallica?[/QUOTE]

Metallica, see how easy that is?

[B]PELICAN!!!![/B]

If you don't like this band you're insane.

[QUOTE=40 oz 2 freedom]Metallica, see how easy that is?[/QUOTE]
See how incredibly wrong you are?

huh?

No way does Minor Threat have better musicianship than Metallica.

What?

Since when does being able to wank on a scale for 3 minutes mean better musicianship? You people need to learn there is more to music than just playing things as fast and as complicated as you can.

Yo, Metallica doesn't do that....

No I'm not saying they play better music, but musicianship is different.

They play better music with better musicianship. End of story.

I hate Metallica. They are nothing compared to other metal bands.

Metallica is a disgrace to thrash and metal in general. For good 80's thrash outside the big 4 (anthrax, megadeth, metallica, and slayer) check out testament, holy terror, and exodus.

anthrax and slayer are both great, but metallica and megadeth suck.

And let us not forget that dick lars.

[QUOTE=conniption]anthrax and slayer are both great, but metallica and megadeth suck.[/QUOTE]
i love megadeths old stuf. peace sells... but whos buying is a great album.

[QUOTE=conniption]anthrax and slayer are both great, but metallica and megadeth suck.[/QUOTE]
SLAYER = GOD.

[QUOTE=whiteminority]SLAYER = GOD.[/QUOTE]
No, not really. And I own most of their records. They are very good though.

anthrax used to be my favorite band, ever since 2000 when i played thps 2 and then picked up Sound of White Noise a couple days later.

Slayer is my favorite trash band, I don't know much trash though.

You can't say early Metallica isn't quality thrash.

I could never get into Megadeth.

the only metallica album i like is master of puppets, and it wasnt all that good, and megadeth is basically megadave, it is all centered on him. I just dont like their music as much.

[QUOTE=REINER]Slayer is my favorite trash band, I don't know much trash though.[/QUOTE]
Testament, Exodus, Holy Terror, and Voivod. Go download now.

Yeah, get the Bonded by Blood album from Exodus.

[QUOTE=NewKindofArmy03]You can't say early Metallica isn't quality thrash.

I could never get into Megadeth.[/QUOTE]
Master of Puppets is the best. I listen to it constantly when I get high with my brother.

[QUOTE=whiteminority]Master of Puppets is the best. I listen to it constantly when I get high with my brother.[/QUOTE]
FACE BREAK

well id have to be edge first to deserve a face break.

[QUOTE=whiteminority]well id have to be edge first to deserve a face break.[/QUOTE]
I'm just playin' braaaa

Reiner, I can barely tolerate any Metallica songs, but they're better musicians than Minor Threat. That's not putting down MT in any way, even they would say they aren't as good of musicians as metallica.

[QUOTE=.:~ Route 1 ~:.]I'm just playin' braaaa[/QUOTE]
just making sure you werent one of those crazy sXe nazis.

No, BUT I AM.

[QUOTE=40 oz 2 freedom]Reiner, I can barely tolerate any Metallica songs, but they're better musicians than Minor Threat. That's not putting down MT in any way, even they would say they aren't as good of musicians as metallica.[/QUOTE]
Brian Baker is just as good as metallica (I've watch videos of him playing, trust me), just because his bands don't show it doesn't mean it.

You need to learn that just because some bands have crazy solos and such doesn't make them superior song writers.

And you need to learn that bands you don't like can possibly be more talented than bands that you do like.

It doesn't, and I don't think anyone here thinks that, but Metallica are good songwriters.

I'd still take Minor Threat though, them being one of my favorite bands.

Talented as they can play faster?



You do realise this whole argument has been over opinions?

Who do you think is more influential, Minor Threat or Metallica?

Theyre both probably the biggest influences on their genres.

[QUOTE=whiteminority]just making sure you werent one of those crazy sXe nazis.[/QUOTE]
I'm actually thinking of going edge.....Idk, alot of messed up shi[I]t[/I] is going on with people I know and society. I don't want to be a part of a poisonous society.

Minor Threats easily, especially since they influenced bands from Metallica's genre.

I think Minor Threat is more influential. But in metal the most influential band is Black Sabbath. Every single band name drops Sabbath, Metallica is after them though.

Minor Threat > Metallica